Toyota did that for years with their window switch assembly. You saw the same design on a Corolla and a Lexus, but the Lexus would have a nicer finish.
I suspect the second scenario is the more likely, as the car makers have had long personal relationships with their suppliers and will prefer to work with them.
US manufacturing in the 1940s was very in tune with the multiple supplier method. Jeeps and Liberty ships still come up as examples for their broad production and interchangeable parts.
This happened because the economy was on war footing and the government commanded it. Same reason Packard was making Rolls-Royce Merlin engines.