upvote
Correct. You can even go back to things like the Shaker furniture or the history of the suit, or money itself. My point is that it is interesting how maximizing profit will always lead to thinsg merging and so eventually you'll reach a point of only one per category.

Think about it like this, 15~20 years ago, each company was building an operating system: Simbian, Windows Phone, Windows Mobile, various Linux based phones, Android, iOS, Blackberry OS, Palm OS, Firefox OS, Ubuntu's Unity Mobile... But then with the rise of iOS/Android, the cost of building something for each platform sky rocketed, you could have ten people each making the same tool for a different OS, or each making a different tool for the same OS. On the other hand it was easier to write one software for Android, and install Android everywhere, instead of having ten different apps for ten different OSes, and a company could install Android on their phones and have a smart phone, the other could make a whole operating system and only when all of the Anroid apps were available to their os it would have become feasible.

So efficiency and optimization always means the death of variety. You can have many programming languages with no good libraries, or a crappy JavaScript and C that have everything available to them... We all chose the latter.

reply
But this was because software was expensive. Actually now this could be the only field where the trend could be reversed. You could make any niche platform, and porting apps over would be a few dollars and some minutes.
reply
Miss me with your vibe-coded OS
reply
And are all Android phones the same? You can have one with liquid cooling of battery and turbo fan cooler for CPU! Same will be with the car. You can make so many different designs with standard parts!
reply
Yeah but most of the phones I see have the same look, same camera array, same all-screen look and camera notch. Like how all laptops are almost the same.

The OS as far as I'm concerned is the same Android with its Material Design and UI rules. Sure, that makes using it easy and that is all that matters, but hey if you go one step more radical you'll see the difference between Windows Phone's Metro, and iOS, if you go even further you end up with forms like Smalltalk and even more so with things like Ivan Sutherland's Sketchpad. Things can be way, way more different but we get the same navigation bars, carts, boxes, icons, ideas... across all our software.

reply
Kind of. Some are bad, some are even worse. We were told and thought that future will bring us mass customization. That was 30-40 years ago. And all we got are these cars, phones, computers, microwaves... looking the same, doing the same, costing the same, and all are equally useless and shitty. Such a future.
reply
There are all sorts of cars, phones, appliances. People choose to buy the same biting stuff. Even colours, look at the parking lot! all cars are either black, white or gray.
reply
yeah, why is that? even resale value should be higher for anything than yet another ugly silver car.
reply
Standardization also has an intrinsic value. Think of traffic signs.
reply
Headlights have gone the other direction in my lifetime, to the point where I see more hazed and cracked lenses than I see good ones - bespoke replacements are too expensive to bother with.

Was chatting with the local hardware store owner a few weeks back about bulbs and solenoids - there are standards, but the breadth of different types in cars on the road means it isn't worth the shelf space to stock them - individual types move slowly while stocking enough variety to cover what the local market needs takes space away from more profitable things (like metric-thread fasteners).

Even nearby auto parts store end up ordering common parts from regional warehouses, putting them on roughly equal footing with RockAuto in terms of time to delivery (and of course at a disadvantage on price).

And this doesn't even get into truly unique parts like door latch motors or the various ICs that control various subsystems.

Frankly, it's a mess. Having a spare "parts car" sitting around is best if you have the space for it.

reply
Standardized? For a century?

I can't count on both hands the number of different types of battery, spark plug, fuse, or indicator lamp I've encountered.

And I've never worked on a car that was produced prior to 1979.

reply
Sure, but to be fair, for cars manufactured across the same decade or two, at least going back to maybe the 50s or so (when 12V became "standard") and up to around 2010-ish - there was a small enough range of those things that I would have a reasonably good chance of getting on at the nearest gas station (well, "service station" since I'm in .au).

There were "step changes", like when headlights went from sealed beams to halogen bulbs in reflectors, You either had 6" or 8" sealed beams, or most likely H4 halogen bulbs (or a single filament bulb I've forgotten if you had separate low/high beam lights). If you had a headlight out, it mostly didn't matter what model car you had, or of it was a Ford or a VW or a Leyland, they all used one of 4 types of bulbs and they were all interchangeable.

In my head, and this is more motorcycle specific than car specific, but likely indicative across the entire automotive industry, it was the early 2000s when that started to change. My 1991 and 1998 Hondas and my 1999 Ducati and my 2004 Cagiva all used H4 headlight globes and the same 10/25W tail/brake light globes. My 2009 Yamaha was the first bike I owned where I had to buy headlight globes from Yamaha.

reply
Once upon a time, headlight bulbs used to be more-standard than they are. Or at least: They were from my US perspective.

I've had cars with 9006/9007 headlight bulbs. Those were OK, I guess, other than the polycarbonate housings that turn into a clouded quagmire of shit when exposed to sunlight.

My 2012 Honda uses D2S headlight bulbs. That's a metal-halide part and it does not interchange with any other format, including other metal-halide parts. Each also requires both ballast and igniter assemblies. (Once lit, the bulb itself runs on [IIRC] 35V. But it takes a few kiloVolts to get it to initially arc over, vaporize some metallic salts, and start making light. And none of those volts are the ~12V that the car's electrical system produces.)

But at least it can use ~any regular D2S bulb. More-modern cars often use LED assemblies that aren't interchangeable between models at all.

But, yes: For decades in sealed-beam automobile world, we had a couple of sizes for round, and a couple of sizes for rectangular, and these sizes included the whole light-producing assembly, with focusing elements and the whole shebang. Some included a high-beam filament and some kept that separate, but: Any of these were very normal (standardized) things that anyone could pick up at ~any place selling auto parts and swap out with a screwdriver and whatever it takes to remove some trim.

(I've lived long enough to have seen sealed-beam headlight assemblies on shelves at small-town grocery stores. I have every confidence that if I rolled into the parking lot of such a store with a burnt-out halogen headlight in nineteen-eighty-something, then I'd be able to buy one and borrow enough basic hand tools to replace it in their parking lot in fairly short order. I'd probably also have paid Way Too Much for the headlight assembly itself, but I'd have been very grateful anyway. Convenience has a cost, even in matters of safety.)

reply
"Standardized" in the same sense that screw threads are standardized. That doesn't mean collapsing all the way down to a one-size-fits-all part.
reply
I can think of at least 3 types of car battery terminal in-use today: The old top-post, GM's side-post, and Toyota's (close-but-not-the-same!) top-post. And that's just the terminals -- nevermind the different sizes and mounting configurations.

I can screw in any of a whole galaxy of spark plugs into my Honda's engine, but that doesn't mean that the pistons won't collide with them before reaching TDC. (Does it matter if the screw threads are compatible when the parts crash before they can be used?)

Do we really have to talk about the light bulbs and the fuses, too? It's pretty boring, but I'll be bored later if anyone really wants to get into that.

(I'd like some popcorn, first, if anyone feels like contributing something.)

reply
Somehow, LEDs made lightbulbs even worse. I have 7 different types of lightbulbs I need in my house. 7! Two of them aren't even screws. Wait, no, there's 8, I forgot the LED strips as well with the JSTs. Actually, nine if you include USB. Wait, ten, because there's USB-A and USB-C.
reply