upvote
I'm no mathematician, but my understanding is that the Riemann Hypothesis implies that the distribution of prime numbers has a nice, predictable structure. Many existing proofs assume that the Riemann Hypothesis is true to take advantage of that structure. So, now we know that all of those results are true!

One example is the Miller-Rabin test (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller%E2%80%93Rabin_primality...), which checks whether a number is prime. Without assuming (a more general version of) the Riemann Hypothesis, this is a probabilistic algorithm: the best we could prove is that it has some small probability of reporting that a prime number is composite. But with it, we can prove that the algorithm is guaranteed to work. (Mind you, there are other deterministic primality testing algorithms that don't rely on Riemann for their correctness proofs.)

I don't know any immediate, more practical implications of solving it. I would love to know if there are any!

reply
Imagine that we haven't mapped all of earth, and there are still many unexplored landmasses. A while ago we discovered a large continent, and after sailing around it we found it's the biggest unexplored continent we know of. But it's surrounded by cliffs on all sides, so we haven't been able to land on it yet.

Solving the Riemann hypothesis means we finally landed on it. We don't entirely know what's inside. Maybe it's a lot of mostly-empty forests with little of value, but if it's like any of the other continents we've already explored, it probably has an abundance of natural resources to take advantage of. Now we just have to go digging.

reply
This vague analogy makes me feel even more confused after reading it.
reply
We just unlocked a large new area. We don't already know of specific useful things in that area, but based on past experience with unlocking other areas, we expect that in the long term we'll find a lot of useful things.
reply
The result by itself doesn't really unlock anything, since it was presumed to hold. TBD whether the proof contains novel techniques, those would be the key to a new "continent" of math.
reply
How much of math is based on unproven hypotheses?
reply
it has the potential to cascade things its a very general problem that allows tons of other theories to be simplifed or have greater guarantees, but its a really wide, so nothing economically relevant in the immediate sense, however hopeful if you want for progress, freightening if you think about knowledge work.
reply
From the article:

> Scads of other mathematical proofs and hypotheses have been proposed, which work only if one assumes that the Riemann hypothesis is true.

reply
That only kicks the can further down the road, how are these other works helpful?
reply
It is helpful in an abstract theoretical world.

In the real world... not so much. Lex Friedman had a bunch of great guests talking about this.

At a certain point, math disconnects from the physical world. In a ~Platonic~ one may say.

Steven Brunton (GOAT and author of of the best ML books I've seen) gave the example of the Navier Stokes result. Could this new fluid dynamics result be used to make cool new engines? No. Unfortunately the scale where the proof resides, viscosity and real-world turbulence take over.

https://open.spotify.com/episode/0ndqMvnUJkNmQrhK98R09Y?si=6...

reply
>?si=64e32d788be94e32 tracking parameter
reply
There are proofs based on the proofs that are based on this really important problem
reply
(We merged this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50583445)
reply
honestly it would probably be more consequential if the hypothesis was disproved; Cryptographers already assumed it was true, I imagine this is the case in many other areas.
reply
If we could go back and ask people in 1850 if studying prime numbers would ever be useful, they would never have guessed the benefits we get from it today like internet banking, secure browsing, cryptocurrencies.. The biggest benefit of solving RH may be something we cannot fathom yet
reply
It's philosophical. It's about the way natural numbers work, the "anatomy of the integers".

There are no practical uses.

reply
First comes theory, afterwards sometimes practicality.

So many mathematical discoveries later became embedded in theories that allow us to understand the physical universe and in doing so engineer it.

reply
> There are no practical uses.

There are numerous algorithms that depend on GRH being correct for them to be correct.

reply
It's associated with the distribution of prime numbers which is very important to cryptography but also my god what is with the intellectual incuriousity here?

The exact same ridiculous argument could be applied to the basic mathematics and physics underpinning literally all modern technology.

reply