upvote
> It's more like a war or pandemic that leaves half the population dead and society broke down

Half the population dead is still a doomsday scenario especially for a technological civilization. We are far more dependent on others than we were the last time any society saw that scale of death. If you're thinking it would only take a decade or two to recover then I'd revise the estimate to maybe 10% of people killed. Those are heavy losses even for combat but not unrecoverable if that's the extent of the death toll. 50% dead would get ugly really quickly. A lot of critical information and skill would be lost and you'd be short half the workforce needed to operate things the way they're set up. Sure, there'd be less people and less demand for necessities but there'd probably be a lot more emergencies to deal with due to nothing working the way it should and everything being harder to accomplish.

Think how that would affect just fire departments as an example. Crew is only cut in half if you're lucky, maybe they're all gone if they are needed at home. More places are abandoned or unattended so fires that start get out of control. A lot of things are being done by people who are inexperienced or don't have the right skills or who are overloaded with additional work so more accidents are going to happen, electrical fires, car accidents, heavy machinery accidents, house fires caused by improvised cooking methods if there are blackouts, maybe even intentional arson.

That's only a fire department but everything would be affected. How do nuclear power plants fare with half the engineers and technicians to operate them? How do factories operate when half of the people who knew how to make new injection molds are dead? or the people who service the machines and equipment? what happens to medicine when half the surgeons die before they can pass on their skills? and so on for everything.

reply
Even a nuclear winter would not stop solar panels, it would reduce their output
reply
Don't nuclear blasts produce powerful EMPs?
reply
"Yes, we know a nuclear explosion will generate an electromagnetic pulse (EMP), which, depending on the circumstances, could disrupt certain electronic equipment, but the doom and gloom scenarios will not happen. That stuff belongs in Hollywood,” he says."

https://www.lanl.gov/media/publications/national-security-sc...

reply
Most neighborhoods are not net zero. Most homes are near neighbors.

If you have extra power from your not-destroyed solar panels, it's better to use that power so your neighbor has refridgeration, than to run an LLM.

reply