upvote
You're saying Claude had a great time because humans have a great time and it might be possible to model humans in software?
reply
I'm saying that Claude being software is not a definitive argument against Claude having subjective experience, because it might be possible in principal to model humans in software.

Pointing out that Claude lacks internal temporality, a observe/check/act loop, memory, non-virtual experience and therefore can't have a great time would be a much sounder argument.

reply
What’s the subjective experience of gradient descent? Bubble sort? Does ‘y’ feel left out all by its lonesome in y = ax + b?
reply
What's the subjective experience of a neuron? Action potential? Does a calcium ion feel left out by its lonesome in the voltage-gated channel?
reply
> You do know that humans also have a physical substrate?

Lmao

Edit, because this is mean without context: Your comment is essentially the following meme:

> Person who has never worked with anything but computers in their lives: 'Hmm, this brain looks an awful lot like a computer.'

reply
It is true that I am not a neuroscientist but I don’t think that the substrate being software vs chemical is a priori a reason to rule out subjectivity. I think there are other things missing from the current LLMs, (particularly time, inference time chemical feedbacks or electromagnetic feed backs, continuous training, memory, non linguistic thought, etc.), but not the deterministic and formalizable nature of the system. I would not be surprised if something made of software running on some sort of manufactured computation devices did have subjectivity in the future.
reply
You're leaving out the most important bit, which is consciousness, and this is harder to crack than inventing time machines ^^. At least time machines are amenable to science and we kinda have a vague idea of what time is. Consciousness OTOH, is so fundamentally subjective that we can't do science on it by definition.

Of course this is only a problem if consciousness is a significant part of being intelligent, but we don't really know yet.

reply
This is just a bunch of nerd shit sophistry being used to equivocate humans with software. That's a bad take, Claude's a program, it doesn't have feelings no matter what the weird Bay Area sex cult tells us.
reply
I don't think Claude has feelings, but not because it's software, but because it's too simply constructed to capture subjectivity (tho that's a tough claim as we haven't got a precise idea of what subjectivity nor of what is required for it to emerge).
reply