upvote
The story is about a company that has proven the Riemann Hypothesis. That alone is pretty close to the news nowadays. The proof by Alpöge might be open-source, but the technology used to generate that proof (Claude) is definitely a trade secret of Anthropic. So for me this story from the 1970s shows surprising parallels to our reality of 2026.

But there is more on the Wikipedia page. Dijkstra also used to quip: "The question of whether Machines Can Think is about as relevant as the question of whether Submarines Can Swim."

Some people are simply ahead of their times.

reply
> That alone is pretty close to the news nowadays. The proof by Alpöge might be open-source, but the technology used to generate that proof (Claude) is definitely a trade secret of Anthropic.

The four color theorem took about 1000 hours of time on a the mainframe. Was the proof of the four color theorem suspect in this manner when it was released, and only became okay when everyday computers could run through the program?

reply
Yes? The proof was initially met with skepticism and was subsequently refined and built upon.

I don't think it had much to do with everyday computers being able to run the original program.

reply
I was asking in relation to this:

> the technology used to generate that proof (Claude) is definitely a trade secret of Anthropic.

The type of computer that could run the four color theorem was inaccessible to common people for a long time.

reply
Yes. Why do people keep spouting off about this without learning any history :'(
reply
Dijkstra was a devoted Christian. He also died years before seeing the state of modern LLMs. Religious people have certain magical supernatural biases regarding human consciousness. That is of course usually not a problem when they are working in any other field such as computer science or mathematics as long as they are not speaking on those topics where religion muddles ones thinking.
reply
Funny, I interpreted the quote as explicitly rejecting human exceptionalism because I thought "yeah, submarines can obviously swim but it's a silly question"
reply
Maybe he meant it as in both can achieve the goal in different ways, I am not sure, but it does seem like he is saying they are totally different things. In fact now that I think of that quote, any interpretation starts to become messy. I mean can submarines swim? They do seem to be swimming. I am not sure what answer he intended for this part of the analogy.
reply
To me the implication of the quote is: you can call it swimming, or you can confine "swimming" to a narrower meaning, but it doesn't really matter. In other words it is purely a semantic debate.
reply
He’s saying it doesn’t matter what you call it if they are functionally/observably equivalent.
reply
This is the concept of faith. Science is a process of continuous disproval yet operates in a state of certainty.
reply
Faith is fine as long as it doesn't clash with reality. And the reality is, the human brain is a physical system. Unless you can prove otherwise, consciousness is a property of some physical systems, so there is no reason to think some another physical system can't have consciousness.
reply
Faith is fundamentally incompatible with science. It demonstrates an individual is capable of believing things without evidence, which is the antithesis of science.

This then becomes a source of mental perjury: once one leap of faith has been shown, you must doubt every other conclusion, as it may too be based on some leap of faith. It undermines credibility to an extent that I pretty much dismiss any who tries to combine the two.

I personally find the logical conclusions of anyone who firmly believes in a god to be suspect. We have enough scientific evidence to rule out the possibility with enough certainty that no one should be taking that wager.

Go ahead and hate me, but no one will ever convince me otherwise.

reply
I believe the same, it frankly in any other circumstance would be called clinical insanity, but I try to be more diplomatic in saying this.

With mathematics and computer science work at least, we can be certain since they are formal and checkable regardless of beliefs of the creator, and as far as we know Dijkstra's work in cs is generally quite accurate.

reply
It is not insanity. It is brainwashing. The same process produces irrational nationalism, racism, and most other -isms.

I agree with Dawkins: religion is child abuse.

EDIT: on the upside, brainwashing can be cured in many if not most cases. AFAIK, the cure for insanity is still a WIP.

reply
You could have just stopped after the first sentence and had the same amount of content
reply