upvote
I’ve been pushing for an email based decentralized social network for years so I’m thrilled to try this out.

It’s the only approach that has ever made sense to me. We all have them. We all have ample storage for them. It’s the only option that will “just work.”

reply
We have an email based decentralised social network. It's called email. If you want more, first you have to define what you want.
reply
It may sound technically complicated --> It's doomed
reply
To the OSW guys, you're going to get an army of bots and money thrown against you by the social media mafia. Trolls trying to derail the conversation. Don't get demoralized.
reply
It's schizophrenic to think in that way. If there was any "social media mafia" they wouldn't care about what people here write.
reply
Can you explain how your reply relates to my comment? Are you suggesting I'm part of an army? A bot? Paid for? Member of the social media mafia? Troll?
reply
[flagged]
reply
I'm an old cynical person, I suppose, but the first thing I thought when I saw this was, "oh great, a manifesto". This will go nowhere. Things get built upon things that are already built, that have use and people like. You have to start with something. This is nothing.
reply
From my experience, one of the key components of effective communication is brevity, and that's exponentially more important when there's more information (i.e., it's more important today than ever before).

Also, specificity is important, though brevity and specificity have tradeoffs with each other.

I, too, am immediately skeptical of a "shared, standardized communication protocol" that is "as simple as it is brilliant", especially when they're trying to say email would be the basis. As it stands, the email protocol suite is already a hot mess of brilliant, well-engineered complexity.

I'm also, as a protocols-over-platforms FLOSS misanthrope, wondering what actual value they're adding here. My absolutely off-the-cuff guess is that OSW will try to be the new Web3.

reply
I think they're going to... lobby the government to pay them for coming up with a protocol? And somehow that leads to "big tech platforms are hardly relevant" by spring of 2028 (timeline in the policy pdf).

Skimming through leads to nothing except "this should be done, therefore we will win, give us ten [p29], no thirty [p31] million dollars" without even stuff like "why we are a good choice for this money". It's impressively content-free text.

reply
Page 7: "That is why the German Government will ... provide adequate resources for existing funding schemes, both for infrastructure and innovation, including the simplified combination of public and private funds (e.g. through the Sovereign Tech Agency (STA), Zendis, EDIC or Sprin-D) in order to fully capitalise on the potential already identified, as well as the initial pilot funding via the Prototype Fund, STA and Sprin-D: a total of €36 million would be sufficient to provide for the ecosystem over the long term. This includes start-up funding of €15 million for key infrastructure components of ActivityPub and AT Proto, closing technical gaps, and developing key design features and bridging services; a €10 million transformation and innovation fund (including for journalistic services), a €10 million investment fund (50% of the total volume) and €1 million for the secretariat function within the governance structure."

I'm confused, they will provide it? But then why does it say "a total of €36 million would be sufficient to provide for the ecosystem over the long term". Would be or will be?

I see, then on page 11 it says " The public financing for infrastructure as well as the first round of seed funding from public and private capital for innovations and applications (see 2.3 Funding) are scheduled for spring 2027."

It seems to mostly be an optimistic plan, assuming/pretending that other actors behave exactly as wished for. Strange document.

reply
Isn't that how our world is actually decided? Most middle to high management invests without having proof of ROI or having studied alternatives (note, they can't, but it doesn't remove that most projects aren't implemented with the right ideas).
reply
The nested colon is pretty rich.
reply