upvote
Instead of the sun heating the earth directly, part of suns energy is used to generate electricity, which then heats the air. This is about net zero.
reply
That seems simple but SP absorbs more energy than the earth which reflects it. Putting dirt on your roof is zero sum (some does), or mirrors (snowy roofs does the job too)
reply
that depends on absorption and emission spectrums
reply
The sunlight was going to heat the planet anyways.
reply
This is a silly take. If you use solar-derived electrical energy to move hear gained by solar heating from inside outside, you are not increasing the amount of heat gained from the sun. It’s literally solar energy all around.
reply
You are converting light to heat. The whole issue of climate change is that more light is converted into other frequencies and heat, which then doesn't leave the planet as much anymore.
reply
Light is anyway converted to heat (except maybe if you use a mirror).
reply
Solar panels have a drastically lower albedo than the surfaces they sit on. You know, because we want to actually capture that sunlight and turn it into electricity instead of reflecting it back out of the atmosphere.
reply
Common asphalt shingles don't seem to be better than panels. But sure, if you're building a new roof, might as well use high albedo material/finish.

But what about panels over empty land? Claude with my simpleton prompting says panels win over grass -- grass albedo isn't that high (0.25 vs 0.07), panels offset it with generated electricity (unless your grid is wind/hydro/no waste heat source).

reply
Obviously, yes, solar panels are a net win vs. burning fossil fuels. I’m simply pointing out that solar isn’t totally free in that we end up capturing more solar input than we otherwise would.

That said I think in practice it is pretty close to free. My own numbers show that if the Earth’s landmass were entirely grass, and we entirely replaced it with solar panels, it would be equivalent to roughly doubling atmospheric CO2 in terms of retained heat energy. Powering all of civilization would require less, and only be a few hundredths of watts per square meter.

reply
deleted
reply