upvote
It’s not even an explanation. How do calories translate to mass? What about water weight? You can lose weight a lot faster by dehydration than by calorie deficit!
reply
Calories are saved by body into fat cells. You can initially lose few pounds of water weight then it stops. So, you cannot really keep on losing water weight for several weeks, after first few weeks it will stop.

Here's the proof of a calorie deficit working: https://i.ibb.co/F41dPj99/e53d5859da28.png

Each row in the table is a week.

reply
A calorie is a unit of energy, a fat cell is made up of matter. How does a fat cell store calories?

Remember, you’re explaining to a five-year-old. You can’t stop a five-year-old from digging deeper and deeper. They aren’t discouraged by hand-wavey explanations.

reply
deleted
reply
deleted
reply
The interesting thing about weight loss is, that it happens mostly via breathing:

https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/287046

reply
That would be an oversimplification.
reply
That depends entirely on the context. Within the bounds of how weight loss typically comes up, calorie deficit is indeed the simplest answer, and the best starting point to learn the rest on your own. That its over simplified misses the point a little bit. An adequately reductive explanation must account for both a comprehensive understanding of the subject matter and also an understanding of the context within which it is presented, to be any good. That is why its a great rubric for how well one understands something.

It is not intended to be anything more than a mental model for evaluating how well people you don't know understand something you don't understand yourself.

reply
> How does weight loss work?"

> Calorie Deficit

Trying to change mass by reducing energy, that might be the very most simple explanation of why calorie counting is misguided.

reply
It's neither simple nor correct explanation.

The more correct one would be pointing out that humans aren't dumb matter-to-energy converters. For many people, the body will happily down-clock quite hard in response to a calorie deficit; for others, it'll create irresistible psychological urges to fight the limit.

I'd probably go towards scenarios: imagine the body is a block of flats, and the municipal government decides for some reason to cut the city heating allocation for the block by half during a harsh winter.

Things that will happen include some combination of desired outcomes (people improving insulation, replacing radiators with newer ones, closing windows more) and undesired outcomes (people losing jobs and staying home and not paying bills, people starting fires indoors, tapping infrastructure to direct more heating to themselves, sabotaging neighbors, outright threatening or murdering neighbors to take their fuels, going out to the streets and rioting or attacking neighboring buildings or city council, etc.).

There's probably a simpler explanation to give, but I currently don't know an example of "self-regulating system" that most normies would understand. "Homeostasis" would be a perfect term, because it's something kids are taught about in primary education - unfortunately, as far as I know, most adults have no first clue what it means.

reply
You do not need to "speculate" on how TDEE (total calorie burn of the day) changes in response to a deficit; we've documented it here:

https://i.ibb.co/HThyPcSX/f0b1704b2cf3.png

https://i.ibb.co/vCFYB87j/7ee73cd7ce4d.png

method of maintenance tracking: https://macrocodex.app/knowledge/rethink/adaptive-tdee/#macr...

reply
Yes. And we're not even considering whether weight loss is beneficial for everyone.

There will be so many studies at population level of how lower BMI correlates with people overall healthier, but that doesn't guarantee that slightly obese people would get healthier through weight loss.

Yes, none of it simple.

reply
Energy is stored in the body chemically, so why should more output mass than input mass not lead to a reduce in body mass?
reply
It's misguided, but it works reliably on every human. If you are not losing weight you haven't reduced calories enough. If you don't lose weight on zero calories for a year you are lying.

Also, (simplified) mass is a form of energy, so I am not following how that assessment would explain the fault with the approach.

reply
Why not jump to a more simple theory of mass in/mass out then? Why care about calories at all, especially as they're not a biological unit either ?

Trying to actually and reliably measure what happens on food intake at an individual level is near impossible anyway, so keeping the explanation simple would be a step in some direction IMHO.

reply
Because drinking a kilogram of melted ice cream is not the same as drinking a kilogram of water. One of them has zero calories, the other does not.
reply