upvote
The thing is, Vakil says it was vetted by Brian Conrad, who is basically a human Lean engine.

Masullo isn't a data scientist. He got a math PhD at Stanford and has been working there since, supported by soft money. So not a professor, but someone the grant holders thought was worth paying to do research.

reply
Whenever I, as someone who stopped at Calc 3 in college, read modern mathematics papers I realize how differently mathematicians brains must function than mine. This is not a value statement and nor am I demeaning either side. It's just... wow.

(setting aside any dispute as to the veracity of this particular paper, the point still stands more broadly with tons of human-generated output)

reply
Any technical subject beyond a certain horizon of familiarity is pretty much impossible to understand. You're simply being overwhelmed with definitions.
reply
eh, i see it when it comes to programming as well. the mathematical types write this crazy functional code that is just impossible for my brain to get. there are also a lot of unintuitive (to me) concepts.

not a value judgement, i just find procedural code to be infinitely more understandable

reply
It's perfectly possible to write 940 pages manually over 12 years of work. Almost certainly many more due to drafts and failed attempts. Also, the Alpoge proof is GBs of Lean code which translate to 250k pages in the "human" version.
reply
Please stop copy-pasting uninformed reddit comments in every thread. They didn't even find the right guy, Alessandro Maria Masullo, who has a PhD in math at Stanford and also received a presidential honor from the president of the Italian republic for being a top student.
reply
I'm highly skeptical also, but OTOH extremely long human proofs have been a thing in the past, especially for important results like this.
reply
Published a number of hours after an AI-assisted proof has been published for a 150+ year old hypothesis? Doubt.
reply
It's 940 pages long and presumably the process of producing it created many witnesses willing to vouch for its provenance as well as records of progress. Setting your math career on fire for a lie that obvious would be crazy.
reply
> The hope was to bring Alessandro to Stanford for a year to polish the writing and then announce it after running it by enough people. Now it seems best to put out the current draft.

We are not sure when this proof was drafted. It might have a few months or even more and it was rushed due to Alpöge announcement.

reply
They have had another person reviewing it for months and the author has been incorporating his feedback, according to TFL. If anything I believe the AMS would give Masullo priority if both pan out.
reply
It's a working draft, which they published hastily for obvious reasons.
reply
It is said that others have been reviewing that human-written proof for many months.

Obviously, it was published immediately, despite the reviews not being finalized, when it became known that an AI-assisted proof was announced (but I understand that the complete AI proof has not been published yet).

reply
The arrow goes the other way, most likely (similarly to what happened with Navier-Stokes).
reply
deleted
reply
940 pages vs 15M lines of lean from the AI proof
reply
Wiles' proof of Fermat's Last Theorem was 129 pages and lean proof was 13 million lines

Interesting in this context because Alpöge has the lean proof but not the human readable variant while Alessandro Masullo proof has the human readable proof but not lean proof. This might support Alessandro's claim that it is not an AI proof, and it will be particularly exciting if they both solved the Reimann Hypothesis using different routes.

reply
> It's 940 pages.

Just ask ChatGPT to summarize it.

reply
I did, and it claims to have found errors, but those errors may be possible to repair. These kinds of small issues are usually found and fixed when papers are reviewed formally prior to publishing.

Given the era we live in now, if this version works too, expect a Lean formalization of it within days.

reply
I haven't seen a single piece of code which doesn't contain errors according to Claude (I'm quite sure Hello World level codes are exceptions, obviously). Most of them are false positives, many times all of them are that. Also, asking Claude to review the same code multiple times results in different found problems, with different priorities.

So, this means absolutely nothing.

reply