upvote
I've looked into this kind of thing maybe 5 years ago, and there were some (expensive) devices meant for ingesting SD cards onto SSDs (either internal or USB). Some just had buttons, and some had small screens with status etc. I think there there were some with wifi portals for management. Now it looks like there are are more cheaper options that are for a more general audience.

Question: is there a reason that you couldn't skip the pi and just use a USB-C hub and your phone to copy from the reader to a SSD? pre USB-C I did this but it was kludgy using apple's "camera connection kit".

reply
I wasn't sure how much power the whole copy process would take. Gemini tells me with the phone I had then even a powered USB hub would not be charging the phone when it's on USB OTG; and the killer argument is that the phone only had USB 2.0.
reply
> I wasn't sure how much power the whole copy process would take.

It seems likely that whatever it is, it would be less than powering an entire additional computer like a Raspberry Pi. :)

> Gemini tells me with the phone I had then even a powered USB hub would not be charging the phone when it's on USB OTG

What phone are we talking about? There's always been lot of weird information out there about USB OTG capabilities; it always seems like it's more mystery than verified fact. This quagmire is all that Gemini has to work with.

To add my own anecdote: There's certainly a lot I that I haven't done, but every time I've attempted to power a phone or tablet while it was doing USB OTG, I've been successful. (I don't think I ever tried any of that prior to about 15 years ago, though.)

> the killer argument is that the phone only had USB 2.0

That's a limit. USB 2 only has one 480Mbps channel and it is shared for both TX and RX.

But still: It can copy from one device to another at around 15 or 20 megabytes per second.

That's enough to fill up a 500GB SSD in between about 7-9 hours of total runtime. Not great, but perhaps not terrible.

If a day's shooting generated (say) 10GB of new stuff to back up, then: That's only about 10 minutes per day for backups. Backups can happen while I fuss around with dinner or whatever.

---

Your solution is clever and I do like it, but I think if I were backpacking then I'd rather take an extra battery than a Raspberry Pi and a keyboard. The battery is a better multitasker, I think. :)

How was the trip?

reply
So, why not a USB hub and use the phone to copy from card reader to NVME? Or even simpler, just the NVME and put the card directly into the phone?

No powerbank, no Raspberry clone, no card reader, no networking, no ssh.

reply
Out of curiosity wouldn't it have been possible to do the same with a small four port USB-C hub plugged into an android phone? And then plug two things into the USB-C hub, a microsd-to-usb reader and the USB3 external NVME drive. This would allow for the full set of CLI file system manipulation tools and things like rsync to be run on the mounted filesystem of the SD card and/or the NVME drive, assuming installation of something like termux.

On a daily basis very easy to use an android GUI file management application to copy or move all the files from the microSD card to the NVME storage, doing a bulk select and then 'move' to mounted destination. Or write a tiny shell script that can run in termux that moves all new files that don't exist in the NVME drive destination.

If I were doing this and I had some reasonable level of confidence in the wifi where I was staying temporarily, I'd try to set up a script to periodically do an incremental back up from the mounted filesystem of the NVME drive to a small fileserver that lives in my home office, via VPN.

reply