upvote
I think your point and the point you are replying to are consistent.

Your link takes a lot of the coal power CO2 that is generated in China and assigns it to the US where the products are consumed. The prior post argued that the US needs to stop importing products from China.

reply
Here's emissions per capita without reallocation by consumption: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/co-emissions-per-capita

It shows the same thing. US emits way more per capita than China.

reply
I stand corrected.
reply
Why cherry pick? Put Singapore in the check list.

If you care about CO2 per country, it's China. If you care about CO2 per person, there are many countries worse than the US.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/consumption-co2-per-capit...

reply
I picked those because those are what the original comment mentioned. I just don't think it's fair to point fingers at China just because they have a lot of people when other countries are more wasteful.
reply
>I just don't think it's fair to point fingers at China just because they have a lot of people

oh okay, why not?

population growth isn't just some random function.

brutal, maybe -- but unfair? Not sure.

reply
You could go by land area I suppose?
reply
US: ya but China pollutes more!

China: ya but the US are far more dirty per person they'll gain an advantage this way so we can't slow down (though they seem to be the ones building out the most renewable infrastructure)..

Canada: ya but both those guys are worse than us. We barely have any people!

India: well if nobody else even nice guy Canada is going to bother...

It's like nobody remembered the eye for an eye teaching.

reply
This isn't about punishment, it's about collective action to eliminate fossil fuel usage, and looking at individual consumption is the right way to look at it. You imagine the average Chinese person living in a cold climate can't heat their home, and wants to increase their heating usage by 200kg per year. Meanwhile the average person in the US uses 700kg for heating and also spends a few tons on flights and car travel every year.

It's not about "advantage" it's about asking the Chinese person to continue to freeze while the person in the US reduces their consumption by 200kg. So the Chinese person has 200kg worth of heating while the American has 500kg. But they should be equal assuming equal climate, is the thing.

reply
well American need more because they drive 2 ton ford car
reply
"The elves should take the ring" "No, the men should!" "No, the dwarfs should take it to Mordor"

The hobbit steps forward

"I won't. I won't take it. We hobbits are too small, we never got a ring of power. We have no involvement in this. It's simply not out responsibility!"

The men, elves and dwarfs, not humiliated, continued to argue.

reply
By that logic if you split China into ten countries with the same total emissions then they wouldn't matter any more right?
reply
deleted
reply
CO2 is not the worst effect from coal
reply
The climate doesn't care about per capita.
reply
Thought-terminating nonsense. All those people you call "capita", are real people with real lives and your suggestion in essence is to immiserate them. The climate does care about per capita when each of those people contributes to the development of green technology even in some indirect way.
reply
> All those people you call "capita", are real people with real lives and your suggestion in essence is to immiserate them.

You're putting a lot of bad faith words in my mouth I never said. If anything is "thought-terminating," it's that.

reply
You should know that the phrase you used implicates the beliefs I outlined, if you didn't already.

Also I offered a real counter-argument, that per-capita is in fact important. How is this thought-terminating?

reply
the climate does not care about per capita!
reply
Correct: the climate cares about absolute numbers. If we want to distribute an absolute reduction in carbon fairly across the world, we should equalize the per-capita emissions.
reply
Nobody cares about fairness; in order to convince larger nations to do anything , you need a large enough military and economic force backing the alternative.

I'd actually say that the US AND China have little-to-no responsibility to start a push towards cleaner energy because they benefit so strongly from the status quo. Those that don't have that benefit should be more incentivized to pushing their carbon output to zero, and pressuring both these entities with sanctions, trade wars, and military action wherever possible. Eco-terrorism should also be financed by these smaller entities targeting backers and companies of the larger ones.

reply
Fuck it. Let's just restart the game
reply
It also doesn't care about what countries people are arbitrarily grouped into. Per person emissions need to be reduced, and bigger countries have more people. You can't blame countries for having more people if their emissions for those people are lower than your own.
reply
sure i can. the important counts are the amount of plants and cars and so on.

the thing that needs to be turned off is coal and gas plants, not to mention gas and diesel cars and trucks

the people are irrelevant, and this is just excusing larger and growing populations to burn more.

i can blame them just fine for having more and replacing their coal plants with new coal plants

reply
This (climate) is a common problem. You of course can say "I want my yacht and my personal airplane and I do not care if 1M in another country use a coal plant only to have electricity to cook a meal". But I hope you can imagine how those 1M will consider you.

Solving a common problem can require finding a common solution, which would require some sort of agreement like "I will consume less, if you consume less and we can both survive decently".

Anyhow, at this point I find the discussion irrelevant as renewables are cheaper. Whoever wants to make it about "save the planet" or "they and not us are doing the damage" are indirectly helping the fossil fuel industry that wants this to be a "culture war" and not a discussion about "what is cheaper" (which they would loose).

reply
>the people are irrelevant

That’s where you lost the point. Earth doesn’t care if it gets hotter. The people do.

reply
Right. In that case China+US (which is strictly bigger than either) is the singular entity which needs to regulate.
reply
the climate doesn't care about china or europe or america either, so why are we apportioning blame to individual political entities in the first place? and why are you chiming in with this perspective after it's pointed out that, relative to its population, china is less polluting than america?
reply
> per capita

So? If I have a family 5 times the size of your family, my family is consuming more, negatively affecting those around me.

reply
Let's say there's your big family and five other families who all drive big trucks. The other families are all pointing at you saying you're the one who needs to fix things, not them, even though their collective emissions are higher.

It doesn't matter to the planet what arbitrary social construct you group people into, every family needs to put in the same work per person.

reply
> every family needs to put in the same work per person.

Why?

reply
Because the people are the ones who pollute, not abstract concepts like countries, states, families, etc.
reply
People's individual choices make zero dent in the overall environment, even if it affects local ecology.

Environmental issues have to be solved at a group-scale. Policy, market forces, technology innovation, etc.

To tell people they need to stop using plastic, not get something delivered next day, to not eat meat, and make it their personal responsibility simply does not solve things.

What's really off-putting (and likely hypocritical) is someone telling someone else they're failing morally on these matters.

reply
My point is that the groups are arbitrary. If you have a country with a billion people or ten countries with a hundred million people then the responsibility is exactly the same. Splitting a group into smaller ones doesn't make it not matter any more.

And of course personal choices matter, exactly for this reason. If a million people choose to be wasteful then it's not valid to claim "it's not MY massive car that's the problem".

reply
China chooses to manufacture disposable, low quality crap, and then ship it around the world. So casting them as better because of low emissions per capita is not holistic thinking.
reply
They manufacture it because people around the world buy it, it's not like they do it to hurt the environment like a Captain Planet villain.
reply
The ones to blame about the disposable crap are the ones that buy them anyhow. Which is mostly not China, so either way they seem to be "less to blame".

Or, by that logic, let's go to the source and blame only the fossil fuel producers ... wonder who produces more oil.

reply
If you are going to blame consumers as the ultimate drivers (e.g. in the case of goods manufactured by China) then you also have to blame them for the drive of other things like fossil fuels or AI data centers.

Otherwise it is just cherrypicking.

reply
Well obviously, if you burn the petrol in your car it's not the gas station's fault for selling it to you.
reply
The point I was trying to make is that it makes little sense to point to one type of link in the chain (material producer/energy user/product consumer), everybody gets something out of it.

Now, how essential for them is what do they get out of it - that's a different story. Buying one mobile phone per year is different to not having electricity to turn on the lights at night (exaggerated examples).

reply
And if you have a common last name, such as Smith or Johnson, people with your last name are consuming several orders of magnitude more than people whose last name is Zillman.

The environment doesn't care about arbitrary sorting of humans into sets. It just cares about totals, which is why unless you can make a good case that some people have some sort of natural or moral or divine right to consume or emit more than others the allocation has to start with per person.

reply
> It just cares about totals

Global greenhouse gas emissions have risen sharply over the past century, driven by industrial growth, expanding energy use, and population growth.

Select for US and China in this chart - https://ourworldindata.org/greenhouse-gas-emissions

What do you recommend?

reply
by doing nothing, most of western country birthrate is in decline anyway

would take a while for developing country but at the end of times, world population would decline and in translate to "reset"

reply
The problem of per capita has a very simple solution. Those with too high CO2 per capita need to have more children, and those with too low CO2 per capita need to have fewer children. That way it becomes more equal and thus more fair.

Should this be the new goal for COP32, or should it focus more on addressing global climate change and reducing the total global emissions? What is the metric that we actually care about?

It should be noted that older demographics have higher emissions rates than younger ones, so having more children is really an effective way to reduce per capita CO2 emissions. The emissions get spread out over larger population, and the new generation has less emissions than then the older generations.

reply
As soon as a metric becomes a target it ceases to be a good metric, obviously. The point of per capita emissions is looking at things like heating. If 1M people living in a cold climate in China use 1000 tons/year for heating, and 100k people living in a similar climate in the US also use 1000 tons/year for heating, expecting both countries to cut those emissions by 500 tons/year is likely suggesting that the Chinese should literally freeze to death.

Serious proposals need to take into account individual needs.

reply