upvote
Those aren't mutually exclusive... it's good that these bugs are getting fixed, but each critical severity bug that gets fixed is a headache for all of us who administer servers.
reply
I see the Kessler Syndrome play out at work.
reply
Are you implying that patching vulnerabilities will lead to more vulnerabilities? How so?
reply
Not necessarily more vulnerabilities, but I think the fear is that the continuous churn of security patches will lead to increased instability and reduced availability.

Security patch intentionally or inadvertently removes a behavior that systems X and Y depend on, so they must be fixed, and then that change cascades to dependent systems A, B, C, and D. And some of those changes will be incorrect and introduce new vulnerabilities and the cycle of life continues..

reply
You're seeing bugs get band-aided. Clanker-generated band-aids for clanker-surfaced issues aren't necessarily a proper fix, and may even be a step backwards if they introduce new issues.
reply
this bug was introduced by clankers most likely...
reply
likely based on what
reply
- version 4 got released this year

- mid 2025 a lot of people appeared contributing out of nowhere

- https://github.com/openssl/openssl/pull/29178 this rewrote the code for base64 - you can delve into it to check if this was human generated.

reply
That contributor is definitely a vibe coder these days; just look at their profile's readme: https://github.com/Nick-Nuon, the only place I have ever seen that emoji list style where every bullet point starts with an emoji is from chat bots, but chat bots really really like it.

I don't see any obvious tells from the code diff though, I would've expected chatbot code to be more commented and nothing immediately stands out.

The commit messages and PR description don't read at AI-generated at all, there are small typos and grammatical issues. For example, the sentence "Originally, the OpenSSL base64 encoding kernel includes a buffer of ctx->length" confuses word tense a bit, correct grammar would've said "Originally, the OpenSSL base64 encoding kernel included ...". Chat bots are terrible at writing but typically impeccable when it comes to word tense and spelling.

reply
Good to see that I'm not alone in seeing very weird things there - I also don't think it was vibecoded (back then, Claude wasn't there yet...) but they surely used an LLM (the passage you mentioned likely can easily be produced by pointing the LLM at 2 folders... - also scripts outputting emojis are a tell imo...).

I guess the PR back then was a bit of a CV-padding action, where they integrated their research into a widely used OSS-project. That the project maintainers just accepted this in good faith (tbh the PR is better than the last vibecoder I saw pushing into a rust-numerics projects: "enable AVX only on AMD because my broken 10 y.o. Intel clocks down when executing AVX...") bodes ill that our shared infrastructure survives this in usable "shape".

reply