upvote
I’m making a subtler point about medical research. Yes, its value is in the benefit it brings to people. If someone developed a powerful new drug and didn’t let anyone use it, both the drug and its developer’s accomplishments would effectively be worthless. Similarly, if we produce proofs only machines understand, and in doing do deprive people of an opportunity to strive towards a goal, to figure something out for themselves — the value drops to near zero. Often in math, the problem itself is worth much more than a single solid.

I think even with intrinsic motivation, people would get worn down by having things they worked for, possibly for years, yanked out from under them on a regular basis. The field must change how it does work and provides incentives, or it will become no more than a hobbyist playground for LLMs, and largely stop providing benefits to humans.

reply
Very few if any human can hold the entire arch and workings of a modern CPU in their head either, yet people seem to be using their phones just fine and the value has not dropped to 0. If LLMs designed a chip (see HN thread from yesterday), and people don't really know every single in-and-out of it, but it works fine in the phone and gives you 1 month of battery lifetime, people wont care.

And again if having a problem solved before you "yanks it out from under you" that's still just wanting to be the one who crossed the finish line first. If you have internalized the extrinsic value mindset in this way, you will of course be sad about the developments.

Finally I think the current structure is already fine. Philosophy, classic literature, music theory departments still exist, and nobody is dropping out of them just because things were already done and figured out. I think here again we get to the archetype of the extrinsically motivated mathematicial who wants to acquire, stamp and claim things for their own for social status.

I think this will lead to people just doing maths in the way they want to, if I analyze Dostojevsky because I love it and find it meaningful, no-one can "yank" anything from underneath me and I can know that everyone of my peers have the right motivations to be there.

reply
Even if humans are never able to understand the proof, they can still go forward assuming the hypothesis is now true e.g. they can assume GRH when working on other problems.
reply
[dead]
reply