Warm introductions are probably the only way round this.
The manager needs to make sure the HR part works. With one recent role where I received mostly obviously fake CVs, I found they had updated the role description to be very buzzwordy. After I rewrote it to be much more "this is what we do and how we do it and this is what we expect from this role" I got fewer but much better candidates.
Is blacklisting candidates legal? Still a shitty thing to do.
(Not saying the applicants are being immoral or anything like that, but can't agree with calling the recruiters shitty)
Dishonesty will bred dishonesty.
And I agree with the person you're replying to, I'm hiring a human not an AI meat proxy. I won't explicitly blacklist them, though the rejection reason will stick with them if they apply for other positions.