upvote
Say you solved GRH.

Would you really wait 4 days knowing that every big AI lab on the planet is racing for this result?

Worse is better wins again.

reply
https://math216.wordpress.com/2026/11/20/hurried-announcemen...

This is what they intended to do, and did for months.

reply
Yes my friend thats how things used to work, and should even now. Assuming all models can solve this stuff why cant we wait a few days to cleanup our work atleast and make more sense out of it.

Didnt OpenAI learn and started to cleanup the work a tad bit... ofc its not perfect but this thing is a joke.

I dont and wont understand the HN mindset of winning the race at any cost mindset.

This seems like a stock pump attempt that failed miserably.

I dont see the point we can all be civil and build better stuff now. Why try to one up others at the cost of throwing out slop.

Trust me if the value of your product can even be measured in days, then thats not a product worth investing in.

I personally think AI companies deserve to fail if they cant even understand that.

reply
To clarify, I didn't say it's 100% correct, no questions asked. I said the opposite in fact: the expensive part of reviewing this is checking that the top-level statement actually says GRH. Actually exactly in line with what you say, that to me is where the skepticism should go.

What it "works" here to me is simple that it type-checks. Another user (hafeoz) even compiled all 175k modules upthread, with no errors and no sorry. Of course, a kernel bug is possible, but there are independent reimplementations of the checker, so you'd need the proof to slip past every one of them. A wrongly stated theorem is the more realistic failure, I think someone brought this up as well, and that only needs a page or two of definitions checked by humans, not 15M lines.

On readability: nobody was ever going to read 15M lines, or tbh even 1M after cleanup. That's what the kernel is for. Cleanup makes it easier to learn and build on, nobody's saying that shouldn't be done. My argument is simply dead modules are ugly, not wrong. OP himself says he expects it to be massively simplified.

As for "why not spend 3-4 days on it first": it went out today, and people were independently checking it on their own hardware within hours. That's arguably the better order, iterative progress first on successful ideas, not perfection. That's kind of what the whole YC ethos (who's page we're on, is. lol). Besides, a human proof got rushed out within a day because of this one, so the incentive to publish first was clearly real. We're on the same page here, just the 3-4 days of simplification first isn't the right way to progress imo.

reply