upvote
No one but people who own crypto will care about it if modern cryptography is broken. I think most people will be too preoccupied by the "all data sent over the internet can now be decrypted and read by anyone" problem. We're talking about a breakdown of all internet-connected systems, anything controlling secure and sensitive infrastructure, disruption of almost all manufacturig, shipping and logistics worldwide, the leak of all identities, secrets and communications, and likely downstream mass societal unrest and wars.
reply
>We're talking about a breakdown of all internet-connected systems

No, that is false. Loss of existing confidentiality, yes. There are other ways to prove integrity without primes, such as Vernam ciphers.

reply
Even if there are alternate ways to achieve secrecy, the publication of something that takes down the current encryption paradigms would still have the effects I mentioned. It would take months for everything to transition to a different scheme, by which time everything important will have already leaked. And that's not to mention all the encrypted data that's being saved now to be decrypted once the algorithm is broken. With how much we integrated the internet into everything, it would be a civilization-wide disaster.
reply
Brother, if cryptography is broken, cryptocoins are the least of our worries....
reply
It really isn't. We had the clacky copiers in the 80s and 90s with paper checks and everyone ate and slept and drove to work just fine.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_card_imprinter

reply
Not sure I understand the argument here. Having to abruptly switch back to such a system from the current one would be catastrophic.
reply
Exactly, and it's incredibly unlikely, that in the event this did happen, it wouldn't be preceded by massive amounts of pain. There's no world in which society says, ohhh cryptography might be broken, let's go back to pen and paper for ledgers, exchange, etc. Even though we tend to classify crypto as it's own thing, the entire traditional finance system at this point is digital for the most part. All of it is going to have a bad time if cryptography is broken.
reply
My point is knowing where primes are doesn't destroy digital comms, it just stops the ability to fully trust data on public lines. We had decades of sending and storing financial, medical, and all other sensitive info fully unencrypted; we would certainly do it again if we had to.
reply
OK I laughed.

And actually, come to think of it it in more serious terms: we'll adapt.

It'd be pretty hilarious if what AI implied all along is that we all had to touch grass and exchange copper coin.

reply