upvote
One of the reasons we have abominations like DMCA is the phrase intellectual property.

The term "intellectual property" to refer to something protectable by copyright or patent is a mind virus. It isn't property. The length of time that you are granted a monopoly by the government over an invention or copyrightable work can be arbitrarily set by the government. Anywhere from a minute to 1000 years or beyond. That's not how any other property works. So stop calling it property. It is the grant of a monopoly to reward you for creating something that will, after a reasonable interval, become free for anyone to use. That's not how actual property works, and for good reasons.

reply
You have it backwards. The DMCA gives sites immunity from being sued themselves which was the custom and law before it. Nobody wanted to host anything. Being a host is a serious liability still in most of the world outside the US.
reply
It can be both. It allows hosting until someone looks at it harshly, because the protections against false claims are basically nothing.
reply
I've personally had DMCA abused against me to get projects taken down maliciously. Really part of the problem are providers that take down first and ask questions later. That was heroku, who not only took it down but acted like a complete asshole and treated me like a criminal when I reached out to tell them the complaint was nonsense. I just closed my account and moved providers.
reply
Not surprised. Heroku has big corproate customers now, I imagine they really don't care about small or personal sites.
reply