upvote
> But major environmental groups, including the Sierra Club and National Wildlife Federation, have opposed the bill, arguing it will weaken environmental accountability.

> Many Democrats have also opposed the bill. They say it will worsen pollution by making it easier to greenlight oil and gas projects and energy-hungry data centers, while weakening protections for clean air and water.

reply
Sierra Club is against building infrastructure to distribute clean energy as well. Their opposition to this doesn't say what you want it to say
reply
The Sierra Club is not honest or trustworthy.

In 2020, they sued to stop a transmission line from bringing clean hydropower from Canada to Maine. In 2024, they sued the Maine government for not doing enough to combat climate change.

reply
Oh yeah, how dare they sue to stop a private company from cutting a large corridor through pristine wilderness (maine's only really durable resource) to take hydropower from the people Maine buys it from to.... Not Maine.

Also Mainers get nothing out of it.

That transmission line was absurd and stupid. Maine needs new generation, not more demand to the same international markets we buy our power from.

Maine hasn't done enough to combat climate change, which is a serious problem for our fishing industry, which is already suffering from the impact of climate change and may eventually have no jobs. The power line made 0 improvement to that.

CMP has been refusing to connect already built solar installations. Our power is expensive because of that.

reply
Is climate change an existential threat or not? Because if it's an existential threat I don't really see myself caring about a small amount of maine's pristine wilderness.
reply
It's become necessary to destroy the environment in order to save it.
reply
> to take hydropower from the people Maine buys it from to.... Not Maine.

Interesting attitude. Why should anyone in North America care about the effects of climate change if the worst effects are felt in... Not North America?

reply
> making it easier to greenlight oil and gas projects

Orthogonal problem that ought to solved separately.

It would be weird for anyone to argue that we do not need more energy faster and at lower prices.

Energy is foundational to civilization.

reply
No one disagrees that energy is foundational to civilization, but we have been thoroughly informed of the dangers of oil and gas consumption. This comes down to short term financial gains over long term environmental impacts, and AI companies are slated to consume unprecedented amounts of energy.
reply
Gas turbines are not more economical than solar and wind. It's infuriating that we're allowing them to be built, but as time goes on and more solar and wind join the grid these plants will be relegated to peaker work instead of running full-tilt.
reply
> Gas turbines are not more economical than solar and wind.

I would expect that companies would build the most economical power source that they could. If gas turbines are less economical, it seems strange that they are being built; there must be something more nuanced to that story (or companies that are building them see the economics differently somehow).

reply
"Companies are efficient" is a lie. They will make decisions which make no sense all the time for short term gains
reply
deleted
reply
There are issues other than cost, like speed and expediency. Solar and wind are far cheaper than gas and coal, but they take much longer and are harder to permit. Basically oil, gas and coal are favored by regulation and subsidy.
reply
Ummmmmm...

"Economical" has different meanings depending on whether your time horizon is the next quarter or the next century. It also depends on whether you just consider your own pockets or those of the whole humanity. A lot of stuff, like the entire fossil fuel industry, is economical as long as Someone Else pays conveniently pays your debts! In any case, "economical", whatever it means, is not what we need. Sustainable, including economically sustainable, is.

reply
> I would expect that companies would build the most economical power source that they could.

Please stop expecting this, or at least take the time to figure out whether your priors are justified or not, because it sure seems like the facts aren’t supporting your world view these days.

reply
I bet that in the US that manufacturing and installing a gas turbine is in order of magnitude less expensive than manufacturing and installing the equivalent solar capacity.
reply
There is no equivalent solar without at least overnight hours of batteries -- which are, yes, very expensive.
reply
Not true at all. You can order huge amounts of solar panels for the cost of a gas turbine with delivery in a few weeks, while you can't get delivery of turbines for several years [], but getting land and a permit is a different issue. You missed the real issue which is regulation. Meanwhile the likes of xAI data centers pollute with gay abandon.

[] https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/03/climate/jet-engines-ai-da... https://www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/how-jet-engines-are-...

reply
How are people still saying this? You can spin down the gas turbine when you have a lot of solar production.
reply
Why don’t they just build solar / wind / batteries if they’re so much more economical?
reply
Because current regulatory and administrative barriers prevent them from being built or connected to the grid.
reply
The point of life is to be healthy and happy. A substantial fraction of the energy we use actually has the opposite effect. We don't need more energy overall when we could use less with better life outcomes.
reply
More energy in the form of fossil fuel-based sources is not cheaper, no matter how low the immediate price. The long-term cost of continuing to increase greenhouse emissions are exponentially larger.
reply
It isn't lower on paper, either. BAAJA would unlock wind and solar projects moreso than any fossil fuel generation.
reply
It's pretty clear that across the board leadership at Google, Meta, Amazon, Anthropic, OpenAI, Microsoft and others don't believe this.
reply
Because the stock market does not incentivize longer term thinking.
reply
That's a strange complaint when two thirds of the companies on the list have share classes that make it so that the founders have absolute control over the company.
reply
Yeah, and it's pretty obvious the US is still quite primitive and has a lot of civilisation founding left to do.
reply
> Yeah, and it's pretty obvious the US is still quite primitive and has a lot of civilisation founding left to do.

Tell us more.

reply
It's important to point out that these Groups' claims are wrong.
reply
> The bill also makes data centers pay for the power they use

Data centers paid for power they use. It's amazing how far the data center conversation has drifted from reality.

Data centers, like all large scale grid-connected projects, are also assessed fees for the infrastructure costs they incur.

The debates have been around additional math beyond that where some people think that additional infrastructure buildouts should be billed even more to data centers, beyond what is assessed for their own connection. The argument was that utilities are sizing infrastructure projects based on projections of more data center growth and it's not popular to bill infrastructure growth to anyone but data centers right now.

reply
If datacenter demand drives up electricity, it is rational for citizens to want the costs put on the demand generators. Has someone drifted from reality for not wanting to champion economic suicide? Are they a crank if they're not out there with "Yes in my backyard" signs for datacenters?

Society has tools like taxes and laws to make sure those who can pay (datacenters and their backers) bear more of the burden.

https://fedscoop.com/democrats-letter-ai-data-centers-electr...

https://www.npr.org/2026/10/29/nx-s1-6022096/who-benefits-wh...

reply
They have to pay for the power they use? What a success. That bill must have teeth.
reply
do datacenters not pay for the power they use?

i'm not stupid, i know what you mean, but why say stuff this wrong way?

there are no new datacenters in San Francisco, yet my electricity rates have nearly doubled in six years. can we pass a law that says, my rates are frozen in 2019 too? it would benefit a lot more people.

the hard part isn't deciding, oh, use solar. the hard part is, reining in voters and tulipmanias. some voters like tulipmania, next week, we'll learn the hard way that "datacenter bad" isn't the win people think it is.

reply
Let's talk about solar.

Median days from application to permit issuance in San Diego is 0 days while it is 4 days in NYC. In San Francisco it takes 42 days!

Permitting is only part of the problem. Guess how long it takes from signing a contract to switching on your solar system? In Nevada it is just under 60 days while in California it is ~150 days. Texas isn't much better, at ~120 days.

Bureaucracy literally saps energy.

reply
there are a bajillion places around the world with no permitting. where are their big solar projects? i agree that permitting is a core issue, but how do you justify, "people can do whatever they want with their land" when you use it for solar, but not datacenters? everyone's income is someone else's expense, so it's not so simple, there's no objective or rationalist or effective whateverist or non-political answer to this problem. it's all political. the bureaucracy is a symptom of a popular political goal, and then when we look deeply into whatever technocratic, unenactable policies about energy, like "nuclear" or "solar" or whatever, we find it's still vibes at the bottom.
reply
The main goal of the permitting process seems to be raising costs and slowing projects down. If the permitting were focused around encouraging renewable energy projects and keeping things safe while hampering fossil fuels, I would be all about it.

Making it harder to build makes rent-seeking more profitable, so slowing things down is a goal unto itself. It's not just vibes - the vibes are how to obscure the goal.

reply
> there are a bajillion places around the world with no permitting. where are their big solar projects?

Here is a is map of the largest solar projects & locations: https://cleanview.co/power-projects/operating/solar-farms/us

reply
This is the US, the same place we just talked about
reply