upvote
Thats the weirdest video and title i have seen in a while.

Its not magic to use a different voltage system. Electrical engineerse capable of building a car can just do that.

It seems also that 48v + 12v was used already in the industry since 2010 and the real difference of tesla is 48v only and only in cybertruck which failed hard.

So its not a tehcnology genuies thing its again the old car makers not taking china serious enough to align faster and quicker. Probably because its just a lot easier to do it the old way until it either really hurts or until they are gone (see nokia and co).

I think these big car makers get run over by chinese companies because they don't see the car market as a commodity which it now becomes.

Companies like BMW can easily go to their suppliers and demand what they want. And BMW showed with the Neue Serie that they are very capable of building very good EVs.

Whatever the problem is, it snot a technical problem and if you look how many big car companies already use the same base etc.

reply
I’ve been in automotive for 20 years and it’s clear you haven’t.

I know you need to hate Musk, but calling the cyber truck a failure is a complete misunderstanding of “halo vehicles”. The cyber truck is immediately recognizable over any vehicle in the world, it was a resounding success in marketing and engineering around regulations that make every other vehicle extremely similar. Yes, I know how much it is disliked by some people.

GP is correct. If you want innovation it needs to be a multiple laboratory approach because other you are going to get only what Bosch or Vector or ZF or ContinentalTevis will give you drawn exactly by SAE one time and nothing more.

reply
The cyber truck started as a failure because Musk promised things which were just not true.

$40k vs. $60-70k 500 miles vs 300 miles 3.5k lbs vs 2.5k lbs payload

Clear failure.

Next their demonstration of the glas live: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udxR5rBq_Vg and don't tell me they were happy with the result. This wasn't a win it was overpromised and not a success.

Then the sales were not what they wanted and "U.S. Tesla Cybertruck sales have fallen sharply—dropping to 20,237 units in 2025 (down 48% from 38,965 in 2024"

Its not even allowed in Europe and it can't be driven in Europe with a normal license because its too heavy.

The cybertruck also had plenty of bad engineering decisions. The huge whiper makes it hard to get replacement. The stainless steel doesn't hold up and has to be glued on instead of being the chase itself which was one of the core ideas of it.

The Fiat Multipla is also easily recognizable.

But don't get me wrong, im european the cybertruck is way to big for were i live anyway and i care very little for this car. But for sure its a failure in every core metric relevant to having a sucessfull pick-up and iwas for sure not meant to just being a marketing stunt or a halo vehicle. It cost Tesla a lot of money to make and they are winding it down because the endproduct didn't fit the market.

Im for sure not in automotive, i only live in munich and have worked on projects with BMW and Mercedes.

If you work for BMW, BMW tells you what you can use and how it has to loo like. I don't think BMW gets told from Bosch or co but i can be wrong.

reply
It shouldn't be controversial to say that the Cybertruck is a commercial failure. Tesla leadership candidly admitted the Cybertruck's sales were over 50% below target.

The Cybertruck was an engineering marvel, introducing several groundbreaking features. It captured a ton of media and pop culture attention. This does not change the fact that production lines were vastly over provisioned for the eventual amount of units sold.

I don't doubt that the Cybertruck project pushed Tesla engineering forward substantially. So far I don't see any evidence it has translated to additional sales of its already popular models 3 and Y.

reply
The cybertruck vastly undersold all predictions and ended production after a few short years.

As a "halo vehicle," it was an embarrassment to the Tesla brand.

It's interesting that you've decided that their critique of the Cybertruck must be motivated by Musk hatred.

reply
True, but so far the only Tesla vehicle that uses 48v architecture was just discontinued. I hope Tesla launches a new passenger vehicle to take advantage of this soon.
reply
Cybercab is 48v and they claim they will be making a lot of them.
reply
If you believed Tesla's claims, there would be no reason for a Cybercab to even exist, because more than 10 years ago Elon was saying you'd be able to have your Model S join a fleet of autonomous rideshare vehicles while you sleep.
reply
Horrible AI slop video. Try this instead: https://electrek.co/2023/12/07/tesla-shares-48v-architecture...
reply
> It required a company that is largely their own supply chain to bypass the chicken versus egg problem.

If you're trying to say that Tesla did this, you'd be wrong. European and Korean car makers were already switching in models were it makes sense long before Tesla released its first 48v (the cyberyruck).

Tesla did release their whitepaper last year to accelerate the transition mainly in other American makers, we'll see if it helps.

reply
That happens for any widespread standard. It’s why we’re still running x86-64 all over the place and why most of the internet is still IPv4. It’s just how things work.
reply