upvote
I think it very much depends on how this is implemented. Some things simply don't need to have design changes almost ever because it it is a solved problem. Some things just need to share attachment points to be swapped with other or better versions. Like why do we need 20 different oil filter styles for 20 different cars? Why is one car battery 1/2 inch longer so it doesn't fit in another cars battery tray despite being the same capacity? Why do we need 20 different tierod ends on 20 different cars when a single design would work with 80% of them?
reply
Several commentators mention batteries. Is this an issue in the US?

In Europe every car I've had has had roughly interchangeable batteries. There might be two or three different sizes for family petrol cars. That seems like a reasonable amount of useful variation for manufacturers to choose between when playing Tetris with all the components they need to fit alongside the engine.

reply
Agree and disagree, a framework of standardized motor and frame, unibody or frame on body would be great.

Do we really need a new car to look cosmetically different every few years to spur sales and say “new?” At the same time this means they can still customize the sheet metal, for different trims and types but the motor is the same, transmission is the same, seat is the same, etc

And for those parts, do we really need new part numbers every year? Heterogeneous is great? But something something Henry ford you can have any color as long as it’s black is also ok.

Plus it isn’t really new, brand engineering is this. Toyota grabs the bmw z4 and makes it a Supra, Mazda grabs the rav4 and makes it the cx50, etc

reply
Tesla has basically proven the answer is no.

And personally I think most cars have been getting uglier. I would’ve been happy if they stuck with what they had 10 years ago.

So yeah, if you wanna save money, stop wasting it on a new redesign every few years. Don’t waste the money retooling to change random things every year.

reply
Trabant and Wartburg also have, long ago ;).
reply
Those and 911 had proven it's an ok engineering decision and a commercial suicide at the same time.
reply
^ This commenter enjoys real cars
reply
Tesla is an example of an actual opposite. Their best-selling model is the last one released, the refreshed Models Y and 3. Ones they try to keep selling year after year have been discontinued.
reply
Wasn’t the last one released the Cybertruck?
reply
Refreshed Y and 3 came out after the Cybertruck
reply
wasn't the last one to release the cybertruck?
reply
Car manufacturers have been doing this since the early 1900s. They call these designs “platforms” or “vehicle architectures.”

They might do a cosmetic facelift every couple of years but the platform will typically stay in production for a decade or so.

GM in particular are famous for using the same chassis, drivetrain, floorpan etc on half a dozen or more models across their marques.

reply
For me someone who does most of my car maintenance and repairs this would be very attractive knowing that parts were standardized and by doing so would guarantee that there would be a huge aftermarket parts marker since one part could target multiple models and this would mean competitive prices thus lowering the cost of repairs.

Still, however, as great as cheap available parts would be.. the major car brands desperately need to find ways to significantly lower the price of their cars. New cars and trucks are reaching the prices of like a big down payment you could put on a house. Standardized parts would definitely reduce costs but would that be enough? Even many 2 income households struggle to get ahead. In my opinion the number one priority of these companies should be how can they make an inexpensive car that the average person can afford.

reply
Well, at least in Europe, the cost problem may be due to regulations and safety gimmicks. Look into the madness of GSR2.
reply
> Do we really need a new car to look cosmetically different every few years to spur sales and say “new?”

The problem that I have with cars in general is that they use pretty old technology and you want something new that actually works OK and it does not have that much lag. While I understand the myth about manufacturers using old components because they are proven, they should get over it and use circuits made in the 21st century. Reliability has grown a lot, we don't need vacuum tubes in the cars anymore (I am being sarcastic about the vacuum tubes).

Another thing is the subtle but annoying differences in cars in different geographies: in one country you have a 360-degree camera system, but in others they don't even offer it as an add-on. For the same car. And other little things.

What I would like to see though would be to have the ability to upgrade the hardware in the car every 2-3 years. Like replace 2-3 "boxes" full of components and have "an almost new car" with improved technology.

reply
> Reliability has grown a lot, we don't need vacuum tubes in the cars anymore (I am being sarcastic about the vacuum tubes).

This is a rather unenlightened take. The electronics used in cars aren't typical consumer gear - the parts are much more rugged. This is for good reason. The same car could start life parked on the side of the road in the nevada desert (wild temperature fluctuations), go on a roadtrip through death valley in the summer, and a few years later be parked on the street in florida (ridiculously humid) or somewhere in north dakota (extreme cold). Meanwhile we expect not to have any major electrical issues over a 20+ year product life. It's actually fairly absurd when you stop and think about it.

reply
> The electronics used in cars aren't typical consumer gear - the parts are much more rugged.

Do you think they make regular and -Q1 parts on different photolithography machines from different silicon? Nope, the only difference is post production testing and price.

reply
lot more than just silicon goes into electronics. even with IC's, the wafer has gets combine with other parts to become a packaged IC that can be qualified.

PCB's, wired, solder, resistors, capacitors, connectors, cases

yes, testing is more. But there is a lot more in the manufacturing side for a qualified part.

reply
Solid state components tend to last. It seems quite common to rescue a 40 year old consumer PC from a junk pile and find that it still works. An iPhone can also visit Nevada, Florida, and North Dakota and continue working just fine too.
reply
> PC from a junk pile

A junk pile in residential storage, sure.

> An iPhone can also visit ...

Try leaving it out in the backyard in north dakota for a full year and see how long it lasts.

reply
I don’t think it is an unenlightened and absurd take.

A Tesla does not use 5-10 years old chips and works in all environments.

All of the things you mentioned are telated to the metallic components of a car. If I take the battery out of my phone, and connect it only when needed, it will work just the same.

Again, this myth of old electronics are better for a car needs to be put to rest.

reply
I'd prefer them to keep using the old parts if they work. That way I am more likely to be able to take it to an independent garage who will have compatible parts, rather than taking it to the dealership & paying a premium as well as waiting for ages for them to ship the brand new part in.
reply
For them to stay competitive as independent companies? Of course! Otherwise they look identical and have the same parts, and their only competitive difference is what? Pricing? On the same parts?

They might as well merge now and save the drama.

reply
If they standardize internal components like tie rods, wheel bearings and battery trays, I doubt anyone would think the cars look the same. In fact, I think this would be great: standardise the jelly bean parts that don't really change much and don't see much innovation. There is absolutely no reason that different cars should use different incompatible 12 V batteries when the capacity is identical.
reply
Engineers select different parts for different tradeoffs.

If all the parts are the same, everything will perform the same. Every brand will wear out at the same time. The cars will corner the same, accelerate the same.

Thus, no brand differentiation in the market.

reply
If all the 12v batteries had the same capacity and specs, there was already no differentiation.

if only one size 12v battery ‘exists’, then no one can have a bigger engine (requires a bigger starter and battery) or more electronics (requires a bigger battery, etc.).

also no ability to be more efficent, as they all have the same battery anyway and the same electronics and engine, eh?

either way, no meaningful differentiation.

if so, just merge into one company already eh?

reply
> Otherwise they look identical

Hasn't this ship already sailed?

reply
> For them to stay competitive as independent companies? Of course! Otherwise they look identical and have the same parts, and their only competitive difference is what? Pricing? On the same parts?

What makes you think they'd look identical? You think the only parts in a car are cosmetic parts?

reply
vehicle exterior and interior dimensions, trim, etc. all effect part dimensions and compositions and ultimately capabilities. except maybe colors.

how else do you think this all works?

reply
> vehicle exterior and interior dimensions, trim, etc. all effect part dimensions and compositions and ultimately capabilities. except maybe colors.

Nope

> how else do you think this all works?

As someone who actually has built-up cars in the past, and currently hand-building a lotus replica, I can assure you that I know how all this works, and speak from a position of authority on parts, compatibility and dimensions.

reply
Uh huh, so if everyone has the same transmission how do you differentiate on power?

Oh, your experience is expressly when nothing is standard, and you pick and place from a entire catalog of non standard parts? Weird.

Especially since you don’t have to actually meet regulatory or emissions standards which they do?

So not actually applicable at all?

reply
> Especially since you don’t have to actually meet regulatory or emissions standards which they do?

Built-up cars (as in, building up from a wreck), do have to meet standards.

Since the rest of your argument relies on me not knowing what I am doing, there's really no point in continuing this thread.

reply
[dead]
reply
For most parts, they are actually just (unnecessarily) designed to be not compatible so that the manufacturer will take profit from parts as well. Incompatibility becomes a feature for profit, not for anything else. This might actually be good for competition because now a small company can start with less money and standardized parts and focus on things they can actually make a difference.
reply
Ferrari would use parts from other car companies. What Ferrari cared about was the engine.
reply
Part of the reason Japanese cars had trouble getting a toehold in the Midwest is that American cars already had suppliers in common so it was more likely they had a set of rotors for your random Ford and they had to order them for your Subaru. That was also before people read some of the books on supply chains so those orders took longer.
reply
if the US market thought it can compete or win certain markets then the door would be open. FOR: Smartphone, Software, AI models, EV Cars, Routers, etc,

The reason is because Cybersecurity is a priority for us and the Chinese are spying on us blah blah. I know for sure that cybercrime was no where as frequent as today, and with that not only is it from china anymore along with a much larger scale of intrusion and theft.

reply
[flagged]
reply