upvote
You're not wrong. From what I've seen, the Japanese firms need someone internal to act as a champion to do the organizational push and overcome inertia. For the Toyota Hybrid system in the Prius, that was Takeshi Uchiyamada - Chairman of Toyota Motor Corporation during it's development.

The first generation Prius was technically amazing but not much to look at (a coworker had one - "bland" is how I would describe it). It sold in low numbers, allowing Toyota to build expertise with the technology before the second gen became a smash hit.

They're following the same plan for their BEVs. The Toyota bZ was nothing special in terms of electric vehicles, but they just finished building a battery factory in the US to scale production up for their next generation.

https://pressroom.toyota.com/toyota-supercharges-north-carol...

The question is whether they're acting fast enough. BYD and other Chinese makers are screaming fast when it comes to introducing new models. While the Chinese haven't entered the US market directly - they're already here in terms of Waymo's Ojai vans, which are made by Zeekr, a subsidiary of Geely.

reply
One of the main reasons Toyotas are perceived to be so reliable is their refusal to innovate. The last generation Tundra was made for 14 years with almost the same technology the entire time and as a result is one of the most reliable vehicles ever made.

The new generation tundras with an “innovative” ICE and hybrid motor, both based on the same 6 cylinder design, are having widespread and catastrophic engine failure.

reply
My prediction is that the US makers will rebrand some existing models (Chinese or more likely European) and assemble them in the US in order to jumpstart the industry.

In Japan I have no idea what will happen. Yes they've shown they can innovate. And Toyota can last a long time on their reputation for quality. But I have no idea how much they need to sell a ton of cars to survive. The transition will take a long time[1] (saving grace for them). I'm sure the global sales volume of ICE cars will start declining very soon, if not already.

[1] Or not. If battery costs drop suddenly, it's game over.

reply
Global ICE sales are already declining.

With the US/Israel/Iran war, this year's sales seem likely to be less again.

https://ourworldindata.org/data-insights/global-sales-of-com...

reply
In some markets, the US notably, electric cars are kind of a curiosity. I think the main issue is that, at the low end, the total cost of ownership of an entry level Tesla or similar is rather high relative to something like a hybrid Corolla. At the high end, electric trucks are insanely expensive and less practical than gas trucks.
reply
> I think the main issue is that, at the low end, the total cost of ownership of an entry level Tesla or similar is rather high relative to something like a hybrid Corolla.

The problem there is you're comparing a Corolla to a Tesla and not e.g. a Chevy Bolt, which has a lower TCO than both.

> At the high end, electric trucks are insanely expensive and less practical than gas trucks.

There is a reason companies like Amazon use electric delivery trucks and it's not because they're impractical.

The main issue with trucks is that to give an electric truck a reasonable range when hauling a load, it needs a much bigger battery, and then to justify that you have to be actually using it as a truck full-time rather than as a truck-shaped car. Which is fully justified when you are, because then the fuel savings are enormous.

Whereas the people not really using it as a truck don't really need the bigger battery and then it doesn't have to cost that much. And even that isn't going to matter if the battery prices keep going down.

The other option which the US companies seem to be leaning into is to use the smaller battery and offer a range extender that runs on gas, which is a hybrid in a sense but it's more like an EV with a slot to put a gas generator.

reply
> offer a range extender that runs on gas, which is a hybrid in a sense but it's more like an EV with a slot to put a gas generator.

The industry is kinda moving in that direction anyway, even for personal vehicles.

We’re seeing a number of new “hybrids” (that are really tiny EREVs, EV vehicles with no charging port and cheap tiny batteries, tied to a gas generator). Reduces complexity drastically while keeping most of the fuel efficiency

(See the new 2027 Nissan Rogue Hybrid, or the 2027 Hyundai Santa Fe Hybrid. Both going EREV, and assembled in plants in the USA)

If the industry continues down that route, every car will be an EV and your just picking how large a battery you want vs how large of a gas generator you attach to it.

reply
The price difference between a hybrid or ICE version of the same model of Toyota, if the consumer is concerned with gas mileage alone, will take longer to reconcile than most will own the vehicle.

The average new car buyer is not very good at math or they wouldn’t be there in the first place.

reply
Electric trucks make complete sense for stop start delivery. We had electric milk floats universally in the UK 60 years ago.
reply
Corolla is not in the same category as Bolt. It’s closer to Model 3, and beats it at 60% the cost and 5 minute “refill”.
reply
The Model 3 is in an entirely different class than a Corolla. It's not even close in nearly every metric you can conceive: horsepower, acceleration, interior, cargo capacity, efficiency, tech, assist, ongoing updates, etc. The fact that the TCO between them is actually comparable is a huge win for the Model 3.

Remember when everyone was going wild over the fact that Elon was promising a sub-$25K EV? That was in 2018. Today, a Model 3 goes for $22K (in 2018 dollars). People aren't paying attention.

(Edit: Sorry I typo'd the amount in the CPI inflation calculator. Should be $27K, not $22K. Still, in the $25K ballpark).

reply
> The Model 3 is in an entirely different class than a Corolla.

I am not sure that median U.S. driver really thinks that. After all, both are about the same size and serve a similar purpose. The Tesla is a lot faster, but for city driving and commuting the difference hardly matters.

Things like "tech" and "ongoing updates" are a negative for some people. Inevitably, this means more things that can fail and more opportunities for manufacturers and third parties to mistreat the driver. I, for one, require my car to be offline, with its cellular modem physically powered off.

reply
They said TCO
reply
Does TCO include insurance and registration, both higher for EVs? Or is it just purchase price, fuel and maintenance?
reply
in the US, TCO of any EV will only beat a Toyota hybrid if you charge at home. Really the TCO of home charged EVs should include the cost of the home. And comparisons of environmental damages associated with the vehicle types should include the home or apartment construction, heating, etc.
reply
Maybe this is a terminology issue but isn’t Amazon using electric vans? I understood the trucks GP talks about are the Ford F150 Lightning and the likes (justifies the high end label).

For city deliveries an EV is a no-brainer. Short distances with lost of start-stops, lots of idling, perfect for an electric motor. An electric F150 will have very different usage pattern and TCO.

reply
> There is a reason companies like Amazon use electric delivery trucks and it's not because they're impractical.

Right. It's subsidies/incentives. And, of course, operating within the legal/governance structure, you can 'fine' the vehicles you don't like - have special clean air zones with fees for entry, high tax for oil/petrol, etc.

I hope you didn't mean this was something to do with costs. It's just the government using licensing, laws, taxes, etc to direct proceedings as they want - nothing to do with the underlying costs.

reply
Large delivery trucks get like 10 MPG when they run on gasoline, and even worse than that in stop and go. Operating one full time puts its fuel consumption in the tens of thousands of dollars a year. Eliminating two thirds of that by using EVs pays for itself straight away without any subsidies.
reply
More like 4mpg. On diesel they get 10mpg. Which is why diesel has long been popular in trucks
reply
> I think the main issue is that, at the low end, the total cost of ownership of an entry level Tesla or similar is rather high relative to something like a hybrid Corolla.

The main issue is that the US effectively bans imports of electric cars from the most efficient suppliers on the planet.

reply
An entry level Tesla is kind of a luxury car though. It costs twice as much as a Dacia Spring and Chinese models are much better value, or so I’ve heard.
reply
It depends what you value. If you value software quality and UX too, Tesla still has a competitive offer.
reply
Tesla also comes with massive political baggage in the form of Musk.

His interference in elections and the war in Ukraine hasn’t gone unnoticed in many markets. Tesla comes with weaker residual value because of the brand damage.

Now that other manufacturers are moving away from soft-screens towards tactile controls software UX is much less important too.

Personally, I’d much rather have “knob per function” than have to go menu diving through a GUI at 80mph.

There’s many great alternatives now that really are great value. i.e. Renault, Nissan, Skoda, VW, BMW, Dacha.

reply
Have you tried the self-driving on the latest hardware on Teslas? It's so good, it will blow your mind. I have owned a Y since January this year and have put around 13k miles on it so far. 98% of them are self-driven. I truly never want to go back to a car without this feature.
reply
Can I safely read a book or be intoxicated while “self-driving”? Otherwise it’s just automating the easy part.
reply
Yes. I don’t own one but I’ve been in the driver’s seat of a friend’s and my hands were in my lap for an entire 26-minute test drive along small winding roads and next to water. The car owner has always told me FSD has long been best on the highway than smaller roads with weird nonstandard things. I’ve also been in multiple Robotaxi rides in the past couple months, and some were in the Cybercab which has no steering wheel.
reply
Was your friend intoxicated or he had to take control of the car in a split second?
reply
Fair point, but those are regulatory changes, not technology ones. You can both read a book and be intoxicated if you are in an area zoned for full autonomous driving.
reply
Check out the videos of the Tesla Cybercab on YouTube, eg https://youtu.be/kRymvULv0p4
reply
Have you driven in one? It's automating all of the parts, and you are just high level monitoring it.
reply
I haven’t. Sitting there ready to take control is the same as me sitting there driving. If I’m liable for an accident I’m not going to give away control.

Self-driving cars, the kind that doesn’t put a human on the hook would be amazing. I can read a book, work on my laptop or even take a nap in the backseat. I want a driver without having to pay a human for it.

reply
You might think that, but I can tell you both from my experience, and from others I know that have driven in them, it really isn't.
reply
Not sure I understand. Either they require you to sit in the drivers seat or they don’t. If I can get a DUI from “self-driving” I’d rather save that money for a taxi.
reply
[flagged]
reply
Also European: Chat Control, DSA
reply
How many European manufactured EVs are there that aren't just assembled from foreign batteries and parts?
reply
I think most of them use locally (European) produced parts.

For instance, Renault use cells manufactured in France, Poland and Hungary with AESC in Douai, France as the main supplier.

Nissan have major EV manufacturing for the new Leaf at Sunderland, UK and AESC has a gigafactory for that near by too.

reply
the statement was: support. so if its a bit better then thats already right direction.
reply
I drove a VW ID recently and you have plenty of physical buttons everywhere you look as the driver, yet some important features are behind the touch screen.

If you ignore the ongoing nazi car brand aspect, which is pretty hard to I agree, I am not convinced the traditional car brands you mentioned are better value. And they have a nazi past too. But that’s a while ago so it’s okay.

reply
Dieselgate stochastically killed a lot of people recently.
reply
Very few people ever cared about that in the US. Diesel cars are a rounding error in total passenger vehicle sales.
reply
My grandfather still cared about the Nazi thing and refused to ever buy a German car. I doubt more still cared about that than Dieselgate.
reply
OK, if don’t like German car brands because of their past there’s still Renault (French) and Nissan (Japanese).

Both have reasonably priced, well engineered EVs in their range now.

Both use Android Auto and IMHO that works very smoothly and without jank. Plus they have physical controls.

Personally it’s a company’s present and future behaviour that I care most about rather than stuff that happened in the 1930s and 40s no matter how horrific.

reply
I'm not sure Renault is a strong improvement in terms of nazi collaboration.

You do you, the Nissan Ariya or the Renault Scenic aren't that bad indeed.

reply
[flagged]
reply
And politicians associated with Chinese makers are clean as a whistle?

I've got no love for the cringe machine that is Elon, but c'mon. Would people really buy from a Chinese maker over Tesla based on some kind of political stance?

reply
That’s a good question that I can’t answer but for the sake of argument there’s plenty of other EV manufacturers in the European EV market at least.
reply
Personally? Absolutely!

The Chinese haven't been spending a lot of money to support right wing authoritarian governments in my country.

Buying Tesla does. So you don't have to be "clean as a whistle" to be a massive improvement.

reply
But they are heavily supporting Russia which is definitely spending money to support right wing authoritarian governments in you country.

Worse than Musk? Probably not. Better than Musk? Also probably no.

reply
Musk is also supporting Russia...
reply
At least regarding Denmark, Chinese leaders and EV CEOs haven't threatened to invade the country.
reply
Tibet.
reply
Sounds like we both agree that Tibet is not Denmark.
reply
Which is not Denmark…
reply
What a load of bs, people have the attention span of a fruit fly. Saw one clown put a sticker "I got it before Elon went crazy!" on their Tesla in Copenhagen, but that's about it. Danish are buying Teslas like there's no tomorrow.
reply
Danes are buying EVs as fast as they can before a possible tax increase next year, but preferring European and Chinese vehicles where possible.

If they can't get something else, they settle for a Tesla.

Tesla had a 0.8% share of EV sales in October 2026 in Denmark.

reply
> Tesla had a 0.8% share of EV sales in October 2026 in Denmark.

Is this figure really for EVs only? I don't find this article[0] absolutely clear, but in context it seems to be referring to Tesla's share of all passenger car sales:

> Norway remained a bright spot for Tesla. The carmaker recorded its best October on record and was the country's top-selling car brand with a 9.8% market share, according to OFV. Chinese brands continued to expand their footprint, accounting for 22.5% of new passenger car registrations, their highest monthly share on record.

> [irrelevant quote]

> By contrast, Tesla's market share in Denmark was only 0.73%, behind BYD (002594.SZ), Leapmotor (9863.HK), Xpeng (9868.HK), and SAIC-owned MG (600104.SS), which captured between 1.6% and 5.5% of the market each.

[0] https://www.reuters.com/business/tesla-registrations-surge-a...

reply
I think you're correct, but with EV sales at over 80% of car sales in Denmark it doesn't make much difference.
reply
Thanks, I hadn't realised the EV market was that big. You're of course right that the difference is therefore very small.
reply
It's super weird that the biggest names in EVs total up to 10-15% of market share, and also that EVs are 80% of auto sales. What am I missing?
reply
The Reuters article is comparing Tesla with Chinese vendors.

Not listed are all the European, Japanese and Korean cars. I see lots of new VW, Kia and BMW EVs in Copenhagen, far more than Tesla or Chinese, but I haven't searched for statistics.

reply
Out of all cars sold in Denmark in 2026, 5.9% have been Teslas.
reply
In October it was 0.8%, or 137 Teslas.

In September 2026 (the end of Q3), Tesla registered 2,299 cars in Denmark.

This is just because of Tesla’s ”delivery waves”. Also October 2025 Tesla’s sales in Denmark were low.

Cherry picking the weak months is very deceptive.

"Yet Tesla’s Danish registrations are up 47% to 10,126 for January through October, a 5.9% share, according to Mobility Denmark, showing why one month is not a good description of the yearly registrations."

https://evxl.co/2026/11/03/tesla-nordic-sales-jump-denmark-s...

reply
I've seen similar stickers on Teslas here in the USA.

I wouldn't have a Cybertruck because they look absolutely ridiculous but a regular Tesla looks like a pretty normal car.

There are probably a fair number of Danes who more or less agree with Elon's politics too.

reply
deleted
reply
I'm under the impression that even among the outliers that are people who buy new cars instead of used, most buy cars because they need to go places. How many of those are willing to shell out an extra 15k or so for something as vague as software quality?
reply
if you change software quality to just quality, toyota/honda will answer that question.

better quality car is higher priced.

reply
They aren't the same. The quality you get from Honda and Toyota is the kind that keeps you from being stranded, keeps you from paying costly repairs, and keeps your car running for hundreds of thousands of miles. Software quality in the cab barely moves the needle on actual value.
reply
Honestly, any of the major electric cars have abysmal UX. I don't want a massive screen. I want real buttons and knobs that I can operate without looking at them - like any sane person would engineer for a single operator craft.
reply
I have a Hyundai Ioniq 5. Its software quality is just fine, especially if it is enough to keep me out of a Tesla.
reply
There's very little difference between Tesla and BYD day to day. I'm also going to have Android Auto open virtually all the time so couldn't see any difference.
reply
I think Tesla doesn’t have Android Auto or Apple CarPlay. I have never driven one, but that’s what I read.
reply
Hahaha, I've been in Teslas many times (but not as a driver) and thought I'm seeing Android Auto. Which I guess proves my point.

I mean, for most people, you put Spotify/Audible on, switch to the map, go. There's a hard limit on how much things can change.

reply
Honest question: what do people need software quality for? What exactly are they doing with their cars that need all that in-car software? A phone attached to the center column offers a better software experience than any car maker could offer. Are people really paying that much to play games on their car screens?
reply
No. I own a tesla and what I value is the integrated dashcam and sentry mode. Next comes route planning (which is gmaps under the hood but on a larger screen so easier to see). Energy information so that I can check how much I used and when.
reply
> integrated dashcam and sentry mode.

Unfortunately, that footage does not stay on your computer/car.

https://www.drive.com.au/news/tesla-shared-private-camera-re...

reply
This is common in every major chinese EV manufacturer now, maybe apart from rock bottom cost tier.

I've sat in my friend's 600 HP Zeekr few months ago and saw all you mention in some form or another plus much, much more than in my colleague's tesla 3.

reply
For an EV, planning a longer route where a charging stop is needed.

Ideally that should work to your preference, for example a restaurant vs fast food nearby.

reply
We're in a transition, but in the near future you'll need you'll plan less and basically just stop when you need to.

The capital cost of an EV charging station is absurdly low (compared to say building a gas station) and returns are high value with zero effort.

In other words they're a high return profit center, which means that pretty much every place which is aimed at "passing long distance traffic" will get one at some point. We're already seeing this play out a bit, but in 10 years they'll literally be everywhere.

reply
Why would you want your EV to route plan? My cellphone does so in a convenient package.
reply
Integrated EV route planners do things that a phone can't, mostly battery related. They consider SoC, predicted consumption, charging stations along the way, etc. They also pre-condition the battery while approaching a charging station so that battery temperatures will be optimal for charging conditions. Of course, most of this only applies to long trips. If you have a charger at home and are running to the mall 15m away and back none of that matters.
reply
So a phone with an app that integrates with the vehicle rather than an outdated, slow, buggy, in-dash computer that may have functionality breaking updates pushed to it at any time then?
reply
That is if automaker supports Apple CarPlay/Android Auto. Tesla (and some other companies) does not.
reply
You attach a phone holder to the dash and use Google Maps. It's plenty visible.
reply
It’s more about having something that works well than a crazy feature set.
reply
I've navigated entire countries with my phone, using Google Maps.
reply
You could have used a bicycle too.
reply
Reductio ab absurdum?

I don't see what having a huge dash screen gains you unless you have eyesight problems.

Aren't Americans constantly harping on about liberty and convenience?

reply
I would never pay twice the price of the car for those, and tesla has made some properly stupid hostile UI decisions like moving turn lights into steering wheel.

Plus tesla is poisoned by nazi owner who is extremely hostile towards Europe for whatever reasons and feels like he needs to interfere in global politics, that brand is burned for good regardless of products. Something about having actual morals and spine and voting with wallet and not supporting evil actors if you don't have to.

reply
> An entry level Tesla is kind of a luxury car though.

It's a luxury *price*. It is not luxury *quality*.

They're pretty crappy cars for the price, lots of flimsy plastic and bling.

reply
“Luxury” is a market partitioning attribute, not really a quality attribute. There are many examples of horrible quality luxury cars, much worse than any Tesla.
reply
Could you name few?
reply
In terms of the vehicle being lipstick on a pig? some notoriously bad examples are Cadillac Cimarron, Aston Martin Cygnet, Lincoln Blackwood, Buick Terraza
reply
I had to look up what are these vehicles. Neither of these looks anything luxurious just like Tesla.
reply
Exactly. None of those vehicles were particularly nice, even by the standards of their time. That is my point, "luxury" is primarily a descriptor of how a vehicle is marketed.
reply
This is an outdated meme.
reply
It's not really a meme. Telsa are selling very expensive cars that are not all that good.

Why am I paying Mercedes prices to drive around in something that's not as good as a Dacia?

reply
> An entry level Tesla is kind of a luxury car though.

It absolutely is NOT a luxury car. There are a lot of people, especially early adopters, who have tried to act like it is in order to increase its cachet. I think that this point that game is up because they're no longer rare or limited, a Tesla is the most normal thing an Uber driver will pick you up in the airport in. Nearly everyone has been inside one, and it only takes one experience to realize its a plastic econoshitbox. There's nothing wrong with that, some of my most beloved vehicles have been my shitboxes I've taken on adventures. But let's just be real here, Tesla owners are no longer fooling anyone.

reply
You can buy an entry-level Tesla for $37K. That's not a luxury price. It has TCO comparable to a Corolla LE or Civic LX, while being in an entirely different class. Even their entry level vehicles have so many nice features that Tesla makes standard across their entire trim offering.
reply
Luxury is not a list of bullet points, it's a quality standard which is inclusive of quality of experience. I would rather have a Corolla over a Model 3.
reply
I don't know were you get this from about trucks, but electric trucks are already competitive today.

They cost a lot more in manufacturing but save money on the road. They can recuperate energy what an ICE can't do and for companies the investment into solar is just basic math.

They are also more practical than gas trucks in plenty of scenarios: they are more quiter and they can break quiter. They are more agile and its easier to have more power as a bigger engine is nearly free. As usual with EV and recupreation, you need bigger engine anyway to do this efficient.

At least in germany btw. you can only drive for 4 hours and have to take a break and there is a huge difference between short and long haul. Not everyone needs to switch yesterday.

reply
I have owned a Tesla for a year but have now switched back to petrol simply because of range. I’ve spent way too many hours at fast chargers. And this was in the Netherlands and Germany. US distances are typically much longer from what I understand.
reply
This sounds very strange to me. My Model 3 goes 550km on a single charge. I use the charger at home and charge it like my phone. I've used a fast charger twice in 3 years, only as a curiosity.

I'm guessing maybe your problem was that you live in an apartment which doesn't provide a parking space with electricity, so fast charge was only option? Definintely an issue, especially in some countries where the usual home isn't a standalone single story like Australia where I live.

reply
You should also realise you are the outlier. Most people travel far less than the range of their vehicles (petrol or EV).
reply
This does tie into a good point - EVs get surprisingly expensive if you charge away from home.

The price difference between home charging vs a fast charger can be extreme, 6-7p/unit vs 80-90p/unit.

reply
The UK price for electricity is ridiculous. I hired an EV last year for 4 weeks when I visited my parents, the cost was 2-3x what I pay in NZ charge stations. The total rental costs (inc fuel) still worked out the same as a petrol car and it was a cheaper way to get an automatic. Everybody I knew parked on the street so no easy way to get cheap power.
reply
I exclusively charge away from home since I don't own a wallbox. I also regularly drive from north Germany to Switzerland, in my model 3 Highland that means 2-3 charge stops. Which I would do anyway.

Usually I charge when I go grocery shopping. I can't remember the last time I drove to a charging station just to charge.

reply
[dead]
reply
Yes but this too is temporary. If you think how much cheaper it is to install a charging station than a gas station there is no reason competition will not drive down prices in the future.
reply
Except if you account for grid costs. You can (and the military practices) set up a gas station with a tanker truck, a hose and some dispensing pump anywhere. It takes grid connections (and capacity) to have a charging station.
reply
Lol the vision of a portable gas station is a funny one, but plausible. People have also set up portable superchargers using semis beside racing tracks.

In the long run I think electricity wins out. The grid is available nearly most places people will have their cars in the first place (along roads), barring the wilderness. The production and distribution chain for gas vs electricity is a funny one to think about. And the fact that it's non-renwable. Solar and wind are very clean and limitless sources of energy.

reply
That is highly regional. Where I live, many public chargers are cheaper than charging at home because residential rates are so high. On average, AC/L2 chargers are roughly the same cost. Even the most expensive fast chargers are more like 2x home rates, not 10x.
reply
Whle I obviously can't know exact GP's situation in particular, statistically speaking they are not necessarily an outlier, for the region they are from.

Typical Dutch driving pattern is strongly bimodal - a lot of everyday short trips (think commuting), plus several holiday trips per year - Austria, south of France, Italy, you name it. That would be the trips where "too many hours at fast chargers" would be a problem for me personally.

reply
There are a handful of lines in Europe where you drive your car onto a train and then drive off again when you reach the destination. However, you typically stay in or next to your vehicle, which is not enjoyable for a long trip like you describe.

Over here in the USA, there is one such train that goes from Washington DC to Florida - 1400km, the same driving distance as Amsterdam to Nice. Your car gets loaded onto special train cars and then you get into a normal passenger coach; they are coupled together and go. Passengers get all the amenities of a comfortable long-distance train.

This is what we need more of :)

reply
deleted
reply
The fact that most people only drive a few miles most of the time is true exactly like most people don't have house fires most of the time.

It's a true statement, they don't. Yet everyone, not just people with jobs and hobbies that cause fires, still needs smoke alarms and fire extinguishers and building codes that demand multiple exits from bedrooms etc.

This "outlier" argument that a lot of people think makes sense, doesn't. It's completely invalid. Most people could actually get by with a golf cart most of the time. Except no they can't, because most of the time isn't good enough.

reply
Your argument is funny to me because we don't have any regulations here for those things.

In my house there are no smoke alarms, or fire extinguishers, and all the bedrooms have a single exit. And I'd say we're pretty typical in this area.

Which is not to say those things wouldn't be a good idea, it's just that the attitude towards house fires may be more local than you assume.

reply
Many people think that until they have a fire.
reply
Many people think attitudes towards house fires are more local than you assume until they have a house fire?
reply
Out of interest how much range do you need?

BMW just launched an i3 with a 567 mile range. Is that enough?

Personally I think I’d be pretty happy with 300 to 400 miles.

Range will increase over time.

There’s still lots of efficiency improvements to be made like replacing the motor, differential and breaking systems with in-wheel combined brake/motor units.

We will get to a point where EV range is greater than on ICE cars.

reply
I want a cheap EV with a 100 mile range for local errands that I use for 80-90% of driving. Use far fewer batteries and make it cheap enough that it's a second car and it'll solve any concerns about range anxiety.
reply
so now everyone need two cars?
reply
> replacing the motor, differential and breaking systems with in-wheel combined brake/motor units.

There are a lot of drawbacks to this strategy btw. Unsprung weight gets a lot worse, and expensive high voltage parts become much more exposed to elements and shock loads. The benefits seem unlikely to outweigh the drawbacks for most applications.

reply
> Unsprung weight gets a lot worse

Not necessarily. Where it gets interesting are the prototypes with lower unsprung weight than the equivalent braking system.

They’re not there yet but it shows there’s definitely new avenues to explore.

reply
I don't own a car, never have, but for everybody I know who has an EV (in the Netherlands) this is not an issue at all. After you need a recharge people need a coffee break too, and 20 minutes fast charging is enough to get you there. Maybe you have different needs or don't take breaks from driving that much?
reply
I don’t know about Europe, but it’s quite typical in the US to drive for 1-1.5 hours for a regular commute. I drive to grad school 2-3 times a week for ~50 minutes typically for example, can easily be an hour on some days, no stops at all because that’s a relatively short distance. For longer journeys, we typically don’t stop except maybe every 2-3 hours. We would only stop for 20 minutes or more for a lunch break, not coffee, and once in the middle of a 5-8 hour road trip with smaller 5-10 minute stops sparsely placed.
reply
Then you would get plenty of range just starting with a full charge and plugging it in while you take your pit stops. I make a 3 hour drive, about the first hour is in dense traffic, once a week and I only have to stop to charge if the car is below ~90%.
reply
> I don’t know about Europe, but it’s quite typical in the US to drive for 1-1.5 hours for a regular commute.

The average in the US is 27 mins: https://www.census.gov/topics/employment/commuting/guidance/...

Longer commutes aren't uncommon, I wouldnt call them typical.

reply
When 1/6 of jobs are work-from-home and otherwise not uniformly distributed, the mean is a pretty bad statistic to use. 9.5% of Americans (up from the previous year) had a 60 minute plus commute (one way).

I wanted a median/quartile breakdown, but that seems harder to find.

reply
Per minute favors EVs in heavy traffic. The stats you want are average miles.

> In the 2022 National Household Travel Survey, home-based work trips by car, van, SUV or pickup average 14.4 miles one way, with a median of 8.9 miles.

https://truedrivingcost.com/articles/average-commute-distanc...

reply
No, I want time. Because the topic was not about battery life for EVs in a commuting situation but about the tendencies of Americans to feel comfortable driving for a prolonged period. A lengthy commute acclimating people to being in a car for a long time speaks to that.
reply
If you checked the link you would see that the commute time statistics exclude people who work from home. You would also see many links to some more broken down data you can work with.

Only 10% travel one hour one way or more.

reply
It’s not typical in the sense of the US average sure, but “typical” doesn’t necessarily imply anything about average, it can just as easily mean “normal”, “common”, “expected,” etc. Where I live, it’s quite common to hear about not only people driving long distances for work, train commutes are often about as long.
reply
I do 35,000km a year / more than twice the average in the U.K - and have used a fast charger 5 times this year.
reply
> US distances are typically much longer from what I understand.

Ehh that's complicated. They're much _much_ longer once you get out into the sticks. In the suburbs I imagine it varies. But in urban areas AFAIK they're fairly similar and as it happens those are the areas where you benefit from EVs the most while also being where people with highly paid jobs tend to be located.

reply
TCO in Europe for EV is beating ICE for a while now, that isn't the case in the US? Why not? Is it because Americans like big inefficient cars more, or is gasoline that much cheaper?
reply
US is bigger and we drive more, maybe twice as much more. The US is big and empty when you start looking beyond the major cities. The wealthy who want EVs got them, but the ICE vs EV crossover won't happen for a few more years without easy infra access.

Dunno about Europe, but EV chargers are not that common yet. You could drive a few hours and end up street parking or lot parking and there's no charger.

This gets tricky if you drive a long while and your destination doesn't have a charger, and then you have to return, and you haven't been able to have your car charging while you were at your destination. If that isn't reliably done, ICE cars make more sense unless you're rich enough to just have as many cars as you need, which a bunch of people aren't.

reply
Energy in general, whether gas or electricity, is cheaper in the US than in the EU. Gas is far cheaper thanks to much lower taxes. So energy costs are a lower percentage of TCO either way. But even with the recent price hikes, in the US (on average) it's cheaper to use gas than exclusively use fast chargers. Of course, home charging is significantly cheaper than either of those, but that means owning a garage.

The big difference is that public charging is more than 3x home charging in the US and (on average), less than 2x home charging in the EU. As the number of chargers goes up in the US eventually that will change. Why the US lags in charging infrastructure is a different question, but is probably because so many early adopters were able to charge at home.

reply
> Of course, home charging is significantly cheaper than either of those, but that means owning a garage.

It doesn’t mean this, but you do want to at least have your own driveway.

If you work near-ish to a city (so that your typical daily roundtrip is ~30mi or less) you can even get away with exclusively Level 1 charging. I did that for the first 40k miles on one of my EVs before we finally bought our own home where we could install a Level 2 charger. But the new home doesn’t have a garage either, just a driveway.

reply
Also larger distances, and everything laid out inefficiently with bad zoning. Basically motor-lobby ruined it for them.

Just bought a PHEV (Peugeot), and if you can charge at home it runs rounds around ICE cost-wise, eves with it being relatively power-hungry compared to some alternatives (but so comfortable and sleek). With public charging it is marginally cheaper than ICE, pricing of public charge points swallowed the price advantage, but I guess it is not free to build that infrastructure, so its okay I guess.

reply
Public charging is still significantly cheaper than gas where I live in the US, and Trump's war increased that difference considerably.
reply
Gas in the US is cheap and distances are far. Even with current "high" gas prices, it's still around €0.90/l.
reply
If EVs are "curiosity" in the US, it's dead. I think almost all the countries EVs have been successful are places that have lower population densities than the global average(not G7 or European average), including the US and not including China.
reply
> I think the main issue is that, at the low end, the total cost of ownership of an entry level Tesla or similar is rather high relative to something like a hybrid Corolla

Atlas Policy has the 2024 models within a few grand of each other at 7 years. It's not significant and the Tesla is a much nicer car. Hybrids are expensive to maintain.

reply
The US banned the import and sales of chinese EVs like BYD. Who knows what american roads would have looked like otherwise?

Only 16-20% of cars on the road in the "u"s are trucks, so not really relevant anyway.

reply
I'm pretty sure the Ford CEO owns a Chinese car
reply
Roughly yes:

https://finance.yahoo.com/sectors/technology/articles/didn-t...

But the rules may differ for those of us who are not major automotive CEO's.

reply
For sure and kinda understandable (i get - i just don’t get it, like the gun thing). But Toyota does sell different cars for different markets, why can’t they EVs for markets that want them. It took them 1.5 decades to make EV that’s finally competes with others makers.
reply
It means firing a lot of people (labor intensity of EV production is much lower) and Japanese automakers can't do that for a multitude of reasons. They are cooked, they will just go out of business. Fast.
reply
Germany is currently going through this transition. It will be interesting to see what happens.
reply
They are just failing, not transitioning. Old factories and brands closing down, new ones not appearing, people retiring or becoming jobless. Unions prevented transition.
reply
It's easy to be cynical about it but I don't see an easy path. Sure, you can choose to bury your head in the sand like the Japanese do and will likely pay a heavier price later.
reply
There is no politically possible choice. They will just fail. Some may transition to military production though.
reply
True, but not sure about doomed.

The trick China and Tesla is using is to recur parts by integrating multiple parts. This impacts repairability massively.

Consumers REALLY hate this.

reply
Same with US and European automakers. Guess they shouldn't have listened to all those oil lobbyists.
reply
Why does every auto maker need to be into EVs? It seems like Tesla and a handful or other products are the only EVs that make money.
reply
This is a bit like saying, back in the day, why does every camera manufacturer need to be into digital (vs film).

I realize that in some places the momentum behind EVs is not obvious since so few are sold. But the change is inevitable. Even if you think China is a weird case, the fact that Western Europe is now all-in in EVs should make it obvious that there is no turning back. It's not ideology but capitalism that's pushing this. Costs have come down and will continue to do so. All the European makers have many EV models now and the only thing holding them back a bit is the massive workforce that needs to reskill.

reply
No it’s not. Can you explain why an EV is a direct progression of car technology?

A digital camera is more convenient and cheaper to operate. An EV is less convenient for me and more expensive. If you live in Europe maybe it’s more convenient, but also appealing to those consumers views.

I actually can’t believe your still saying this when it’s clear the EV narrative is down after all the US companies tried it and Tesla interest is waning.

reply