upvote
Excepting any of the clean-room workarounds for the 10NES lockout chip, or the famous Game Genie case in Lewis Galoob Toys, Inc. v. Nintendo of America, Inc. (1992).

Camerica and Codemasters subsequently used voltage pulses to bypass the lock (parallels to the recent PS5 BIOS and Firmware bypasses) with things like the famous Micro Machines and Dizzy series being unlicensed. AVE's hilarious rubbish (the notorious Action 52 for example) and Wisdom Tree's religious shovelware do the same thing.

The reason why Tengen got slapped so publicly and severely is due to them acquiring the 10NES source code from the U.S. Copyright Office under false pretenses to do a non-cleanroom bypass of the NES10.

All of these arguments seem to be cyclical over the last 30 years. The difference now is that the barriers to entry for collective activism, domain specific knowledge, and legal research have been eradicated. I don't necessarily fancy Nintendo in this fight going forward.

reply
It's my understanding that Tengen engineers almost had a clean-room 10NES complete when others came in and brought them the dirt
reply
And yet communities like SMW central, devoted to Mario romhacks, have been around for 20 years without fail and Dolphin, a gc/wii emulator, is one of the best actively developed emulators.
reply
Dolphin specifically targets discontinued GameCube and Wii hardware, relies on free volunteer work to facilitate clean-room reimplementation to allow HLE, and avoids promoting piracy.

In contrast Yuzu were forced to a settlement due to relying on extracted cryptographic keys to run games, provided instructions on how to hack Switch consoles and illegally extract keys and game files, earned $30k/month on Patreon, and facilitated 1 million people playing Zelda:TOTK before its official release.

Cut and dry differences, with the Yuzu Scenario the better equivalent to the Picofly situation.

reply
US law is insane. Just to be clear - if I'm manufacturing hardware and I want no one to even make an unauthorized breath in its direction, I can just encrypt the firmware and from now on, the arbitrarily placed 'lock' makes the hardware mine and makes it a federal crime for the user to interact with my property in any way I have not explicitly approved?
reply
Many device manufacturers are already moving in this direction, yes
reply
Romhacks survive only because they distribute lean patch files that only include the changes that are applied by the user to a ROM file they already own, which ensures that romhack website owners never even touch the original data.
reply