upvote
> The proof should stand or fall on its own.

At some point in the chain an "authority" has to validate whether the proof stands or falls.

reply
sure, still wouldn't trust the guy who wrote the proof to verify it though, which is what this person is asking.
reply
Of course it has to. Its not about that, its about whether or not to get excited. I think we can start to get excited.
reply
Appeals to authority are not inherently fallacious if the individual is, indeed, an authority on the topic at issue.

To the contrary: we lean on authority opinion in most spheres of life because one individual's ability to understand is limited and so we abstract away "true" in auxiliary fields to mean, roughly, "held to be true by trusted authorities". We even rely on it in law.

reply
He's saying that it isn't right automatically because he said so. It adds significant credibility that the proof is correct compared to me saying I did it but the proof itself is what matters (at least to most people)
reply
Just like when Andrew Wiles discovered the proof to fermat last theorem and Grigori Perelman with the poincaré conjecture, multiple authorities in the field got together and verified that the proofs were correct (even after Wiles initially had an error.)

An appeal to multiple trusted authorities is better than a singular authority. So at best I'll keep as unverified until it is checked, unless you have read the 250,000 proof and checked that there is no issues or soundness bug with the lean proof.

reply
They are inherently fallacious as in logically unsound. There is no connection between his credentials and him being right about this particular thing.

It's very important to keep those things separate.

reply

    They are inherently fallacious as in logically unsound.
At the risk of triggering an infinite regression (or logic loop), the redoubtable Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy's page on fallacies provides the following (https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/fallacies/):

    The ad verecundiam fallacy concerns appeals to authority or expertise. Fundamentally, the fallacy involves accepting as evidence for a proposition the pronouncement of someone who is taken to be an authority ***but is either not really an authority or a relevant authority***.
Once more, I would point you to the fact that even the legal profession-- which is fundamentally one of the most epistemologically pure fields-- spefically allows the opinion of those deemed "authorities" to be submitted as evidentiary.

See: https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/fre/rule_702

Without an epistemology that allows integrating truth-by-authority, you by necessity need to prove every assertion from first principals. Have you done so?

reply
Very interesting sir. Thank you for this exposition.

But I do not see how this changes the notion that being an authority does not turn your arguments sound or even valid. There is nothing to connect. I can be an expert and completely wrong and there is nothing epistemology can do for you there.

The legal profession is taking a shortcut like the CS profession is taking a shortcut with the halting problem. Sure, we can end the discussion that way but we cannot use it as an argument otherwise.. halting problem solved, just press control-C?

reply
You can't even contribute to math at this level without an advanced degree (cranks and delusional people notwithstanding). So maybe I should clarify I mean "authority" as in someone with high repute among his colleagues.

If we were all factory technicians, and Max has the best record among us at fixing the machine, that doesn't mean his word is final. "Max said so" is an appeal to authority. We are all capable of reading the documentation and performing our own repairs, and sometimes Max can be wrong.

reply
obviously the claim is about how much credence to assign the claim until the proof has been verified
reply
>fallacy

It doesn't make it right, but more importantly to people who always quote every known fallacy: it doesn't make it wrong either. We shall see, empirically how it goes.

But it is highly relevant whether this is some crank on an Internet forum posting proofs about infinity-hat or someone with some credentials, even if that framing was a bit hyperbolic.

Which is another thing: sometimes people aren't really making an argument as such, so quoting fallacies is just on purpose low bandwidth English comprehension.

reply
It's not about whether the claim right or wrong. "Fallacy" doesn't mean "a function that always returns false". It means it employs flawed reasoning. Saying "$SUPER_COOL_GUY claimed it" (implying it must be true) is a thought-terminating phrase. It's saying "don't scrutinize or question. Trust that he's the authority on these things. For only a fool would attempt to contravene his infinite wisdom.". That logic is absolutely flawed.

Even Einstein was incorrectly critical about some quantum physics properties. Who would dare tell Einstein, the master of relativity and spacetime, that he was wrong? How could he possibly be wrong when it comes from the man who gave us the most famous math equation in history?

reply
Yes, that's right, but proof checking does take time and effort. For an initial announcement, the fact that they are a well regarded mathematician means that it's worth taking seriously and not that it's definitely correct. If it's someone unknown, then you'd definitely be waiting for the proof to be checked before talking about it.
reply
That is why it is still a "claim" of a proof, until other mathematicians verify it.

Not saying it is incorrect but, all claims of mathematical proofs have to be checked over formally regardless of who discovered it.

With this particular mathematician it just means it should be taken seriously but you cannot blindly believe it is correct without multiple authorities testing that there are no holes in the proof, just like they did with FLT and the poincare conjecture.

reply