upvote
When making such strong claims that could easily devolve into semantics, it would be valuable to explain what you understand to be the definition of the semantic fulcrum of the claim.

In this case, that semantic fulcrum is what it means to '''understand''' something. Because the question of whether Claude understands things hinges much more on the criteria for understanding, than it does on our belief on the capabilities that Claude has.

reply
Sure, I was mostly saying that to be a bit adversarial. I will say though that claude has had much less RL in certain areas, such that an explanation of e.g. why FTL travel violated causality is mostly remixing answers that are in the training data rather than a serious effort to facilitate understanding.
reply