upvote
there is a lot more to rebuilding communities besides technology.

the whole social aspect. caring for others. not being selfish. trust.

the problem is that lack/failure of those is the reason for society collapsing in the first place.

so rather than learning how to preserve my own food i am interested in learning how to build good will, collaboration and consensus, especially in a diverse society.

reply
One phenomenon I’d not thought of until I encountered it, but that seems obvious in retrospect: in the immediate course of an exogenous shock (like natural disaster or war or large-scale social disruption), people tend to really come through for their neighbors [0].

The most reliable pattern seems to be a temporary burst of social cohesion. To the extent that durable negative social outcomes materialize, they tend to (1) roughly follow the contours of the same new material/social circumstances had they developed non-suddenly; and (2) take weeks and maybe months to overcome that initial swell of empathy.

In any case I agree that the human side is the important side—we owe a nod to communities like the Amish and religious orders who’ve done a lot of R&D into social cohesion technologies during blue skies!

[0] (e.g. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7115229/ and https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/028072709801600305 and many others in the genre)

reply
Re [0]; that does not seem relevant for the scale and scope of something that would require not just surviving, but also rebuilding society. What makes you think an extremely limited event with a pervasive sense and experiential assumption, of it being a temporary state, would lead you to believe that would convey to a large scale, permanent state where services and resource availability and supply not just break down, but remain so?

You really should maybe look into the censored version of what actually happened during hurricane Katrina. It has been intentionally and deliberately suppressed. Knowing the truth could not only mean the difference between life and death for everyone you care about, but makes all of these “survival guides” utterly useless and even dangerous because their assumptions are based on not just inaccuracy, but lies.

reply
Trade networks are far more important for rebuilding society than any of the above. Massive trade networks capable of moving goods thousands of miles.

The materials to run society don’t exist all in one place and except for the recyclable metals that are available in bulk in most urban environments and lumber mills which are relatively well distributed, people are going to start running out of basics really fast and society will never get off the ground.

The ones who have the best chance at survival are ironically the billion or so subsistence farmers in poverty who are largely excluded from the modern economy anyway.

reply
Absolutely. Abstracted it's epistemology. We've spent a lot of time thinking about how to think over the ages, and it's served us pretty well.
reply
Tight-knit religious groups will do really well in a catastrophic event. The trust is hard to duplicate outside of maybe the military or similar orgs. Even Mormons have prepping built into their lifestyle.
reply
The vast majority of us in the first world would be completely Incapable of the back breaking labor required to rebuild society. Days span 12 hours plus, all family members must participate and few can lean back and take the labor of others in the initial stages.

There is also a number of people who would chose to be violent to fight for the scraps of before rather than build what the future requires.

And if you think you’re up to it, you’re probably wildly over estimating yourself.

reply
Two scenarios:

1) The collapse happens slowly over time, as a slow degradation of services. You'd have decades to adapt.

2) The collapse happens all at once. Almost everyone dies, because there's not enough food and water to go around.

Also, the people fighting over scraps would be the gangsters and warlords. It would be thugs and homicidal teenagers, not middle age former software engineers. We'd be like Ethiopia.

I guess it's possible to form common defense collectives among likeminded people, but I think the more likely outcome is we'd be cowtowing to the local warlord and paying him for our protection. If we didn't die early.

reply
Open Source Ecology had such great promise, but Marcin got high on his own supply. It's effectively abandonware at this point. I can haz such disappoint.
reply
I've been interested in this project for a long time. I'd like to go visit someday. I was wondering if you could say more about this.

I see a reddit discussion from a year ago mention (and I recall) the website/wiki being poorly laid out with actual CAD files difficult to find. Seems they could have used some help on that end.

Why not fork the project if the leadership failed? I see some links to an offshoot in Germany that might have gotten farther:

https://www.ose-germany.de/die-bewegung/

reply
I was fascinated by it when it first came to light, but my understanding is that they seemed to suffer from ADHD, conflicting incentives, and founder's syndrome.

I had an AI synthesize a doc on the issues: https://share.google/aimode/uT3tYdwHz1tMwQypt

reply