upvote
What about security issues? What about the fact that if AI isn't hardening your code under your control, it's hacking it under an adversary's?
reply
Did it come across as dismissive of security issues? I apologise. The security issues are exactly what’s being weighed against those other issues. Both the security issues and the other issues are valid issues and it’s valid to weigh them against each other.

And I sort of understand what you’re trying to say in that second line, something along the lines of “the only thing that stops a bad guy with a gun, is a good guy with a gun”, right? Unfortunately it’s poorly phrased.

If AI isn’t hardening my code, then my code is very vulnerable to AI hacking from an adversary, I’ll grant that. But an absence of my AI does not cause the presence of an adversary’s AI in the way that the binary construction claims. (Compare “if you’re not with us, you’re against us”, which is a threat that says the absence of your fealty does cause the presence of my hostility.)

Likewise, I’ll grant that AI hardening my code does mitigate the damage from AI hacking, but again its presence does not cause the absence of an adversary’s AI hacking in the way your phrasing says it does.

reply