Or are you saying that the "mythical AI" is mythical because people are using it without putting in any effort, therefore producing poor results? If that's the core of your argument, it sounds like the mythical AI could be out there and you'd not know it because those around you are, to coin a phrase, using it wrong.
I'm kind of struck though that your experience seems to all be second hand (people are using AI and submitting bad code); do you not have any first-hand experience with using claude code and fable?
I'm saying that most code I see AI generate is frequently bad, in ways that nobody disputes, not even the engineers who sent me the code to review - they themselves previously always avoided those exact problems when they used to write the code by hand.
> Or are you saying that the "mythical AI" is mythical because people are using it without putting in any effort, therefore producing poor results?
This also happens.
> If that's the core of your argument, it sounds like the mythical AI could be out there and you'd not know it because those around you are, to coin a phrase, using it wrong.
If you hired a brilliant math PhD who always wrote bad code and you had to keep reviewing every single thing they did and getting them to rewrite their code until it met the quality bar every time, and they never learned from their mistakes from one project to the next so this was a persistent issue, but they were so fast that even micromanaging them let you achieve a better outcome faster than you would have alone, what would you call that? That's what AI feels like.
> do you not have any first-hand experience with using claude code and fable?
I certainly do. But for anything meaty I frequently end up rejecting most of the code they produce before they get to other reviewers, and even then, I frequently have to do more work on them by hand. In some cases I've quite literally had to restart a project half a dozen times from scratch - with different approaches each time - in order to reach results that I'm not disgusted with.
Note that I'm not claiming to be an expert in using AI by any stretch - I'm still very much learning - but that I'm not really seeing these mythical results from others either.