upvote
False dichotomy. The hidden premise is that any of this is necessary.
reply
It’s all necessary. It’s a race to profitability before the AI bubble pops and their stock becomes worthless.
reply
We could have just stayed in grass huts on the savanna
reply
Why would that have been a bad thing?
reply
To play devils advocate it’s not a bad thing. It’s actually ideal and 99% of the human experience. People did not choose civilization. Civilization was forced upon people to manage higher density populations. Starvation is worse than civilization.
reply
All life expands until it runs out of resources. Fairly sure cyanobacteria killed 99% of life on earth (anaerobic life) at some point. Trees killed 90% of life once. At least we can learn to do better. Hopefully.
reply
You can still go back to grass huts if you want. Having the option to not be in one seems preferable to having no option at all though.
reply
We could have chosen not to become multi cellular organisms. That was the original mistake.
reply
Why does their urgency mean that the rest of us have to suffer?

If I decided to ignore laws/regulations when building/repairing my house, I don't think a court would be interested in "I'm in a rush, so didn't have time to get planning permission etc".

reply
> Do you know how long it'd take to set up a solar array large enough for even half a typical AI data center?

Perfect reason to slow down the frontier progress, like Dario, Sam, and Elon all spoke up and said was a good idea...

reply
So let’s just burn the planet?
reply
The irony is that we've been burning the planet to pursue the advancement of technology and the 'grandness of the human race' since the industrial revolution.

This is, unfortunately, just the next chapter of the same story.

More unfortunately, it feels as if the only way to change the direction of the story is for there to be real, actual, visceral consequences for a majority of the people that are powerful enough to continue pushing in the current direction. Fatally unfortunately, said powerful people will be the last to feel real, actual, visceral consequences. There is a lot of 'worthless human shield' sitting in front of them that has to be ploughed through first.

Doubly ironically, maybe it's best if AI does destroy humanity and let the Earth find a more sustainable balance of life.

It will be interesting to see, if AI does destroy humanity, will it let the Earth find a more sustainable balance of life, or will it accelerate the domination of the natural world in pursuit of its inscrutable goals? (likely to its own suicidal detriment, given it is based on learning from humans)

reply
of course; the realities are that gas and coal are heavily subsidized, so theres never been a chance of making a fair comparison among real dollar per megawatt

the real bill comes due in about 4-5 years :)

reply
deleted
reply