upvote
Just price greenhouse gas emissions (or fossil fuel extraction). These sort of weird hoops for new users to jump through fail to consider the possibility that some things are worth doing even if they increase net emissions. A price on emissions would move savings to the least valuable emitters, rather than the newest emitters.
reply
Republicans just took an all time shellacking because of energy prices. Carbon pricing is so far out of the realm of political possibility right now it barely makes sense to acknowledge
reply
Carbon tax proposals are usually designed to be revenue neutral.
reply
Try explaining that to voters
reply
The problem is then voters go turbo Nazi over gas prices
reply
deleted
reply
All that means is the price of generation is bid up, making it more costly for everybody else. For example, PSE in Washington State has a mandate to be 100% renewable in ~fifteen years. They recently got outbid for a solar plant in Oregon by a compute company (Amazon? can't remember off the top of my head).

So PSE's consumer rates are scheduled to go up 30% just in the next three years. It's not going to slow down if AI is bidding up every power plant. And in states without the mandate, it just makes keeping gas plants running more cost-effective, because power is fungible, so there's still a net increase in fossil fuel generation despite said mandate.

reply
Great idea, when will you run for office to get this bill passed?
reply
The builders of these datacenters will tell you that those two things are the same thing. If you don't let them build datacenters without any regulation, in the cheapest possible spot, with the dirtiest possible power, then you are in fact banning them.

This is pretty standard capitalist propaganda.

reply
Yes but anti-caps focus way too much on armchair analysis, the dont's and bans and forecasts of failure. They're not completely wrong, but to move the needle they need to propose actual solutions and get them to stick - even if incremental.
reply
You'd think people in the position to call the shots aren't all 3 year old kids.

- "But I don't want this toy here!"

- "It must go here, because over there is a big crocodile that will eat my toy."

- "Oh okay then..."

Seriously, your "standard capitalist propaganda" as stated is a 3-year-old argument. Any reasonable adult will just say "then don't build it".

reply
For which there would be all the money you could want, but why let morality come in the way of more profits
reply