upvote
Parent comment has been flagged to death, so I can't see it. There are thoughtful and helpful (i.e. "good") ways of bringing it up, and not-so-good ones. Maybe this was a case of the latter. One thing though that should be obvious to all parties and not need saying is that a grammar/spelling/usage complaint is precisely not the act of engaging with the content of the text. It's a separate point. I would even say a lesser point, agreeing with what you hint at. But making it off-limits unfortunately enshrines poor workmanship as unassailable. Nonetheless, HN thinks the lesser point is boring and distracting, well fair enough, but then can we also get rid of all the comments speculating and complaining about what was or wasn't AI-written? That's just as "meta" as the English stuff.
reply