upvote
> The unfortunate reality is that the first candidates to be interviewed won't ever get an offer, because there aren't enough data points to make a decision yet.

This doesn't follow in any way. Sure, the offer the first candidate might receive will be delayed, but if you're looking to fill a position in 1 month and the first candidate you've seen was still the best you saw in that month, you'll of course make him an offer.

And I am saying this from experience - we've often hired our first candidate for an interview in my team. Though I will admit that we don't follow much of the practices I read about and have heard from other friends, so maybe we are not typical in this either.

reply
That assumes that candidates are ok with waiting a month to hear the results of their interview, which in my experience isn't realistic. Also, the best candidates have plenty of options. So there's a significant chance that if they are actively looking then they'll receive another offer in that month. Even if that's just because the other company interviewed them further along in their process and is comfortable making an offer quickly, because they have enough data points to know how good they are!
reply
Mag 7 companies typically take months to finish an interview/hiring cycle. It took over three and a half months to join Google for me. Similar but shorter for other Mag 7 companies I have worked for.
reply