upvote
A technicality: what is being open sourced here are the formulas used to compute value-added tax and other forms of business tax that were affected by the recent tax reform.

Although the Brazilian tax authority does develop software to file personal income tax, and provides it free of charge, that software is currently not open source.

reply
If the formulas and laws are not accessible to the public directly is the law even valid.
reply
I imagine that the law is public, and thus some specification of the formula (as prose). But indeed in the 21st century a law that defines a mathematical formula ought to have a computer-usable component.
reply
We are getting to a points with LLM now that the tax formulas and etc are the important part now rather than the software itself.
reply
This is software though. The repository is written in Java.
reply
Advanced enough LLM can itself create formulas from laws
reply
Doesnt matter if it isnt the same formula applied by tax authorities. Their interpretation of the law is what matters.
reply
Deterministically?

Depends on how the law is written.

reply
It was also Intuit lobbying
reply
Yes, they killed direct file, the motivations are fairly blatant. Open source makes so much sense for this, you can check it and raise issues, raised a few issues for the IRS repos myself (obviously, they were pretty fringe, but this will matter for n=few hundred people)
reply
If you can file your taxes through a commercial app, why can't you do it through an open source app? Is it illegal? What's stopping a developer from making a free to use or open source tax filing app?
reply
The IRS only accepts direct filings from a list of certified cloud services. It's not illegal to generate a paper filing with something else and submit it yourself like if you did it by hand, it's just a lot less convenient. And you're fully responsible for any bugs in the code.

You could get the official instance of an open source app certified but that takes a lot of time and money.

reply
Why don't one of us make a cheap service that generates paper files for people, and prints them in our office and we put them in the mailbox for them?
reply
Thank you for getting to the core question! I did a little looking myself, and from what I found, I don't see that it would take a lot of money. A lot of time and effort, yes. But that's how programming complicated software is.

https://www.irs.gov/e-file-providers/become-an-authorized-e-...

reply
It's a lot of work (tax code is complex, there are also 50 states) , it changes every year so it needs constant work, it needs to be reletivly easy (else why bother using it) and it needs to be totally correct (a bug that calculates things wrong could have very bad consequences.
reply
All the more reason for the government to own and publish it, then the cost of updating the software can be accounted for in all bills that propose new tax changes.
reply
I once roughly calculated the administrative overhead of a job agency, checking the job agency, several layers of subsubcontactors and the checks the tax office has to do and it was ~3 times the salaries. As the complexity grows (exponentially) the people doing the work get considerably more expensive. I didn't even account for their salary administration which would involve employees who also come with administrative overhead.

It would be quite simple for employers to submit work schedules to the tax office, have employees check them, have the tax office send an invoice to the employer and have the tax office pay the salaries.

Have the employer report sick leave and request overtime at the tax office so that they can get fined.

The subsubcontractor system is full of fraudulent billing but if they have to report something to the tax office all the "mistakes" magically disappear.

reply
If the government worked for the people then sure, they should do that. However, the US government works mostly on behalf of the corporations, and it's in the interest of companies like Intuit and HRBlock to keep the tax code complicated and make it as difficult as possible for individuals to do their own taxes.
reply
People will trust an open source repo maintained by the government. Trusting an open source repo hosted by a third party is a different ball game.
reply
Nothing as far numbers wise as I can tell but the commercial apps have a way to digitally submit it.
reply
That's what I'm curious about. Is this digital submission behind some fee that the IRS charges, or a whitelist?
reply
https://www.irs.gov/e-file-do-your-taxes-for-free

Seems based on your income.

This is by design. Intuit spends loads of money to lobby politicians here and keep tax code complicated so they can stay in business. The US in general has a “let the private sector manage these things” mentality but our politicians don’t know how to create actual checks on these industries. Or they don’t care. Or they’re invested financially. Something something conflict of interest.

reply
So it doesn't sound half as bad as people are trying to make it. The IRS gives you a free tool to digitally file taxes if you earn up to $95 000.

Seems more like people are complaining for the sake of complaining.

reply
Why should it be capped at $95,000?
reply
That implies that here is a tax that applies non-progressively for higher earners. This is the worst kind of a tax, but of course, in practice, it might be fine if 100% pf people who earn 95’000$ and above have to declare extra stuff that cannot be declared in the free form.
reply
The open source app didn’t donate for any Republican campaigns. This was considered unamerican.
reply
It's extremely complex, especially once you get into filing taxes for a business. The laws change constantly. To be a serious product, you also have to keep up with atleast 50+1 sets of laws as well, since typically commercial options offer federal for free if you pay for state.

The accountants who are paid to keep up with these things and are most knowledgeable usually only deal with one or a few states. What incentive does any accountant have to lend their expertise to an open source project and help maintain it?

reply
So if it's extremely complex, and especially for businesses, then maybe it's fair that people pay for software that does it for them? I think it's normal world wide that businesses pay for people or software for this.

Also, you wouldn't have to make a solution for more than one state if you don't want to.

If I understand correctly, the IRS isn't hindering anybody from making a free or open source solution. So people who complain could either get on it, or use the options at hand.

reply
Please don't misunderstand my point. I fully think that it should be open source. I've just seen multiple projects start strong and say they are going to start with federal personal taxes and will expand from there. Then I assume they run into the complexity of the issues and just the maintenance needed for federal. They never get state and they never get business. 100% of people filing their taxes need one or both of those. I do not see a point in trusting a new developer that will only do half the job and I will have to enter in all my information again with an accountant or commercial tax software.

I would love to never pay a commercial company ever again. I just no longer get excited when I see an open source project get started for it, because they never come out with the full solution.

The full solution needs to come from the government or some fully funded open source project with a team of accountants and devs.

reply
I mean, you can still file your taxes with pen & paper, using public information and snail mail. But I fear the day when we’re all forced to use some clunky software owned by a shady private company, entering sensitive data and selfies on our smartphones, with no idea where it’s being stored. I’d be happy if the government just left the current system alone before making it even worse.
reply
It’s so bizarre that the US government doesn’t provide a way to do your taxes. At least for citizens.

I live in the Netherlands and the Dutch IRS provides everything I need to do my yearly taxes. Hell they fill in a whole lot of numbers automatically based on what they know about my salary from my employer. Before I owned my own home my yearly taxes took literally five minutes to fill in because of that. Just double checked some pre-filled numbers and done.

reply
It’s not bizarre, it’s by design. Powerful lobby efforts and another sign of the corporate takeover of Washington. Inuit & others have spent millions to keep it this way.

At one point, the government tried to force them into providing free tax filing for folks with simple taxes… they used every dark art / black hat tactic to trick customers into paying for even the simple free option.

reply
Intuit, yes.

But also, the right in the US is fundamentally anti-government (or at least government capacity). They want a return to the federal government of the 19th century, much much smaller.

One strategy they employ is to make people dislike the government. That means reducing its capacity (ala DOGE) so people have a poor experience dealing with it. And making tax compliance unnecessary difficult.

reply
The purpose of a system is what it does.
reply
penny wise pound foolish. This is so unfortunate.
reply
It wasn't a cost cutting measure...
reply
Almost all of the doge cuts cost the nation much more than they saved - especially in costs to the economy at large. Screwworm cost both livestock businesses and increased inflation for food prices and thats one niche example. Cuts were obviously for self enrichment or ideological crusade.
reply
Most of the doge cuts were to institutions that were in the way of Musk's companies enriching themselves by any and all means.
reply
Enacted by cocky, high-iq but gullible youngsters who thought they knew better.

Enabling brash, high IQ individuals with incomplete/flawed data leads to the most catastrophic outcomes.

reply
I don't think there's any evidence they were high IQ
reply
These are painfully direct, as well.

For example: Tesla wants Cybercab to go nationwide. For national safety purposes, Cybercab is self-certified (which is actually normal), but self-certified is constrained by NHTSA, who watches over what is happening and has the ability to halt what's happening if they don't think the manufacturer is following the rules.

Guess which part of NHTSA DOGE cut first?

They laid off a significant part of the NHTSA team with expertise in analyzing and regulating self-driving vehicles.

So while NHTSA has the legal authority to regulate the national push to allow Cybercabs on the road, many of the NHTSA personnel with the expertise to exercise that authority are gone.

Clever, clever.

reply
But definitely sold to the rubes as cost cutting. Just coincidentally defunded every agency investigating Elon’s companies.
reply
It's ok, Elon's a lefty now.
reply