upvote
> Software is solved.

Software has practically torched its reputation to the ground in the last month, let alone over the last year. Outage after outage, outrage after outrage. We've disrupted the lives of hundreds of thousands of people (hell, if not millions) in the last two weeks.

But I know as I write this: there is no mountain of proof high enough to change the opinion of anyone who thinks software is "solved". AI is the irrefutable hypothesis.

reply
Your parent is arguing what execs have been convinced of, not necessarily an obvious objective truth.

AI is finding bugs that have been in PHP, Java, Ruby, NginX for years or decades. Even if "software isn't solved", AI is going to be a big part of the solution.

I think the parent's comment is better read "anybody is capable of creating an app / SaaS these days, so distribution / marketing and the idea for the product are more important than implementation." This seems to be what the zeitgeist of solopreneurs are telling each other.

reply
Software written before AI is being torched and AI is fixing them now you mean.
reply
A "fix" is generally seen as an improvement, but we're actually seeing a lot of enshittification.
reply
Code written by humans who told others they were 10x but in reality built shitty code that AI is now catching.
reply
> Software is solved.

There are more than a hundred thousand SWEs making half a million a year writing software. The industry changed but the demand (of projects) is still outstripping supply.

reply
This isn’t true even at a cursory glance. We would be hearing this constantly if this was the case. People wouldn’t be “anxious” and “worried” about AI or whatever but would be talking about how to make ends meet instead of their existential feelings.

So you took the opportunity of someone asking a personal and important question to spread generic FUD. Despicable.

reply
and what is your point other than I said AI is eating software engineering jobs ?
reply
There is no point to glean for those without shame.
reply
> And thus I paced around my office, thinking about the last five Hacker News submissions on maths, but more organically presented as if I ran into them on the street. Will computahs end dah world? Then the story circles back to whatever mundane thing I was going to do next. Ha ha: There’s nothing that I can do with humans wanting to dominate the world, sure isn’t.

Pot calling kettle black here

reply
the question is how long do we have to wait until the guys that think like this get fired or get sued into bankruptcy.

it’s an attrition game, we have to keep building small software that works, doesn’t get hacked and doesn’t go down while these accelerationists 100x into their crash.

reply
I hate to be the one to tell you this but this fantasy is not happening. The industry has changed and it's going to continue on this trajectory so you have to learn how to do this well. There are going to be companies popping up that will claim to have figured out how to build with these agents quickly, securely and in a manner that's maintainable. Those are the companies that will take our jobs. So either learn how to build like them or move on.
reply
> I hate to be the one to tell you this but this

One would expect a phrase like that to lead into fresh factual information, not a subjective (however possibly well-informed) prediction arguing a point very similar to the one they were contesting in the first place.

reply
This is a completely useless comment and adds nothing to the conversation. You're trying very hard to sound intelligent, but it's not working.
reply
> so you have to learn how to do this well.

I get that you believe that agent development is good, but why are you trying to convince me to join? for my own good? or is it cultish

even if you assume vibecoding is revolutionary, there’s still going to be an oversupply of vibecoders, and virgin programmers are going to be quite rare, in fact it’s already happening

vibeocders lose capacity to go back to actually writing and reading code, and the vibecoding force is composed of non technical folk, and technical folk alike. Technical folk degrade their experience by coalescing skillsets

And I just haven’t seen a big leap in software, maybe lots of vulns are discovered? Vibecoding still hasn’t brought anything major like Chatgpt, wikipedia, uber, iphone, just slop and cves

reply
I think you have your head in the sand. Good organizations are not "vibecoding" . I'm not trying convince you to join anything. It's up to you, but if you think orgs will wait for you to do everything manually because you refuse to recognize the moment you're going to be out of a job. There will be someone else who can do the same work at a fraction of the time and ultimately that's what matters.

You can make llms write good and maintainable code, people are already proving this. That doesn't mean they're just throwing llms on their codebase and writing slop.

I was like you once too until a model came out and was able to do something I could do that previous models couldn't.

reply