upvote
My instincts are very similar on all points.

To push back, or share the self-pushbacks I grapple with...

> In contrast, generative AI ("creative" AI writing, illustrating, music, etc) is a pox on civilization. It is industrialized low-effort plagiarism that harms artists' livelihoods, discourages new art, makes everything bland, and pollutes the world in multiple senses of the word. I hope it dies from a combination of negative sentiments, and too much real-world cost once token subsidies go away.

While this summarizes my feelings on the current versions (which, say, are roughly at or below the math olympiad stage in writing, video, etc), what happens when they actually become good? Meaning, an AI show that was actually as good as The Wire? To the point you couldn't tell the difference without being told?

I really want to say that even then it won't be the same, because the human provenance is essential to the art, but if I truly couldn't tell the difference...

reply
> While this summarizes my feelings on the current versions (which, say, are roughly at or below the math olympiad stage in writing, video, etc), what happens when they actually become good? Meaning, an AI show that was actually as good as The Wire? To the point you couldn't tell the difference without being told?

But here we're dipping into science fiction again. This is not currently the case, and we seem a long way from it.

reply
> and we seem a long way from it.

We're dipping into prediction. But we have the (seemingly relevant, at least) data point that we're in the same situation w.r.t. writing/art as we were w.r.t. to math a couple years ago...

reply
To an extent, sure, but:

- There was progress on maths that led to this point, whereas it's been stalled on art for the same reasons since the beginning.

- Art doesn't lend itself as well to the 'add more agents/complexity' strategy; a 250,000 word limerick is a terrible limerick.

reply
> what happens when they actually become good? Meaning, an AI show that was actually as good as The Wire? To the point you couldn't tell the difference without being told?

Perhaps this comment will make me look silly one day, but my guess is that we'll eventually get there, and a handful of AI-generated productions will truly shine. But "as good as" is an important phrase. Because current-generation AI is trained on existing art, it won't be pushing many envelopes, it'll mostly be remixing what we have, and that will grow stale.

After a few breakout hits with broad shared appeal, I think the novelty will wear off, and AI produced TV and cinema will be too resource-intensive to remain as a profitable going enterprise. There will likely be a short window of hyper-personalized media that will seem very exciting, until we grow weary of the isolation of it. For many people, half the fun of watching a thing is discussing it with other humans, and today's streaming media landscape already leaves many people unmoored from that shared experience.

There is also the question of intentionality. When AI creates that show as good as The Wire, is that because AI has something to say about the human condition? If not, what's the point? If so, should we be paying attention to what AI wants us to pay attention to?

reply
So what if AI slop wasn't slop? If you care about the details and the values behind your work enough to make it actually good, you won't use gen AI or use it invisibly because it concedes control of the details.

If you believe that using the authenticity of your own experience in your art will become vanish from how people value art then yeah we're headed for a future where AI rules. I really hope that that isn't the case.

reply
I like your framework of separating use cases, mostly to evaluate how it will change in those specific areas, but I think you can evaluate capabilities fairly simply: I like to separate AI that depends on giant data centers and huge power draw from the kind that doesn't (not always local)—basically expensive vs cheap.

The expensive stuff isn't sustainable. Not yet. It probably will be, who knows when. I suspect it will be eventually because there's good money in it.

Here are the claims I find highly suspect based on the above:

- Anyone making claims that require expensive AI and attaching it to a short-term timeframe

- Anyone saying highly capable AI is impossible in the long-term

- Anyone saying these specific companies will be the winners—there is absolutely no moat for these models

I personally think anyone claiming something like super-intelligence or something approaching what we might consider sentience even in the next 5 years is suspect as well. I would not take the bet myself, but I would also not bet against it. The main reason is power: there's literally only so much power we can generate, so much societal disruption due to creating the infrastructure we can absorb (not to mention the societal disruption due to the tech itself), so its capability to self-improve is going to be highly constrained.

So far, we see increases in capabilities also increase power usage, I believe linearly. So, we're not seeing increases in efficiency that will make this easier to absorb. There's a ceiling, it won't go up quickly, so I think actual sentient-like AI capabilities are quite farther out than promoters think. Not impossible! I think it's more like a decade+ of maturation of the software and hardware stack—which isn't really that long in the grand scheme of things but longer than most people are betting.

reply
They may have more nuanced views for sure, but nuance is famously lacking from most online discussions unfortunately. I would love to see more of it surface!
reply
> Like the dot-com bubble, I suspect that certain parts of the current AI landscape are unsustainable

It's possible to believe that _almost all_ AI companies will go bankrupt while still believing it is a massively important world changing technology.

reply