upvote
Agreed. We don't need a magic box that sits on the shelf and can ostensibly tell us how to make life-saving medication for ourselves when the day comes that society can no longer make it for us. We need hobbies that involve practicing the requisite skills so that when that day comes it is not only accessible in principle, but familiar in practice.
reply
I never let my kids say they cant do something. It is always they cant do something yet.

The more you practice the better you get. If you did home improvement you would get better at it.

If you wouldnt expect to be able to code at one try Im not sure why you would expect to be good at home improvement in one try.

reply
Yeah ppl will always improve but there is a time cost for all these.
reply
kids have a lot of time.
reply
I keep telling my youngest kid the same thing, but it's not working. No idea where that attitude comes from.
reply
My theory is that a form of the Curse of the Gifted (child) applies to every young person now.

Children who excel at schooling for an extended amount of time tend to categorize the world into things that are easy (most challenges they face) and relatively impossible, as a behavioral optimization. Granted, this affects young people who are above average talent (maybe in a single vector), who are merely above-average or are temporarily developmentally above the curve. Sometimes they are humbled to learn that it's an ephemeral state, while still in grade school.

Amazing and capability extending things are easily learned through the use of technology today, which misleads children to fall into this same behavior at all levels.

Institutionalized fear of failure paired with laziness. At least, that's my best guess.

reply
I’ve always understood this is the real purpose of sports. It teaches children to lose and that there is always someone better than you. And if there isn’t you’re likely skilled enough to learn that you can see how to improve at a task yourself.
reply
And yet, my son has had and overcome tons of challenges in his life. He's had language development problems, dyslexia, simply being able to do his work at school, and he has overcome them all. If anyone should know that anything he's bad at, he can still learn, it should be him.
reply
It’s in the personality I think, or gene. My son has it too, which definitely comes from us. You just need to use a different way to encourage. Or maybe they just don’t want and you have to wait.
reply
Does he see you openly learn?

People learn from your example, not from your advice. Particularly for children.

reply
Agreed, and being willing to fail. I'm fairly handy, but I failed at a ton of small projects many times and/or built/repaired things to a less than ideal quality level before getting better at it. So half the battle is being willing to try and fail to continue to build skills and get better.
reply
Your comment made me think that a carpenter simulator would be useful for learning different techniques and processes used by pros. Looks like such things exist. It wouldn't build muscle in the same way real work would. While less satisfying than finishing a real object I see great value in learning base skills in a no risk, no material cost, simulated environment.
reply
I missed out, but I know several people who earned the rank of Eagle Scout in the Boy Scouts that have many practical skills.
reply
..anybody have thoughts on the Boy Scouts?
reply
Yes, this is key.

I've seen a few "terminally online" friends try to saw a stick in half with a reciprocating saw and nearly take their fingers off.

Having 10 GB of PDFs about how to do stuff is probably like 0.1% of successful homesteading.

At the very minimum I think every person should be able to understand how to start a fire, filter some water, and maybe build a shelf or something (or a rudimentary shelter). No need to be super fancy.

reply