upvote
Couldn't agree more. Before we even talk about how to rebuild society, we should spend far more time talking about how to prevent societal collapse in the first place.

This should be so much more important and universally embraced, but it doesn't let you buy cool gadgets and LARP as a movie character.

However, assuming society already has collapsed, you're going to have a much bigger problem organizing (and defending against other organizations of) your neighbors, than you will trying to build a rain barrel.

reply
LOL.

"Betty the bombs just dropped. We need to get to the shelter. Thank god I read that chapter on how to de-escalate and manage the group 7 years ago, now we won't die. Despite living a life in a fully integrated world civilization and having never tried out any of our survival equipment or food, our 3 months of rice is going to make the difference because I know how to de-escalate whenever the starving people with guns pull up."

I agree though, a print library is probably more valuable to whatever survivors eventually turn up to look through your stuff.

reply
The de-escalation is for when you come back out of the shelter and there are other survivors you have to interact with. If starving people with guns pull up, you could potentially convince them to let you join. Bigger groups are stronger.

Despite what the Walking Dead would have you believe, it won't be total anarchy and looting. Neighbors will work together and support each other against outsiders. Groups will coalesce and co-operate. Humans are social, tribal creatures. We automatically form societies and tribes, especially during a calamity.

reply
> If starving people with guns pull up, you could potentially convince them to let you join.

You think that if you read a book about de-escalation you will talk your way out of giving up all your stuff to starving survivors in a post apocalypse?

> Neighbors will work together and support each other against outsiders.

Do all your neighbors have enough food to survive? Are you going to have enough to feed all of them? After 5 days with no food your neighbors will take whatever you have, and kill you if that is what they have to do to get your food. They might cry afterward, but they will do it.

> Humans are social, tribal creatures. We automatically form societies and tribes, especially during a calamity.

Your argument is you will be safe because humans are tribal. That argument works all the time, so why aren't people safe all the time? People around the world are safe more or less exactly in proportion to how well fed their neighbors are. If your neighbors are starving you are not safe, no matter how nice they are when they have a full stomach.

reply
Their argument is actually that tribal skills are really important.

For instance, convincing your neighbors to be ready for problems before the problems. That builds your social capital as well as prevents them from starving before you do.

reply
> You think that if you read a book about de-escalation

Well I'd be better off than if I didn't read the book. Learning social skills and negotiation in real life is way more important obviously.

> Do all your neighbors have enough food to survive?

My neighbors would have food because I would share and so would they. And then we'd work out something to find or grow more food. Maybe, if it's really dire, we'd form our own looting band. Either way fighting each other would be disastrous for all of us long-term. Maybe survive together or definitely die alone.

> After 5 days with no food your neighbors will kill you for whatever you have.

Is that what you'd do if you were that neighbor? If yes, I'm sorry to tell you that you aren't normal.

If they kill me, who's going to stand with them when unfriendly people from outside the neighborhood show up?

> Your argument is you will be safe because humans are tribal. That argument works all the time, so why aren't people safe all the time?

People mostly are safe. You can walk down the street with virtually zero fear of getting stabbed. Or I don't know, maybe you're just a naturally fearful person. I'm not.

reply
You're not going to rebuild society hiding in a bunker. Society requires more than one person.
reply