upvote
Strong agree. Whatever information you can learn in a few hours of interviews with someone pales in comparison to what you learn by having worked with someone for years. If hiring is restricted and you get very few reqs, of course you are going to lean to hiring a known quantity over taking a risk on a stranger.

I don't think of it as nepotism - if I know someone sucks from working with them, you better believe I'm making sure I warn everyone if I see them in the pipeline. It's not about pulling friends, it's about pulling people you know are good.

reply
That's it. Employing someone is a risk for a company. At the really bad tail end you can hire someone who contributes negative value, is good at hiding that, poisons the culture, and in the end sues you for whatever.

If you've worked for a few months on a team with a competent, decent and reliable person, you'll give this person a huge preference over someone unknown, even if on paper the unknown looks better.

reply
It's technically not nepotism because they aren't specifically favoring family, but it is cronyism because they are favoring friends, peers, and close associates.
reply
Option A is no longer sufficient on its own.
reply
> It's not really nepotism, it's looking for trust.

Well yes, "trust" is the entire point of nepotism and why its a thing.

reply
I have to disagree here, the main point of nepotism is self-service and the corruption of institutions.

The idea is we place our guy in that spot so that a) our guy gets to reap the benefits of the cushy job we lined up for him. b) when conflict arises between our interests and the organizations we can count on our guy to do the thing we want.

The thing I am describing above is much more benign. It's literally HR asking people in the company if they know anyone they would like to refer and then taking the referrals seriously.

reply