But at least we could stop the externalization of costs. Everyone (person or company) who causes environmental harm has to pay for the cost to society. Then, market forces will embed those costs into prices. People and companies would no longer have to be well-meaning and well-informed, because by picking the cheapest option, they would also be picking one with little negative impact on society.
Can we regulate this? Sure. But why regulate this specifically, especially when the public/consumers don't seem to care?
Because everyone will be affected, informed and uninformed alike? Also, it needs to be regulated specifically because consumers don't care.
It's really not that complicated. We need to course correct when the "free market" does the wrong thing with potentially catastrophic consequences.
I do want to see them using less power, or not being built at all frankly. But that claim seems a bit extreme.
I put this in a different thread I believe, but China burns enough coal to run 300+ 2-gigawatt factories. We have larger fish to fry when it comes to energy use, our focus on data centers specifically doesn't correlate with their percentage of the problem.
The original example was overfishing. Each fishing boat has little effect on the overall fish population. Regardless of what the others do, each one ends up with more money catching as many fish as it can. But when they all do that, then the fish population collapses, which is not the outcome any of them prefer.
When they cooperate instead by regulating how many fish each can catch, they can avoid population collapse and everybody's happy.
This is why we regulate things. In the other direction it's why we pay taxes for public goods. Solving these collective action problems is one of the main purposes of government.
If you're proposing there is no choice, who is compelling those using AI to use it, and why?
Probably an employer/educator. Or a desire to appear relevant to a future employer.
A lot of people love AI, but that's probably why those who feel compelled to use it.
Even with the employer example, short of indentured servitude the person is choosing to work for the company and is accepting the concession of having to use AI to work there.
Do you really not see the difference in choosing to work for a certain company and being required to pay taxes?
What DOESN’T work is expecting poor saps to walk into an Applebees and stroll up to some stranger at the bar and say “hey can you please not smoke in here?”
Sometimes I really wonder what crack y’all are smoking. Do we even live in the same world? This level of naivety is almost unbelievable. We know what it takes to get things done, why are we arguing for things we know don’t work?
Your imagination is limiting you in the smoking example. The choices aren't limited to government mandates or individual interventions at an Applebee's bar. For one thing, Applebee's could decide they no longer want to allow smoking inside and ban it themselves, likely due in part to a majority of customers disliking indoor smoking enough that they may dining there.
Ragnarok is upon us!
My argument wasn't that regulation should never be used to make meaningful gains in environmental damage.
My point was that throwing regulation at a single energy use in one area of a single industry is inefficient, won't make a meaningful impact on total energy use, and focuses regulator attention away from much larger change they could be making.
Attempts to regulate a junction of multiple politically hot topics in an industry with massive funding for lobbyists is just begging for years of no results. I'm arguing that there are plenty of lower hanging fruit that would both be easier to regulate, and that the change would both be faster and more impactful.
Because you seem to be making the argument simultaneously that they should and shouldn't
That question isn't interesting at all though. You're taking pushback on a specific topic of potential regulation, extending it to the extreme, and asking if I believe we should live in a world that I'd expect everyone would say is unrealistic and never going to happen.
My point in these comments is that regulating the percentage of renewable or solar energy used by data centers isn't a good use of regulation or regulators' time. AI data centers, solar energy, and human impact on the environment are all highly political topics today. That doesn't mean we shouldn't take up those topics, but we have to be targeted. Picking a fight with an industry that's stacked with well funded lobbyists to, at best, require them to use solar panels for some percentage of their energy use isn't going to make a meaningful enough impact to be worth the effort.
There are many other areas regulators could have a much easier time forcing change while also reducing non-renewable energy use more than the data center case. Focus there if we want regulation to help, don't pick the shiny topic debate only because its what people are talking about today.
And for what its worth, there's a big difference between should and ought. We ought not need regulation, because people ought not be assholes. But some are, and that's where should comes in as we have to make the tradeoffs between ideals and reality. Asking if we should have no regulation at all is asking whether I think we should let all the assholes we already know are here run amuck.
At best that leads elected officials with a choice between taking lobbying money today and potentially losing their next election.
Worth noting that your link isn't polling specific to sentiment of the relative allocation of energy sources used by data centers, its about support for data centers in general.
There are much bigger dish to fry if we want to regulate energy use down or require cleaner energy sources.
"Just regulate" as the OP comment is a flippant use of regulation targeting a specific use of energy in one area of a single industry. That's inefficient at best and won't make meaningful change.