upvote
>If Apple gave the user unconditional control of their own devices, they wouldn't be able to comply with these orders.

They could be trivially given orders not allowing them to sell devices where users "have unconditional control" too, so it's not like that's a magic technical solution that bypasses the legal/political demands.

reply
Nothing is forcing the user to use iCloud
reply
Can we please just cut this kind of stereotypical, childish response from HN discussion?

Presumably you want to use this device with literally any online service, who is still subject to the laws of the governments under which they reside. Presumably you want to install software on this device which must abide by the laws of the governments under which you reside. Presumably you want to purchase this device from a store which has to comply with the laws of the governments under which they operate.

The central issue here is the government, and that is something the people can change if they care enough.

If you want to totally own the phone and software you can: buy a Librem. But for god’s sake please stop constantly whining that other companies don’t all offer products under the exact obscure and unpopular terms you specifically demand.

reply
The comment is very reasonable.

The tech companies do above and beyond what is legally required to make their customers accessible.

Prior to TCNs Apple was going to scan icloud anyway. It does indicate at least some integrity that they changed plans and refused to decrypt ADP.

Encryption is legal in many countries. Not in the UK of course. But in countries where encryption is legal, it is the decision of OpenAI, Microsoft etc, to keep data unencrypted. Certainly this is very bad for the user.

reply
Historically Apple has not gone above and beyond. They have done the opposite and actively worked to close multiple loopholes that governments have used and could in the future have used to demand access to customer data.
reply
Apple is commendable for that. You can surely see the point I am making.

Inference is the main example. The AI companies can implement attestation. They can entirely legally have no knowledge of customer prompts, with minimal infrastructure costs.

They only refuse because they want to go beyond the law, they want to enforce the law themselves and need the data to be accessible.

reply
Could you please stop name calling?
reply
Nobody is name-calling. I called the comment childish, and I believe it is. It is perfectly okay to separate an individual from the inevitably flawed and imperfect way they carry themselves, as we are all subject to do.
reply