upvote
There is definitely a conflict between ‘HR filters only allow through resumes that are AI tuned and read like LinkedIn influencer buzzword checklists’ and hiring managers hate the smell of AI on a resume’.

Warm introductions are probably the only way round this.

reply
In many cases, it's by design. Corporate hiring policies give compliance cover for hiring the warm lead they always wanted.
reply
Yes, fully agree. And even if HR isn't just doing the bare minimum, they have very little understanding of the topics so they can't easily dismiss things as obvious nonsense.

The manager needs to make sure the HR part works. With one recent role where I received mostly obviously fake CVs, I found they had updated the role description to be very buzzwordy. After I rewrote it to be much more "this is what we do and how we do it and this is what we expect from this role" I got fewer but much better candidates.

reply
“and reject this person for other roles in the future”

Is blacklisting candidates legal? Still a shitty thing to do.

reply
If someone isn't honest during the interviews, isn't there a petty big risk they'll continue like that also after getting hired?

(Not saying the applicants are being immoral or anything like that, but can't agree with calling the recruiters shitty)

reply
Recruiters are already shitty when they ask for 10+ years of experience on technology that hasn't been out for 5 or are clearly shopping for reasons to claim the domestic market can't support what they need.

Dishonesty will bred dishonesty.

reply
When will you be firing the entire HR department for using AI-driven filters?
reply
The AI-driven filters are vital. The absolute deluge of resumes you get the moment you post a job can be staggering and completely impractical to actually sift through. And HR departments felt this way before AI enabled entirely autonomous mass resume submission.

And I agree with the person you're replying to, I'm hiring a human not an AI meat proxy. I won't explicitly blacklist them, though the rejection reason will stick with them if they apply for other positions.

reply