upvote
Manufactures like SC Johnson (Windex maker) pay major retailers for shelf space. The more variety, the less shelf space a competitor has.

That’s why there’s 100 different toothpastes that all effectively are the same.

reply
FYI stannous fluoride is not usually the default floride salt (versus historic sodium fluoride), and you still have to consciously make an effort to seek it out.
reply
Hydroxyapatite is what you want in your toothpaste. It remineralizes your teeth so they get stronger. Also, autobrush.
reply
HAP/c-HAP toothpaste is not readily available in retail where I live, and I don’t think I want to pay shipping for toothpaste.

I’ve also had good feedback from my dentist re: manual brushing and “essential” toothpaste (of which I have a national stockpile) so I will use that up before venturing into something exotic.

reply
Just use sensodyne repair and protect. Im not paid by GSK it's just what I use :)
reply
Or avoid fluoride entirely. Straight baking soda works fine and is less likely to have lead in it.
reply
But baking soda doesn't have fluoride to remineralize teeth?
reply
Do you have something against floppy teeth?
reply
Are there different types of glass cleaner? Windex and off-brand windex is all i notice at the store
reply
At a minimum there's ammonia based and ammonia-free. The latter can be important for certain window tints.
reply
hehe yeah not the best example, let's replace glass cleaner with shampoo, toothpaste, soap, any kind of commodity product!

all these brands spend so much money in advertising just to convince people that their product (which is probably 95% the same as any other one) is the best.

what a waste of resource and money.

reply
> hehe yeah not the best example, let's replace glass cleaner with shampoo, toothpaste, soap, any kind of commodity product!

Soap isn't quite soap, though. Like with a certain brand of soap I was using, once I had used like maybe two thirds or three quarters of it, the remaining bit would somehow always sort of dry out or something and no longer foam up properly when washing hands. Whereas a different brand of soap remains perfectly useable all the way to the end.

reply
Not to get all socialism on hn, but these kinds of products would be perfect for making publicly owned corps around. The kind of companies that won’t move production offshore so the shareholders can get a bigger payout.
reply
Shampoo is a terrible example, there's all sorts of different shampoos for different hair and scalp chemistry, where using the wrong one for you can cause skin issues
reply
Asked a window cleaner what they actually use many years ago. The answer? Washing up liquid. Ye olde Yes/Fairy/Dawn/Salvo. So, we don't seem to have figured out the best product to use yet.
reply
Most car guys I used to run with used vinegar and newspaper. Works great, but unfortunately newspaper isn't easy to find anymore...
reply
This is (was?) great for the inside of the windscreen - on cars with plastic dashboards the plasticizers evaporate out in the heat of the sun and condense on the glass. Vinegar and newspaper would clean that off really well, where window cleaner would mostly just smear it around. I was an especially useful thing to know if you were the sort of person who shined up the dashboard with Armourall every time you washed your car.
reply
I agree this is what works best! but It's a bit messy inside.
reply
isn't that literally the case for any kind of cleaners? why have so many varieties of soaps, shampoos, etc. at that point?
reply
There is a part of me that wishes there was a supermarket with all-white boxes just labelled "flour", "shampoo" etc and that all cars looked the same.

More seriously, I suppose it's because you want competitive markets and products can vary along multiple dimensions like price, size, ingredients / composition, ethical claims, consumer targeting, etc.

I'm reminded of one of my favourite historical Onion articles: https://theonion.com/consumer-product-diversity-now-exceeds-...

“As more and more species fall victim to extinction, we face a grave crisis of decreased diversity, not only in America but across the globe,” Hargrove said. “But the good news is, these losses in biodiversity are more than offset by a corresponding rise in consumer-product diversity. Though flora and fauna are dwindling, the spectrum of goods available to consumers is wider than at any time in planetary history. And that’s something we can all be happy about.”

reply
For a long time, that was kind of how Aldi (in the US) operated:

Need canned beans? Fine, no worries: Baked beans, black beans, pintos, red beans, refried, whatever -- they're all on the shelf... and they're all labeled with one of Aldi's in-house brands.

It was generally the same with the meat and the cheese and the produce and ~everything else, too. Ribs? Ribeyes? Fresh salmon? They probably had it, and there was definitely only one brand to pick from -- whichever one of Aldi's house brands fit that broader category.

(It's softened somewhat in recent years. Nowadays, I can select a block of [fucking-outstanding for-the-price] aged cheddar cheese with an Aldi house label, or a competitive product at a somewhat higher price with a Cabot label. They're stocked next to eachother.)

reply
That's fine when that product suits your tastes, but is a problem when it doesn't, because then you have no alternative choice to fall back on.

E.g. even cornflakes – first of all, if you really want to standardise on one single "cornflakes" product, does that mean sweetened or unsweetened cornflakes? If it's the former, I already loose out, because I prefer the latter. (I sweeten them myself if necessary.) And even among the latter category, I've observed some definite variation in both taste and shape/size distribution of the cornflakes, leading to me preferring a certain brand over others.

reply
To be clear, I'm not necessarily in favor of some grand concept like removing consumer choice because a few people think that it would be simpler for them or satisfy some misapplied sense of self-entitlement.

I want you to be able to get as many different kinds of corn flakes as you desire, with as many strange animal, flower, or Dali paintings as you wish for box art -- or very plain. Some GMO, some not. There should be a variety of manufacturing techniques for you to select betwixt, with stable variations in things like shape/size distribution. They can be sweetened with HFCS, cane sugar, stevia, real honey, or as plain and drab as that puritanical Kellogg himself intended.

Maybe you can't get them all at the same place, but whatever: You should then be able to walk somewhere else, or get back in your car, or on the train, hail someone else's flying EV while it's in Revenue Mode, or maybe just have the bot drop it off on the porch later this afternoon, or whatever: You should be able to get that done.

I like variety, myself. And there was definitely a time when I had a lot more mouths to feed when I'd go into an Aldi (in the US), and pick up only the selection of meat, cheese, produce, and canned goods that I preferred -- for whatever reason I preferred that.

It was also like a scavenger hunt -- maybe Aldi didn't have any fresh mushrooms this month at all, or maybe they'd have them at such a fantastic price that I'd have been a fool to buy them anywhere else.

That visit could account for maybe 60% of my grocery shopping for a week, say. The rest would be purchased from Somewhere Else. That worked fine for me, although it did motivate me to accomplish a lot of meal planning based around whatever the Aldi flyer said was cheap this week.

But again, I'm not thinking that a given store should be forced to cater to every whim. Or any particular whim at all, really.

If you or someone else wants to build a grocery store that sells only corn flakes of some preferred kind and quality, with some preferred packaging, then: You should be able to do that, and you should have all of the freedom to sink or swim in that venture that the combination of the marketplace and your coffers allows for. If you want instead to build a grocery store that carries as many varieties of corn flakes as possible, from every corner of the globe, then: Knock yourself out.

I might not shop there at all, ever. Or I might work hard to buy whatever it is you have to offer. (That part is up to me.)

reply
That's pretty much how Trader Joe's is in the US; in fact, IIRC TJ's is owned by one of the Aldi companies.
reply
Yep TJs is Aldi Nord.
reply
It's a thing in canada, sorta: https://www.pcexpress.ca/noname
reply
I just want product packages to be standard sizes and shapes, so that other things can be made to fit them perfectly.

eg. Breakfast cereal boxes should be small, medium, and large, regardless of brand (and "large" and "medium" should differ only in width). Then shelves and cabinets can be sized to fit the ISO standard cereal box with no wasted space. Same with dish soap. Etc.

reply
At that point isn't that going in the direction of "all humans should be the same"? no various scented soaps or certain types of flour better for certain types of baked goods that people prefer or even need (like gluten free)?
reply
You could always order your own chemicals and make your own. We have diluted our own hydrogen peroxide ever since cleaning products were unavailable during COVID. Lab supply stores will ship you 32oz containers of food grade ~30%. That plus the remainder of water on a 2 gallon container is basically cleaning-grade and lasts quite a while.
reply
Higher percentage peroxide breaks down faster than low percentage stuff. You'll want to be careful with 30% (that is quite strong), and store it in appropriate conditions (if I'm not mistaken, a fridge)

General principle you bring up I agree with, but the example is interesting for this issue/reason

reply
3% feels more than enough for anything, and is cheap.

I’m curious your lifestyle and usecase!

reply
yeah I think my example was poor. like dishwasher soap, why do we still have 4-5 brands competing for basically what is essentially the same product.
reply
Because without marketing everything would be treated like a commodity? Just a guess.
reply
I'm fascinated you think the market will produce a best product and then stop. Most of what the market does is figure out how to sell people a shittier product at a higher price.
reply