upvote
Networking is meritocratic.

Are you going to get your idiot friend a software engineering job that they have no ability to succeed at and damage your own reputation?

Of course not.

This is Goffman's front stage / back stage. If everyone is putting on the same front stage performance, what matters is knowing what is back stage. Knowing what is back stage with a person is what it means to "know" a person.

Meritocracy doesn't mean some kind of fine grained MCAT exam and then you are just hired based on a sorted list. The system isn't broken because it is not that.

reply
No disagreement there. I do tend to see networking still hold to merit, people just know who they've seen do well and keep connections open there.

And personally I tend to put less weight behind standardized tests like MCAT vs personal experience working with a person. Standardized testing fights against the challenge of control, creating something so structured and controlled it can be gamed and the results are only as good as the assumptions used designing the system.

reply
Well said. I commented above that having the right skills is table stakes now. Tons of candidates have technical skills.
reply