upvote
> This just screams "we want to censor the views that X stopped censoring"

I tend to agree. It's further a bit insane that "businesses" are getting a say in the governance at all.

> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more

Yeah, the main thing we actually need is the elimination of bots and paid commenters. What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots. What makes twitter hell is the fact that it seems like 90% of the tweets come from bots.

reply
> What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots.

If that's even true (I agree there are no _obvious_ bots), I think this is mostly a function of HN being niche enough. Any social network that addresses a large enough part of society is a target for ads/manipulation. It just comes with the territory. IMO the right approach involves adding a cost to spam.

reply
Agreed, it's very frustrating that X enables the feature to see what country something is posted from (which accounts for at least 80% of bots), but does not enable you to filter your feed or view engagement / likes based on this same feature.

Of course VPNs exist but this would instantly solve so much of the bot problem.

reply
But HN is what it is because of moderation.

There’s 3 topics that are the horsemen of the apocalypse for online communities: Politics, Religion and meta commentary. Any community that allows these topics will have a higher moderation burden.

Conversely, communities for topics where posers find it hard to survive, have lower moderation burdens. Technical topics create higher barriers to entry, and end up with experience community members who can call out errors and referee discussions on merits and domain knowledge.

Required Community moderation level is primarily a function of barriers to entry.

On a separate note, I’ve found that putting this information out there, always riles someone or the other up. I have no idea why.

reply
>What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots.

The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing everyone he didn’t exist. Professional influence campaigns are so effective because no one targeted by those campaigns believes they’re being influenced.

reply
X is a garbage fire now, not sure why that is desirable.
reply
Humanity is a garbage fire, being exposed to the actual clash of ideas and cultures is much more desirable to me than a curated echo chamber of a narrow slice of permissable opinion (not coincidentally, also always the SAME slice on every other platform)
reply
> being exposed to the actual clash of ideas

That’s not what X is. It’s a clash of ideas pushed by folks with bigger bot armies. The calm down after Yandex’s datacenters were hit should give anyone arguing for the cacophony a pause.

Like, what was the last original idea of consequence that developed on X through discourse? Compare that with blogs or pamphlets or newspapers.

reply
That was debunked about a day after the story broke. The only thing that dropped was Yandex crawler activity.
reply
Oh whoops, good source?
reply
> calm down after Yandex’s datacenters were hit should give anyone arguing for the cacophony a pause.

This was fake / deceptive btw. There was no dip

reply
Happy to be exposed to a clash of culture and ideas.

Not happy being exposed to weaponised bot farms - note: not real people - cynically trying to engineer my beliefs by manipulating my emotions.

We've had more than a decade of experience of wannabe social engineers who claim to be for free speech, but are bitterly opposed in practice to truly organic political sentiment when it conflicts with their financial interests. (And their personal narcissism.)

reply
Sorry, that isn’t a defense of X, or a defense of anything.

Nor is Humanity a garbage fire.

Humanity had many better tools to manage discourse, and better discourse in the past.

Twitter did a pretty good job of creating a meeting place. I’ve been on Reddit during its hey day and I’ve seen national movements that coordinated untold millions, to achieve narrow technical policy goals.

I’ve lived and breathed the idea that free speech is the best tool for ideas to win, until the difference between idealism and the actual behavior of users landed on my doorstep.

I strongly recommend people volunteer to moderate wherever they can. It is easy to hold an opinion when you have no skin in the game and things are theoretical.

It’s a constant shame that trust and safety teams rarely engage on HN.

reply
There are no ideas or culture transmitted through X. Its algorithm just shows you shit posted by bots that enrages you.
reply
there is no clash of ideas and cultures on X, it's just rage bait, and people yelling at each other while having 0 intention of listening. X is just as much an ecochamber as any other social media.
reply
Sure but anarchy will not bring some sort of paradise, just like completely unregulated markets bring inevitably oligarchies and oligopolies/monopolies and not some happy long term balanced kumbaya. And where do you set boundaries is up to everybody's emotions.

Letting corporations milk dry anything good remaining in society is also less than desirable. And we know they do it simply because profit, and they will walk much further well into criminal behavior simply because profit.

Kids shouldn't read alone Mein kampf for example or racist xenophobic antisemitic etc things. Don't you agree? And that's regulation too.

reply
This seems laudable so long as you're never the subject or target of hate speech. Then you just kind of look in with a detached interest like it's a nature documentary.

But that falls apart if you are one of those and actually want to hang out there as part of a community. If you were sitting at a park with your friends while random strangers yell the most offensive thing they can think of at you or going to a bar while a klan meeting is the next table over you probably wouldn't be like, "it's so good that I'm part of a diverse marketplace of ideas."

So in the same way you curate your friend group to be people who don't talk about jews controlling the media or aren't painfully insufferable about the Avengers perpetuating patriarchal attitudes after going to see a movie it's nice to have social media where you can have that too.

reply
There are only three kinds of people on X now:

1. Those who don't have enough of a moral sense to want to avoid it like the plague.

2. Those whose desire for money outweighs their moral sense - their desire for exposure to an audience makes X hard to resist. This includes corporations. The New York Times would have to give up nearly 60 million followers to leave X, for example.

3. Those whose values are aligned with the far right, up to and including MAGA, neo-Nazis, and the final boss of that mindset, Musk.

Arguably the first category includes the other two.

reply
If your moral sense leads you to avoiding ideas you don't like, like the plague, I think you might work on refining that moral sense
reply
It's not about avoiding ideas. It's about not lending support to a platform that exists as a vehicle to promote ideas whose catastrophic consequences have been demonstrated over and over through history.

Besides, the ideas in question are difficult to avoid. No-one is starving for the latest rationalization for those ideas - and you won't find any good ones on X, anyway. If you want the intellectual background, read a book on the history or philosophies in question.

reply
Yeah, civil debate of ideas is what happens on X
reply
He didn't say anything like that, you've sarcastically responded to your own thoughts
reply
Sure
reply
Is it not of some value to know just how many people think like that? Opposing views being of interest and all that… apparently.
reply
deleted
reply
That doesn't require you to actually support the platform.
reply
Downvoted haha
reply
X is heavily moderated, just not how you'd like it.
reply
[flagged]
reply
I have to say to the downvoters I am an absolute bleeding heart leftist and I don’t know if I can disagree with this. I made an off-hand joke, pre-election, about a post wherein the user was horrified the Democrats would endorse Talarico. My gentle chiding was a variation on “no, not like that” when getting a Democrat of any kind elected in Texas should be a cause for celebration.

I got absolutely lambasted by that user as a DINO and by a couple of other accounts that smelled of bot farms.

That said, I fully support moderation of these tools. They theoretically exist to form communities. The fact grifters and trolls can ruin that is not freedom.

reply
> I fully support moderation of these tools.

Moderation should be something you yourself opt-in on the client side. The server should have no say in it and deliver the data as raw as possible.

The whole problem with modern social media is that you can't, since there is no unfiltered way to access them, most don't even allow you to see a plain old timeline, all you get is algorithmic click bait. Having account requirements that make the content inaccessible to read via the public Web is another huge issue.

reply
Did you get banned though? Sounds like no?
reply
A recent 404 Media article suggested that at least Bluesky matched reality, while on X people were convinced that memes about a gender-flipped Draco Malfoy were the key to winning the youth vote.

https://www.404media.co/republicans-learn-x-is-an-echo-chamb...

reply
> were convinced that memes about a gender-flipped Draco Malfoy were the key to winning the youth vote.

Are you an actual X user? Because people from both sides were instantly clowning on this, it was far from a consensus and the most popular posts were being meta / ironic

The article is very much giving this meme: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/jessica-chastain-at-the-compu...

reply
Wow that was a close one, you almost had to use it and make your own informed judgement!
reply
I don't think the jury is exactly hung up on whether BlueSky is a leftist space where right wing views are not welcome
reply
People that claim BlueSky is a leftist space would be shocked if they spend 10 minutes on Mastodon.
reply
I fully agree. "Strengthens democratic discourse" is no more than a euphemism for "we can political opinions with which we disagree."
reply
> This just screams "we want to censor the views that X stopped censoring"

> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more

As if X isn't full of its own dark patterns.

reply
> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more

Based on what? The self-styled free speechers took the reins of American social media and made a mess with it.

reply
Do you mean you now see more stuff you don't like?

Why would we need more censorship? Let them say anything they want.

reply
> Do you mean you now see more stuff you don't like?

I mean we’ve seen a global program of attempted (and failed) political mounted by these folks, using their social media power, that has cost lives and liberties.

> Let them say anything they want

I still believe in this. I don’t in them privately and selectively amplifying.

reply
[flagged]
reply