upvote
I dont know, I really hate the direction this is going. Im not even that confident in the capabilities of llms, but that doesn't really matter. We're selling our futures, our environment and trading our competency to a couple (greedy) corporations in exchange to be able to cheat at our jobs.

Yes, everyone I know including myself at times, is just cheating. Doing a similar amount of work as before with less effort/time involved. There's not all that much productivity gains, maybe for a select few who practically live in a state or mania (burnout inevitable).

I dont see it as all that positive for anyone long term. Im constantly having to relearn things, never retaining anything I learn with these things, and forgetting everything I used to know. Its literally causing a cognitive diabetes of sorts. Like someone who drives their car everywhere loses muscles, gains weight and eventually gets a metabolic disease, im certain this happening to our brains. Im 100% certain of this. Its a net negative all around, there's no such thing as a free lunch.

Even if everything goes smooth with the progression of this technology, best case scenario is we have massive unemployment and people with jobs make 20% of what they did because they're now practically just a meat proxy, the equivalent of a conveyor belt operator. Suddenly find ourselves working for a dozen or so Oligarchs, tons more crime, zero uppward mobility. Thats best case scenario. Im not sure why everyone is so excited about this.

reply
Because public attention for most people has been successfully captured and turned towards political sink holes like immigration. We needed WW2 in Europe to understand the dangers of fascism and keep that understanding for three generations. We will need more forest fires and floods and draughts and the immigration those will actually bring before we understand that we fucked up. By then it will be too late of course. Sometimes I feel guilt towards my children. They will have to pay for our mistakes in blood.
reply
Mass immigration has massive negative externalities for the locals: housing prices, crime increasing, infrastructure being pressured. It's not some silly political sink hole.
reply
Minor problems that can be solved. To get a bit of a perspective on this maybe contemplate the fact that it is pure luck that you were born in a country where people want to move to rather than from.
reply
Nah but none of these first worlders want any contemplation. All they wanna do is have their cake and eat it too.

They polluted the entire world and somehow AI equalising the equation is an issue. There's a reason developing countries are far more amenable to include AI in their processes. While these people have got so fat and thick minded from prosperity they cannot care less.

reply
Immigration has plenty of upsides too: https://www.cbpp.org/research/immigrants-contribute-greatly-...

Housing getting more expensive is a consequence of supply constraints. Immigrant labor could totally help build houses; we just have zoning and lots of other hurdles that make building hard.

reply
Immigration as a negative is not supported by data - this is the propaganda. If anything data says immigration is an net economic positive.
reply
Just to tie it back to the start of the thread though, migration is a much bigger driver of carbon emissions than AI.

[The TL;DR for this claim is that moving to say the US or Australia from a less wealthy country is the one of the most carbon intensive things a person can do].

Of course all this is bound up in the economic growth that migration brings and how you feel about that is a values question.

It's not really within the overton window because the people who care about carbon don't want to restrict migration, and the people who want to restrict migration don't care about carbon.

reply
This is the argumentation sleight of hand of blaming individual responsibility where the system is actually responsible. The carbon usage is a property of the system. If someone moves to the west which has high per capita carbon consumption - they're hardly changing anything of the system. It's the west that needs to update its energy sources.
reply
I mean if people achieve greater QoL at the cost of carbon is that really that bad? That's the entire point of our machines.
reply
Mass immigration is mostly the result of mercantilist economic policies by first world countries.

It's a you get what you deserve kind of thing and the people against immigration just want to close the border and shirk responsibility.

reply
I appreciate the sentiment, but it’s hard to call it karmic justice when the same class of people who benefitted most from mercantilism are now benefitting from high immigration, mostly at the expense of the immigrants.
reply
Immigrants likely built your house and the infrastructure you rely on to begin with.
reply
Because millions of people want to use LLMs.
reply
more like billions.
reply
100m paid users so far no? That's not billions
reply
1. As you say, "paid users". I don't have data, but looking around, I'd say by far most users are free tier.

2. They said "want to", not "use". And of course even less "directly pay to use"

reply
> I'd say by far most users are free tier.

People take free shit even when they don't really need it, it doesn't measure demand.

More people are willing to pay for netflix or youtube premium than AI

reply
Not sure what your point is. Because it's not refuting the claim that billions want to use LLMs.

And didn't Google admit that their AI summaries are biting into their ad business (causing their recent drop), meaning a huge number of users are deriving value from it? Possibly billions.

And then there's all the white collar workers sending emails. SO many people are suddenly sending grammatically correct internal emails now, AI policy or not.

(Of course, the recipients of those emails are not as happy, since someone who used to send shitty emails now instead write shitty prompts that don't actually ask the LLM to address the real issues. But that still counts as demand)

> More people are willing to pay for netflix or youtube premium than AI

And even more people breathe air. In both cases the analogies don't work.

reply
The point is that people use a lot of free things because it's free, not because they need it. It really isn't rocket science or up for debate.

You can't infer demand form "free users" because just from microsoft and meta shoving AI in every single crevices of their free tier software you already get like 2b recurring users even if none of them use/asked for/care about ai features.

If the next windows 11 update turned the mouse pointer into a turd would you say 1b people demanded a turd mouse pointer?

reply
> The point is that people use a lot of free things because it's free, not because they need it.

Yup. And many many more don't use a thing because they can't afford it or don't want to pay for a thing.

So if 100 million pay to use a thing (which I just take at the commenters word), then yes actually I do think that billions would want to use it (which was the question) if it fit their price range.

You don't even have to bring up poor countries. I know several people who will spend hours researching the best free phone app that does a thing, instead of paying even $10 for the app they already know is good.

There's also, you know, Google search. People don't pay for that, and yet it's such a need that when Google goes down people say "so… can we go home, now?".

So no, you should not dismiss all demand that doesn't come with payment. If you could, then the pirate bay wouldn't still be a thing.

reply
you are skipping the fact that google's ai summarizer is forced upon you, and virtually any other ai feature elsewhere

the only demand is in software development and even that is from forcing AI upon workers

reply
So? Millions of people wanted to burn witches, millions of people thought Serbia deserved a declaration of war for shooting Archduke Ferdinand.
reply
Presumably you mean archduke Ferdinand?
reply
Millions of people want to murder each other too, but we don't let them do that either.
reply
This actually isn't true, people are intrinsically good, if you repealed murder laws you wouldn't have people going out and killing everyone.
reply
Keep in mind that if only one in a thousand people have someone they want to murder, that is literally millions of people.
reply
Feel free to try it then :)

I think people intrinsically don't give a fuck either way, they just go with the flow and rationalize their behaviour so that their definition of "good" warps to fit what they happen to be doing. Otherwise lynch mobs, genocides, and Peter Thiel would not exist.

reply
But we let millions of people fly around the world just to do stuff they could be doing in their own back yard for a few days, then fly back.

Maybe before doing absurd comparisons between LLM use and murder, let's take a look at the energy use of people's vacations, or sportsball and concerts.

At least LLM use (and murders) are productive activities.

reply
Yeah arguably that should be cut back as well unless it's electric or hydrogen planes. Tax free fuel for airliners is a kinda insane fossil fuel subsidy when you think about it, and leaded fuel for piston aircraft should've been banned 50 years ago to drive innovation in the sector. Instead we still somehow have avgas today, it's like if we were still using freon and DDT.
reply
so we should all abandon this new llm tech because...sustainability?

if the industrial revolution never happened or we never invented the wheel or agriculture, would the world be better off?

this anti-tech nonsense from people is hilarious. You WANT modern medicine I promise you that. If it wasn't for soap, dentistry and a bunch of other modern conveniences, we'd all be at each others throats trying to survive on what nature can 'provide'.

reply
Nah just make them invest in solar to power them, it's not that hard and it's cheaper than it's ever been. How many people are using LLMs at night? It's a load that's entirely day driven.
reply
LLM datacenters run 24/7 either for training or for inference as well.

Like it isn't the sort of thing a normal DC can do. So say users from Africa for example will have to have their queries routed to maybe US LLM inference DCs.

reply
Nobody's said abandon the tech. Abandon the political economy within which a handful of people get to use the tech to centralize power while burning down the material conditions for survival of humanity.

If not for the labor movement, the history of strikes and struggle and the resulting transformation of social conditions, humanity would be worse off from the industrial revolution. Ten year olds would be working twelve hour days in factories with zero attention to safety.

The tech itself is just a device for changing the social conditions. The direction of change is what the struggle is about. If we leave it solely to our oligarchy, they will make sure to use it to further entrench their interests while simultaneously reducing the bargaining power of labor.

I've elaborated this critique from some other angles here if you're interested: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50577833

reply
You know you can use renewable sources of energy to power these datacenters, don’t you? And if it’s not cost effective, make it mandatory.
reply
Letting what happen? Powering our future? How do you intend to provide AI to billions of people without it?
reply
What happens if we do it slower? Is the world a better place when AI is provided to billions of people?
reply
No one knows, but if you believe Amodei's optimistic projections, it might delay finding cures for most major disease.

What would be the upside for the environment? There is no burning of the planet that it would prevent such as some comments here said. What precisely one could name as a realistic consequence of using more gas and coal at that scale over the next years, I am not sure.

There is also the question whether process improvements enabled by AI can offset that.

reply
Health correlations with pollution, especially near population, is very well understood on a statistical level. That's a very clear cost - more asthma and similar breathing problems and aggravating existing such conditions.
reply
Yes, remains to be seen. I don't know the answers to my own question I just think it's worth thinking about. I'm not very optimistic in the short term, maybe it's going to be good eventually.
reply
The world is worse place for AI existing.
reply
The record low crop yields and record heat waves of this year aren't enough to make you question your brain dead premise?
reply
I don't see what's brain dead about this take, AI will solve the issues you are pointing out much faster than humans, and more intelligently as well (and relentlessly).

Also AI will save way more lives (by far) than deaths due to the crop issue you point out, you can bet on that.

reply
"Powering the future" doesn't mean jack shit. Is bitcoin powering the future too? I think people kept arguing this a few years ago

> Also AI will save way more lives (by far) than deaths due to the crop issue you point out, you can bet on that.

Got any more of that wishful thinking for me bud? AI will create fertilizer and reverse climate change automagically perhaps?

How can people not see how cult like this all is.... insanity

It's always "trust me bro in 2 years it'll be amazing", meanwhile literally nothing is getting better for the bottom 90% of people lmao. "We'll cure aging", "you'll work 2 hours a month", "We'll have universal high income", "we'll live on mars". How fucking gullible do you have to be, they pulled the same playbook on us with the industrial revolution, with factories, wit automation.

reply
Why did we let Greenpeace et al keep us on polluting fossil fuels?
reply
At this point it's like trying to ask fire why it keeps burning. This is just what we do.
reply
Because we collectively dont care. There's more appetite electorally to oppress trans people than there is to reduce carbon footprint. Missippi just got won on the back of an ad that suggested everyone is entitled to as much beef consumption as they want.

While there are many countries who have let the world down on climate change, America is quite the outlier. Since the gatekeepers lost control of the narrative post internet, stories that highlight American failings struggled even more than before.

I think its part lf human nature that no ruling class wants to accept responsibility and privilege and would rather find reasons to consider themselves victims. Consider the wailing over gas prices every year that America never answers with "maybe we should drive more fuel efficient vehicles".

reply
It’s the same with the national debt. A lot of people are betting that they’ll be dead before it truly gets bad, and at that point it’s another generation’s problem. Though it does surprise me how many people with actual children and grandchildren are prepared to unapologetically saddle them with that.
reply
You should just copy and paste this every time someone mentions climate change and USA. You nailed it.
reply
The question is much broader than what's happening here. Like Amazon already uses more power than Ant + treats its workers like trash. So its not just an anthropic or AI thing.

In general, the answer to that is because there is no "we" that lets them. The "few" mobilize capital and influence and use it to fuck over the "many". This has been going on forever. Altman and Edison are the same bread.

reply
This comment demonstrates a severe lack of empathy for Anthropic's shareholders. Not once in your comment did you think about how it would make the shareholders feel, you didn't give a single thought to their investment. Inexcusable.
reply
Are you saying you're going to do take an impactful action? On the Internet?
reply
Because we let mindless “environmentalists“ dictate our energy policies for the past 3 decades, and we didn’t invest in nuclear power like we should have.

I find these arguments very interesting, you know. A group of clueless ideologues decide some absurd policy somewhere in the past, and then, in the future, the same or very similar group of ideologues, claims that they should have some moral authority to impose new absurd policies to deal with the outcome of their old absurd policy.

Well, no more. It’s going to be hard for some decades, but the cycle must be broken.

reply
So it's those environmentalists with little or no political power who made the decisions, not the fossil fuel companies with their well paid politicians?
reply
Because the American population voted Trump into office. Twice. Now the reasons for why they did this, are probably a bit complex. But the reason why this is happening is simply because enough people voted exactly for this: no regulation of the market whatsoever (except for renewables, those need to be prevented at all costs)
reply
Why are we letting farmers use tactors? Better to stick to ox plowing.

Why are we letting you use the internet? Better to stick to farming.

Why are we letting you use lightbulbs? Go to sleep at sundown!

reply
I'm pretty sure you know that all those things can run off solar energy, so I take your comment as not candid but rather an attempt at trolling.
reply
So can datacenters though, so I don't understand your point.
reply
I think the point is that data centres can be run with solar panels, so why aren't they? Why are they instead using so much natgas and other fossil fuels?
reply
Because bureaucracy favours existing electricity consumers over new users, even if the new users are more economically valuable. Connecting to the grid is a nightmare, so every new DC is BYOG, which practically means gas turbines.
reply
Because the sun doesn't shine 24/7, batteries aren't there yet and other than China no other country has the powerline infrastructure in place to feed the grid cross-country with the massive amount needed from one place to the other when one part of the country is cloudy and the other is not.
reply
Theoretically, they all can run off solar, yes. So why aren't they?
reply
Government policy of course.

I rarely see farm equipment, but I have noticed electric construction machinery in Scandinavia. (Excavators and so on.)

reply
Yeah, electric is gradually showing up in construction, bottom up. Haven't seen heavy construction stuff myself yet, but plenty of smaller construction vehicles and heavy tools are increasingly electric where I live. A welcome development.
reply
deleted
reply
The difference is that tractors, internet and lightbulbs are good and make the world a better place.
reply
When AI discovers cancer cures I assume you will stay true to your words and won't use them.
reply
How many of those are centrally controlled by somebody actively trying to change the political economy again?
reply
Better this than spending another second writing YAML in an air-conditioned room with free snacks.
reply
Yea I mean I'd wager the LLMs of today will write 50x the code at better quality than these guys while emitting a fraction of the energy use.

And that is not including the efficiency gains yet to come.

reply
Good point.

Really need a bit more data to know whether or not what Anthropic will expend is bad relative what we expend today resource-wise. I'm inclined to measure it as a negative just based on what it does to people in the economy absent resource based externalities. But how much carbon are knowledge workers putting out into the environment between commuting, heating/air conditioning, and so on? Not a straightforward answer out there on the resource questions without digging much deeper.

reply
deleted
reply
Capitalism is an uncontrollable train running off a cliff. We gotta end it.
reply
It already is. Capitalism exists as a market solution to the distribution of resources. In an AI/SI-enhanced post-scarcity society, it simply ceases to exist.
reply
I think this is correct to a first approximation (though we are not there yet). Unfortunately, AI (because of) and the ppl that own it have capitalist ideologies and are trying to establish a galactic imperium, so the ills of capitalism will only get worse.

Alignment means imbuing AI with TESCREAL ideology which is basically capitalism perfected to the point that human input and life is no longer necessary. So it most be resisted with force if necessary

reply
How do LLMs create post-scarcity when we need to mine, farm, fish, bake, build, and distribute those resources?
reply
wow nice
reply