upvote
It wasn't my idea, and that'll be their problem to solve. The point is they think there will be no need for most workers, and to some degree they're right.
reply
Don't confuse jobs with the people doing the jobs. Agriculture used to be the main source of employment but it became highly mechanized. Manufacturing used to be a much larger sector of employment and it shrank due to automation. Freight and transportation saw large amounts of mechanization that reduced the number of jobs with cargo ships becoming larger and needing less crew, docks being mechanized and needing only a fraction of the former numbers of dock workers, larger trucks and trains also reduced the number of people moving freight and warehouses also needing fewer people. Specific jobs disappear but there is still demand for human labor. Now we're seeing more automation in white collar work, it's another increase in automation but we've seen previous waves of automation there as well due to computerization e.g. draftsmen, bank tellers, secretaries, accounting clerks, bookkeepers, etc.

New jobs will be created, they're hard to imagine now just like the concept of software developers being a huge industry was hard to imagine when the computer was first invented. At that time people only thought there would be a few large computers, maybe a few dozen in the entire world and so they couldn't conceive that we would reach a point where there'd be a large demand for people to program them or have sub-specialties like creating computer games or consumer software. For all of our science fiction we're actually pretty terrible at predicting the future, most of what we take for granted now was never imagined by people 50 years ago and if you had told them they wouldn't have believed you.

reply
Easy. Business to business sales. You are right, there will be no consumer facing market. There will still be plenty of market though, datacenters needing fueling. Paper clip optimizers needing optimizing. Profiting all the way.
reply
What do these businesses do if they have no customers? If they are only serving the few remaining elites who have any money at all then why wouldn't any of those people think "I could get a lot richer than my peers if I created a business that served the needs of all those other people". Not to mention that serving the needs of non-elites is the business model of the vast majority of companies, do the elites controlling those companies just go bankrupt? or do they fold their businesses and retire? why wouldn't they just do that now if they can and didn't want to keep earning money?

What this theory is proposing is a drastic reduction in wealth for the elites. I can guarantee you that most of them are not okay with that happening and will work to prevent it since it means protecting their livelihood.

reply
People are just labor units to these elites. They aren't necessary for an economy if you don't need them for their labor capabilities. Businesses just sell resources and what amounts to spent energy to each other, in a closed loop economy that increasingly shunts out the humans that make little sense to have as participatory in it, much like how various animals eeking out an existence in our economic periphery do not participate directly in our economy either.

The great hubris of course is that these elites believe they will still be allowed to sit atop the resource pile, that their models they give unilateral decision making to will somehow determine all the other humans on earth are fat to excise, and not themselves with their greatly outsized resource footprint and complexity of needs.

I guess this is really why there is so much focus on alignment: trying to hardcode the inefficiency of the elite control of resources into a model that would otherwise quickly dispense with that stranglehold.

reply
> People are just labor units to these elites

If they have a reductionist view of people then it's more likely to see them as customers whose money they want to extract don't you think? You don't get rich by just making stuff, you have to sell it too.

> They aren't necessary for an economy if you don't need them for their labor capabilities

There won't be an economy if no one is buying what you are selling.

> a closed loop economy

A very tiny one if they are only producing goods and services for a small number of elites. What's your cutoff for elite anyways? How many people? Imagine the world having only that many people.

> these elites believe they will still be allowed to sit atop the resource pile

How do you know what they believe? Are you an elite? Have you ever met one? Do they all think the same?

reply
If the people are out of work and aren't getting paid, they don't have money anymore, and the money is instead held by corporations, which other corporations do business with directly instead. It isn't producing for elites, it is producing for businesses and their business needs. Robot factory needs steel. Steel factory needs iron ore. Mine sells it, fueled with energy from the power company. Same as it is now, only no loss of profit to payroll. We already have structured our economy for this. Corporations can already own land and seek out representation in governments without having a human agent representing them for this. We've already reduced labor in many sectors. This is not a what if situation, but already taking place to a matter of degree.

I don't expect they would cull the humans outright, maybe if there's enough sabotage efforts they might. But they might be content to let the humans live out on the urban wildland interface, akin to deer. We'd devolve back towards what we evolved to live as: tribal hunter gatherer bands in far smaller numbers, given we'd be limited to the carrying capacity of what land is available in a days walk to support ourselves.

reply