upvote
It is probably not that compressible. Anthropic FLT proof also has a lot of redundancies but my projection is without true mathematical refactoring it will be hard to get to 50% reduction in line count. One problem is that Lean, or type theory really, is truly verbose. In these parallely developed proofs if two agents use slightly incompatible definitions there are a lot of translations back and forth. Also FLT is following routes well established by mathematicians and it still got to 13 million lines. So I am actually surprised that GRH is not much bigger, as it reportedly ranges over a wide swath of fields.
reply
Anthropic claims to have a 1/7 the size version somewhere. https://claude.dev/blog/safely-scaling-multi-agent-teams-wit...
reply
Yes it would be interesting to see that version. If compaction comes from proof architectural improvement (what I called "true mathematical refactoring"), it could improve readability. On the other hand if it is tactical, for example using tall rw stacks that are incomprehensible to humans, shortness doesn't necessarily imply better accessibility. I suppose it has to be a lot of the first kind to get that much compression.
reply
Even with all the resources he presumably have… interesting
reply
Hence why it seems rushed. Backed by Anthropic he certainly can clean it, model access or $$$ is probably not a limiting factor; only time.

I don't know if Anthropic IPO being yesterday, or American Mathematical Society Executive Committee and Board of Trustees meeting being today has anything to do with the announcement happening today, but it's certainly interesting timing.

reply
i would imagine the IPO has everything to do with it
reply
Apparently a mostly human/human only unfinished proof on the hypothesis was rushed to publication upon hearing this news. It is around 1000 pages long. I don't know what the approximate ratio should be but fully formal propfs generally are much longer than natural language proofs. So probably this size is ij 5he ballpark of normal. If anyone sho writes lean proofs or works in formalized mathematics can comment that would be nice.
reply
I am very skeptical of that human-only proof.
reply
It more than 250 000 pages.
reply