upvote
I think you're missing his argument. Claude is a tool, not a person. It's just as counterproductive to anthropomorphize my hammer as it is to anthropomorphize an LLM.
reply
Claude is a tool, but recent evidence suggests that it is also intelligent. Your hammer does not exhibit intelligence.

Note: I'm not anthropomorphizing anything. I think the best description of Claude right now is that it is an alien, non-human mind.

reply
I have no problem in accepting that LLMs are vastly more intelligent than humans in many areas already, but to me the concept of mind involves "beingness" and maybe even sentience, and I don't believe at all that these machines have any of that.

"Alien" is an acceptable term in the sense that these things reason in some very different ways than we do, but due to cultural norms, to me it also brings up notions of beingness. The xenomorphs in the alien movies, vile (and fictitious) as they may be, have a certain ontological quality that the LLMs do not.

reply
I think your position is reasonable, but even if you're right, the "mere stochastic parrot" position doesn't hold water anymore.
reply
I've personally never held that position. I always thought that even in the minimalist case for AI, "stochastic parrots" would have mind-bending implications for our understanding of verbal reasoning. I think that we're well past refuting the minimal case from a couple of years ago, anyway.
reply
Be specific, in what sense has the actual method of action of LLMs changed, according to your understanding?
reply
I don’t think it has changed. The difference is in the model size, complexity, and weights.
reply
AI is a swarm of stochastic parrots, meaning they use pattern matching as their guide. With enough number of such parrots we apparently get an alien form of intelligence. In other words, don't underestimate stochastic parrots.
reply