upvote
That chart - for some reason - jumps from a low point in 2012 to another low point in 2020, ignoring the price fluctuations in the year between:

https://openelectricity.org.au/tracker/timeline?range=all&ta...

Excluding 2020, which I think we can all agree had unique circumstances, wholesale prices are at their lowest point in 10 years. I don't believe this is adjusting for inflation either.

reply
>jumps from a low point in 2012 to another low point in 2020

It sure does. I used the AER report and missed a few years in that hastily assembled graph... but the point was that last year the prices were double to triple what had been the normal baseline (around $50) that had held until about 2016, and had been trending up since. I didn't have 2026 data in that report, so it's nice to see 2026 has been an exception to that trend so far. But that gigantic 20% drop mid-year looks like the result of government intervention around the fears of a fuel crisis. I wouldn't expect that to hold, and the AER certainly isn't.

Now if you want to get into the spicier discussion topic of what drove that price instability (and hence higher prices), look at what energy source appears in 2016 and starts gaining traction, per your source. Growing solar from 0% to 3% within a year was enough to drive "price" up by 50% in that same year. Astounding, and it wasn't until 2020 / 2021 with massive economic disruption, that prices came down at all... and then immediately after that disruption, prices soared even higher.

reply
Unless you adjust for inflation, any comparison of prices across decades will be inherently deceptive.

If you graph prices in constant dollars, it looks... fine: https://chatgpt.com/share/6b02e01f-cf94-83ec-bc92-9599d588fc...

The price today is roughly the same as what it was in the year 2000 and has only ever been cheaper for short periods of time.

If trends continue, electricity will be at an all-time lowest cost within a year.

reply
Like I said, this year has been the anomaly, with every subsequent year since 2016 trending up. Adjusting for inflation certainly flattend the graph a lot! Thanks for sharing!
reply
That's providing an excellent incentive to time-shift usage. If you're too lazy to do it, then you pay more. If you're not, then you pay less. I can tell you in the Pacific Northwest of the USA, time shifting doesn't get me squat, I'm certainly not getting free hours and prices are just skyrocketing.
reply
Time shifting is definitely the rational course of action for now, and if everyone did that, it would level out the wholesale price... but it doesn't make up for a lack of investment in generation! It just kicks the can down the road a little (at great expense to every house that now needs a big battery), while still allowing massive wholesale price spikes which is what drives prices high on average.

Back to generation: In 20 years, Australia is producing about the same amount of power as it did 20 years ago. All those new renewables were simply replacing aging infrastructure. [0] And as the % of solar increases, so does the variability of day to day generation, not to mention the complete mis-match between peak solar hours and the non-solar hours when power is actually used.

[0] https://openelectricity.org.au/tracker/timeline?range=all&ta...

reply
We don't need as much power. Lighting uses 1/10-1/3 as much power. Insulation requirements have lowered space cooling needs. Other energy standards have lowered consumption of refrigeration, dishwashing, and clothes washing. (Edit: manufacturing has shifted to China...)

You don't need a battery to time shift. Program your A/C to run at full power during free hours. Get an all-in-one washer-dryer combo and set it to run then. Set the charge timer in your car to run then. That should be over 80% of your personal electrical load right there.

If solar is cheapest per kwh generation, then it makes sense it will continue to deploy until the fraction of free time exceeds the margin over gas. But as people take advantage of that margin, it won't grow and solar will continue to be the main source of new generation.

reply
>We don't need as much power

Residential use is flat, which means it has decreased per household given how the population has increased during that time. But that's not to say we wouldn't be using more at home if we had cheaper power. While manufacturing shrunk, mining increased... so it's kind of a wash. [0] Electricity is one of those goods where the cheaper it is, the more useful it is and the more economic activity it creates as a result. If the price of power continues to trend upwards, then demand is naturally going to be destroyed.

>If solar is cheapest per kwh generation

Wholesale energy prices were steady up until solar was introduced into the mix. Since then, prices have soared with high variance... exactly as people suspected an intermittent power source would cause [1]. On paper, solar might seem like a cheap source, but it produces at the time of day when there is no demand, and when you factor in the cost of shifting that generation to when it is actually needed, then it is not nearly as competitive. They have other major externalities, but it's hard to beat coal / gas as reliable base-load and peaking-load in a grid.

[0] https://i.imgur.com/J1evRYw.png https://www.energy.gov.au/publications/australian-energy-upd...

[1] https://openelectricity.org.au/tracker/timeline?range=all&ta...

reply
That aging infrastructure had to be replaced and prices were going to go up regardless because of it. Just lucky that adaptable people get cheap electricity.
reply