upvote
Besides, the claim on magnetic force already serves as a counter-example to the main claim of the article.

Unless the article means to say that Feynman didn't understand the magnetic force, they have to admit that the magnetic force was perfectly understood, but impossible to explain in simple terms.

reply
I think Feynman might have been referring to how spin was not understood (even by him), and magnetism is a result of a bunch of little spins adding up. I mean—even today—there are not really explanations that are correct and also understandable by a freshman. There's the belt analogy but, well, it doesn't really explain the physics.
reply
That's not how I read it. Feynman started with the story of a girl going to the hospital because she broke something after slipping on ice. His point was that you can only explain things in terms that you simply accept without further explanation, otherwise you'd keep asking "why". Then he muses about imagining little rubber bands between magnets, but those only have their property in the end because of electromagnetism, so it's a circular explanation and thus unsatisfactory. To him, the magnetic field and its properties simply are, there is nothing underneath it.
reply
> ... simple terms

Didn't Feynman mean "layman terms" when he muses how he doesn't quite know how to begin to explain magnetism to his interviewer (but goes about doing so in 'simple' terms, anyway)?

reply
I would agree that there is a degree of survivor bias in Feynman’s context for that statement. You’ve survived the cull to incoming physics undergrad, which is always has some casualties. You have the potential to be interesting, and therefor worth bringing into the fellowship. You’re not an idiot, but you are ignorant and simple explanations do best to address that distinction.

These understandings and their accidental complexity also often inform composition of many distinct concepts into a solution to a complex problem. The brain must bear the burden of most of them simultaneously, even if you outsource the finer points to specialized teams during execution.

reply
I think of learning as layers and depending on where the scientist is and the receivers are, there can be a huge mismatch in understanding. The difference between simple terms and familiar terms is why I can’t take the article as a rule or reference in life.
reply