upvote
You make it sound like that’s a bad thing though?

Wouldn’t it encourage more domestic production, and thus more and better jobs and long-term sustainability? I think Brasil has more than enough natural resources to produce basically anything.

reply
> Wouldn’t it encourage more domestic production You wish but how do you domestically produce CPUs, GPUs, RAM? Even the US has failed at scaling production of these. Not everything can magically be produced locally and most of the time the taxes create a backwards incentive where eternally sending money out and never building infrastructure here is still more accessible. Keep in mind the currency being worth nothing compared to the US makes things worse locally too, why sell your farm produce locally when you can make 6x as much by selling it abroad?!

With tech this bad then everything suffers, we have to outsorce all server hosting, websites, databases, everything goes to the US, because its just twice or sometimes way more than twice as expensive to have a server in Brazil of equal capacity!

<rant> Not everything can be domestically produced and these insane taxes just make things worse in certain industries, want to buy computers for schools that dont suck ass? Still gonna have to pay insane taxes on top of the insane exchange rate too and no your warranty claim is not getting respected and sending the product to the US and getting a warranty claim back will cost you the same as a new product in just taxes alone. Ask me how my "oculus quest 1" i know.. Its just a lose-lose game for the entire industry and especially with servers, most brazilian's data end up processed in the US and theres zero incentive to build infrastructure here, because everything is so damn expensive, by the time you are done recouping the costs of actually owning hardware in BR you are so outdated that you might as well have spent 1/5th of it on hosted infra in the US. </rant>

reply
Your thinking entirely tech, but that is not a fair way to think about things. Very few countries can actually produce CPU, GPUs, RAM, even USA cannot.

But there is only so much a government can do, they need to ensure their local population can support itself. People do not need CPUs, GPUs, RAM, they need food, water, health care, the actual necessities of live. And all of that can be produced in Brazil year around for the most part.

The fact that you have to pay 2x the price for a phone as somewhere else, doesn't have much to do with the fact that I in Canada pay probably 5x what you pay for produce and meat. I would much rather pay more for an iPhone and significantly less for vegetables and meat, then the opposite.

reply
That's a good reason to have tariffs (and subsidies) on food that can be produced in Brazil.

But with tech there is absolutely no plan to build a domestic industry so it's a permanent regressive tax with none of the benefits tariffs can give you. Building chip fabs is the kind of thing where you need direct state investment to make it work, which is not realistic in a country with way bigger problems.

reply
Just to correct your last paragraph a little: while it's true that you're going to pay 2-3x the cost for an iPhone, there are affordable phones down here from companies that have established a strong local presence like Samsung. You won't get the ___same___ phone but you'll get a decent one. Less options of course.

Food isn't 5x cheaper but it's more like 2x cheaper (Canadian living in Brazil here.) And of course land is 10x cheaper. HHahhaha.

reply
Some food is much more than 2x cheaper though (Brazilian who lived in Canada here). Beef, most fruits and vegetables (except berries), coffee, cheese and milk, to name a few. Processed foods are about 2x.

If you go to a supermarket in a high-income neighborhood, it won’t feel like that, though.

reply
Eh… tax rates for products that go through the formal import mechanism (i.e. the one distributors use) are completely different to the ones available to a natural person.

In fact many parts I bought for my PC had their prices at the same or at lower prices than what it retails in the US. Others I bought on a trip to the US.

There is a LOT of profiteering done by intermediates that is blamed on taxes (hello car manufacturers!), and them being cascading also does not help. The fact that they are structured in this way simply makes it opaque to the layman and allows for this scapegoating discourse while allowing for increased profits. Thankfully the new VAT structure will remove these cascading effects. It’s 20-30 years late, and will take longer for the tax regime to be fully transitioned, but it was finally approved.

Remember that Brazil opts to have high consumption tax rates while having lower income and property tax rates, which impacts people with lower income. There is zero dividend tax! Ask any colleague that lives in an OECD country how much do they pay in taxes combined (consumption, income and property) and you’ll see that you pay proportionally less in taxes than them.

The problem with Brazil is misallocation of public funds, corruption, bureaucracy, the famous custo Brasil, not that “taxes in Brazil are high”.

reply
Not every country will produce everything though. For instance, Brazil is unlikely to produce cameras or certain kinds of electronics. But the tariffs on those are still around 100%. And the shipping is often also taxed.

Plus it also creates more inequality in Brazil, especially since there's a rule where you can import up to $1000 of stuff duty-free if you bring it in through a personal flight. So the rich get to import stuff duty-free on their holidays and the poor cannot. And many people just bring in more than 1K worth of stuff.

Not saying you're wrong. It could encourage local production. But often the ones lobbying for this sort of import are the huge businesses that don't want competition either. And it biases the market towards corporations with the legal knowhow (and skill in bribery) to get in the market and be an effective monopoly....

(I live in Brazil.)

reply
From 1984 to 1990 Brazil completely banned all computer related imports to develop its national industry. Since then, high import taxes have remained, sometimes over 100%. Do you see a booming high tech industry in Brazil?

https://www.nytimes.com/1990/09/13/business/brazil-to-drop-c...

reply
What we see in Brazil is a high dependence on US tech firms and Chinese imports.

It's true that a lot of stuff is made in Brazil, and that's a good thing. I try to buy that stuff when I can. But the import law has such a wide scope that it often hurts when it shouldn't really.

reply
The highest import taxes in Brazil it's 35%, no 100%. Do not confuse "Aliexpress" tax to business import taxes.
reply
The problem is that we still are in a dire need of reindustrialization. We do have the qualified workforce and engineers to produce it, and even some national consumer brands have always been, in my opinion, higher quality or as good as their foreign counterparts (e.g. Havainanas, Olympikus, Mondial, Britânia).

The last time a president tried to, in some degree, make changes for a path towards reindustrialization, well, the national bourgeoisie did not appreciate it, to say the least.

reply
This is the idea at least. Brazil developed aviation and ended up with Embraer.
reply
Especially for a country with 220 million ppl. You can't import stuff for everybody while almost nobody is exporting
reply
At the moment we are paying only ICMS (state tax). I bought earphones from China this week, and these are the values I paid:

Earphones R$76,29

Shipping R$33,68

Tax R$22,56

Total R$132,53

ICMS is 17% but you have to include shipping and it is charged "from the inside", that is, your tax is 17% of the total paid, not a 17% surcharge: 22.56/(76.29+22.56+33.68)=17%.

reply
I recently bought a ~$1000 laptop (for R$6459).

Tax: R$2746.37 (42.52%), out of which R$1486.86 are federal taxes and R$1259.51 are state taxes

So the store made R$3712.63 out of my purchase. Electronics in Brazil are wildly expensive, and there is no real competitive national industry. Sony VAIO is one of the few companies that assembles laptops in Zona Franca de Manaus (which gives a lot of tax benefits), but it doesn't provide any higher-end models.

For context, the latest 16 inch Macbook Pro costs $3000 in the US (give or take 10% state taxes). In here, the same purchase in the Apple store goes for R$37,999 ($6386). Fun.

I'm just hoping that things don't get much worse with the new tax reform...

reply
People really don’t understand how much profit companies make in Brazil. Tax is not the reason why MacBooks cost 220% what they do in the US. There is no combination of tax that reaches that. Same thing with cars, companies make more profit in Brazil than in Europe. Profit per unit sold is much higher here, which we could call price gouging.
reply
Exactly! Apple pays 12% to 14.5% in import duties in Brazil, depending on the item, plus sales tax (ICMS, which is around 20% and varies by state). Their margins here are massive.
reply
This was a simple search away:

> If you start with the U.S. price, taxes add roughly 80% to 95% on top when a MacBook is purchased in an Apple Store, or around 90% to 100%+ on top if you buy it online and ship it directly via courier/mail.

reply
And yet the federal government (or more generally "the left") is always somehow the culprit, when they don't even set most of the tax burden.
reply
Yes, they do.

If you check the voting patterns of the last 20 years, it's overwhelmingly the left that voted and continues voting for raising taxes in absolutely all spheres.

PSDB is center left or left, btw.

You will be hard pressed in finding self-declared right-wingers voting for raising taxes; usually when they pass something related to adding a tax it's to actually simplify or move things around.

reply
For those without context (foreigners), PSDB is a party whose economic model is a cross of Milton Friedman and Keynes.

But because they think vaccines are good and gays are people they’re considere left wing by the far right.

reply
> Sony VAIO Not Sony -- the VAIO brand was sold years ago, and every product with the VAIO brand you see being sold in Brazil today is really made by Positivo.
reply
I'd rather have high import tax and low income tax. Brazil's top income tax bracket is 27.5%.
reply
> Brazil's top income tax bracket is 27.5%

Making it one of lowest in the world.

reply
The threshold for the top income tax bracket is extremely low. And Brazil relies heavily on indirect taxes on goods and services.

It ranks last in tax-to-return ratio [1]

There is no possible angle to attempt saying that Brazil's taxes are low.

[1] https://ibpt.org.br/estudo-irbes-14a-edicao-idh-e-carga-trib...

reply
You're citing a very poor 8-page report to make a really bold statement. Did you read it? It only considers 30 countries, and the index they invented to support their claim is just dividing tax revenue as percent of GDP by HDI with some weights. That's silly to say the least, and far from a globally accepted formula for "tax ROI". And if you open the report you'll see many countries with vastly larger tax burden than Brazil's.

Brazilians complaining that we're the most taxed country in the world is nothing new, but its simply not true.

And there is a very specific group in Brazil that enjoy extremely low or inexistent taxation: wealthy people. Brazil doesn't tax dividends and has very low inheritance tax. And as already mentioned, the top income tax bracket is among the lowest in the world.

reply
> Lula da Silva thing, it has been like that under Bolsonaro and his predecessors

Those predecessors were...drumroll...literally Lula (and then Lula's party member Dilma while he was in prison)

reply
Import tax at 60% for individual buyers was created in 1995, by FHC, way before Lula's party ever came to power. In the dictatorship era it was around 50%.

It's always been high.

As much as some people want to deny it Brazil's problems started way before 2002.

reply
> As much as some people want to deny it Brazil's problems started way before 2002.

I mean absolutely. Brazil is and was a developing country.

The correct framing is not "why has Brazil gotten so bad" (incorrect premise) but rather "why has Brazil failed to get better while others proved it was possible"

reply
Brazil has definitely gotten better. Maybe not at the rate a handful of other countries managed but it’s been steady progress. All indicators get better decade over decade.

I also challenge the idea that there are many other similar countries that have outpaced Brazil. If you look into it they are countries with very specific advantages, or are countries Brazilians wouldn’t want to live in for many different reasons. Growth and quality of life are different things.

Sometimes people compare it to China and think “if China did it so should we”, but it’s never happened for anyone else except China. No one should compare themselves to China.

Considering the economic model of Brazil it’s impossible for it to do better without severely changing the makeup of society. Only revolutions really manage to do that.

Brazil was never going to grow 10% YoY and fix all its problems, it was just never in the cards. Slow and steady progress is unfortunately the best we can hope for, and not go backwards like some neighboring countries.

reply
> I also challenge the idea that there are many other similar countries that have outpaced Brazil.

What would you even consider a "similar" country?

There are plenty of examples of countries that were poorer and had less resources and did much better than Brazil.

> Considering the economic model of Brazil it’s impossible for it to do better

Your comment is trying to paint an unfalsifiable position, but you do not back that up with anything of substance.

Again, plenty of counter-examples.

reply
Similar in either size or development stage at the turn of the century. Nigeria, Egypt, South Africa, Mexico, Indonesia, Pakistan, Argentina, India. Former colonies which are capitalist democracies (or roughly). Are these countries so much better than Brazil today?

I do accept there are tiny countries that have done better.

reply